Amanda: Kiké Hernández leading off the ninth with a tiebreaking homer. That was the sound of the Giants' season slipping away on Saturday night. But this Sunday? It was Andy Pages launching a three-run blast in the tenth, capping off a 5-1 loss that sealed a brutal 65-97 campaign. Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we don’t just watch the game—we break down every pitch, every play, and every power ranking.
Paul: I’m Paul. And if you’re a Giants fan, you’ve seen enough baseball to last a lifetime. We’re here to help you process it. Today is all about where San Francisco stands in the national hierarchy, looking at the 65-97 record, the fourth-place finish in the NL West, and what those numbers actually tell us about the future.
Amanda: That’s right. We are diving into the power rankings for the Giants. First, we’ll look at exactly where they sit in the division context and why that fourth-place finish matters more than you think. Then, we’ll tackle the big question marks in the bullpen and infield logjam. And finally, we’ll give you our realistic win projection for 2027, building on the 75-to-80 win target we’ve been discussing all week. Let’s get into it.
Paul: So, Amanda, let’s start with the hard truth. The Giants finished 65-97. Fourth in the NL West. On paper, that looks like a disaster. But when we talk about power rankings, we have to look at the context of the division. The Dodgers ended their season with their 100th victory, beating the Giants 5-1 in the final series. That gap isn’t just eight games; it’s a philosophical chasm in roster construction.
Amanda: Right. And we saw that in the final games. Alex Call hit an RBI double with two outs in the tenth, and then Pages added the three-run homer. The Dodgers were playing for legacy; the Giants were playing out the string. But how does 65-97 translate to a national power ranking? Is it purely about wins?
Paul: It’s not just wins. It’s trajectory. If you look at the rotation, you had Logan Webb anchoring things, but the supporting cast was young. You’ve got Yunior Marte, Miguel Mendez, Anthony Molina, Landen Roupp, and Matt Wilkinson spread across the starting rotation. In a power ranking, teams with deep, proven rotations rank higher because they can weather injuries. The Giants’ rotation was experimental by necessity.
Amanda: And the bullpen! That’s the other half of the equation. You listed Camilo Doval, Ryan Walker, Tristan Beck, JT Brubaker... that’s a lot of arms, but did they find consistency? Or was it chaos?
Paul: It was chaos. And I use that term carefully. When you have a relief corps featuring Duncan Davitt, Seth Lonsway, Jason Foley, Trent Harris, Sam Hentges, Joel Kuhnel, Cesar Perdomo, Braxton Roxby, Carson Seymour, and Dylan Smith, you’re dealing with depth issues. In power rankings, teams that rely on a single closer or have a clear innings-eating setup man rank higher. The Giants didn’t have that stability. They had a committee, and committees rarely win close games in October—though, let’s be honest, the Giants weren’t going anywhere near October this year.
Amanda: Exactly. So, in the grand scheme of MLB power rankings, where would you slot the Giants? Top ten? Middle of the pack? Bottom tier?
Paul: Bottom third. But with a caveat. They aren’t in the same boat as the teams that missed the playoffs due to bad luck. They’re in the rebuild boat. However, the presence of Jung Hoo Lee in right field and Willy Adames at shortstop gives them a core that pushes them above the absolute basement. They’re not rebuilding from scratch; they’re renovating. That distinction matters in power rankings.
Amanda: I love that distinction. Renovating vs. rebuilding. So, fourth in the NL West doesn’t mean they’re irrelevant. It means they’re in transition. Now, let’s move to Segment Two. We talked about the whole team, but what are the specific strengths and question marks? We mentioned the infield logjam earlier in the week. How does that impact their current standing?
Paul: The infield is fascinating because it’s a surplus problem, which is a good problem to have, but only if you manage it right. You have Willy Adames, Christian Koss, Osleivis Basabe, Nate Furman, Marcelo Mayer, Brett Harris, and Shay Whitcomb. That’s seven players for maybe three or four spots. In a power ranking, roster flexibility is key. Teams that can shift players around based on matchup data—platoon splits, defensive positioning—rank higher.
Amanda: Marcelo Mayer is a huge name there. He’s a top prospect. Does his presence boost the Giants' offensive potential in these rankings?
Paul: It boosts the ceiling. But the floor is determined by who is playing now. With Nate Furman and Osleivis Basabe also in the mix, the Giants had to make tough choices. In terms of strength, the outfield has promise. Jung Hoo Lee, Drew Gilbert, Grant McCray, Jonah Cox, Victor Bericoto, Bo Davidson. That’s a lot of speed and defense. If they can generate contact and avoid strikeouts, that outfield group is a strength.
Amanda: But the weakness? Clearly the pitching depth beyond Webb. And what about the catching situation? We had Drew Cavanaugh, Andrew Knizner, and Zachary Morgan. Did that unit hold up?
Paul: The catching was adequate, but not elite. Andrew Knizner brings experience, but when you’re losing 97 games, the catcher’s ability to frame pitches and manage the strike zone becomes less impactful on the standings. The real weakness was the lack of run support. Look at the final game: the Dodgers scored five runs. The Giants managed one. Offensively, they struggled to put pressure on opponents. Bryce Eldridge at DH is a power threat, but he needs protection. Who was protecting him?
Amanda: Turner Hill in left, Jonny Cox in center... it felt disjointed. And we can’t ignore the manager. Tony Vitello was ejected an MLB-leading seventh time this season. Arguing checked swings. That kind of energy... does it help or hurt a team in a power ranking?
Paul: It’s a double-edged sword. High emotion can galvanize a young club, but it also leads to ejections and lost managerial presence during critical moments. Vitello finishing his first season in the clubhouse after being ejected shows the volatility. In power rankings, teams with stable leadership often rank higher because they make better in-game adjustments. The Giants’ volatility might have cost them some close losses early in the season.
Amanda: Volatility. That’s the word. So, strengths: Young outfield speed, surplus infield talent, a frontline starter in Webb. Weaknesses: Bullpen inconsistency, lack of run support, managerial volatility. Got it. Now, Segment Three. This is the big one. The outlook. We’ve been predicting 75 to 80 wins for 2027. Is that still realistic given the 65-97 start?
Paul: It is. And here’s why. Sixty-five wins is often a fluke number for a team with this much underlying talent. If you take out the garbage time losses against the Dodgers and other playoff contenders, the competitiveness was there. The key is the offseason moves. We predicted back on October 3rd that the Giants would acquire a veteran starting pitcher. If they do that, you add stability to the rotation.
Amanda: And we also discussed Buster Posey’s role. His focus on cultural lessons, learning from the Pride cap controversy, creating a better environment. Does culture translate to wins?
Paul: Absolutely. Player development thrives in a positive environment. If Posey is fostering a culture where players feel safe to fail and grow, you see better performance from guys like Marshall Mayer and Jung Hoo Lee. Plus, if they sign that veteran starter, you suddenly have Webb and a vet giving five quality starts each. That’s 15 to 20 wins right there. Add in improved bullpen usage—maybe bringing in someone like Ryan Walker for high-leverage innings consistently—and you easily cross 75.
Amanda: So, our prediction holds: 75 to 80 wins. That puts them right back in the wildcard hunt. Not first place yet, but competitive. One last thing before we wrap up. The robot umpires. They flipped 54% of challenged calls this season. Catchers were far more successful than batters. How does that affect the Giants?
Paul: It helps teams with patient hitters. If the strike zone is automated and accurate, plate discipline becomes even more valuable. The Giants have young hitters who need to learn patience. If they adapt, they benefit. If they swing at bad pitches, they suffer. It’s another variable in the power ranking equation.
Amanda: Patient hitters. Accurate zones. We’re talking about a smarter, tougher Giants team in 2027. Before we go, I want to ask for your help. We keep this network free, daily, and ad-free because of you. No paywalls, no subscriptions. Just pure baseball analysis. If you value that, please chip in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps the mic on and the stats flowing.
Paul: Thank you for listening. From 65-97 to 75-80. The foundation is laid. The veterans are coming. And the fans are ready.
Amanda: Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline Podcast Network. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this episode with a fellow Giant. Go Giants!