Amanda: Kiké Hernández leads off the ninth with a tiebreaking homer, Andy Pages crushes a three-run shot in the tenth, and the Dodgers close out the season with their 100th win. The Giants are done. But before we pack it up for the winter, we’re ranking exactly where this team stands.
Paul: It was a long road to that final score. We’ve got the full breakdown of the NL West hierarchy, the roster construction questions Buster Posey is facing, and why Tony Vitello’s ejection record might be the most telling stat of all.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and I’m joined by Paul. Today is October 1st, 2026, and we are doing our annual Power Rankings episode for the San Francisco Giants. If you missed yesterday’s mailbag on Marcelo Mayer, you need to go back and listen to that, because today we’re zooming out to look at the big picture.
Paul: Right. And as we said yesterday, the injury woes were real, but the losses were also just losses. We finished 65-97. Fourth in the NL West. It’s a tough pill to swallow for a fanbase that expects more.
Amanda: So here is what we are covering today. First, we’re putting the Giants in their place in the divisional standings. Second, we’re breaking down the actual strengths and question marks of this roster, looking at Logan Webb, Camilo Doval, and those young infielders. And third, we’re giving you a realistic outlook and win projection for next year.
Paul: And we have to talk about the culture shift. Buster Posey wants the team to learn from the Pride Night cap controversy. That’s huge. It sets the tone for how this organization operates going forward.
Amanda: Let’s dive into Segment One: Where do the Giants rank in the NL West? Because 65-97 isn’t just a number, it’s a statement. Compared to the Dodgers’ 100 wins, the gap is massive.
Paul: It’s an entire division. Los Angeles finished first with 98-62. Even if you take away the 100th win against us, they were dominant. The Giants are firmly in fourth place. There’s no debate there.
Amanda: But what about the teams above them? Did we see any movement from the other clubs that makes this feel worse?
Paul: Well, remember Yordan Alvarez winning the batting title for Houston? And Gabriel Moreno taking it for Arizona? Those teams are competitive. The Giants aren’t just behind LA; they’re trailing the rest of the West in terms of offensive firepower.
Amanda: And let’s not forget Jacob Misiorowski leading the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average for Milwaukee. The competition is stiff. Finishing fourth feels accurate.
Paul: It does. And when you look at the ABS challenge system tracker, which ranks batters, catchers, and umpires, the Giants weren’t at the top of any category that matters for playoff contention. This was a rebuilding year, clearly.
Amanda: But here’s the thing, Paul. Rebuilding doesn’t mean you don’t fight. We saw that in the final series against the Dodgers. Kiké Hernández hit that tiebreaker, Betts homered, and we lost 4-3 on Saturday. Then Sunday ended 5-1. It’s hard to watch.
Paul: It is. But Alex Call’s RBI double with two outs in the tenth, and Pages’ three-run homer... those are the moments that define the opponent. For us, it was a reminder of how far we have to go. Fourth place is where we sit.
Amanda: So, fourth in the West. No playoffs. Now, let’s look at the roster itself. What actually worked this year?
Amanda: Segment Two: Strengths and Question Marks. Let’s start with the pitching. We talked about Matt Wilkinson earlier this week, but let’s look at the whole staff.
Paul: Logan Webb remains the anchor. He’s your ace. But beyond him, the rotation was thin. You had Yunior Marte, Miguel Mendez, Anthony Molina, Landen Roupp, and Matt Wilkinson. It’s a lot of innings spread across guys who are still figuring things out.
Amanda: And the bullpen? We have Camilo Doval, Tristan Beck, JT Brubaker, Duncan Davitt, Jason Foley, Trent Harris, Sam Hentges, Joel Kuhnel, Seth Lonsway, Cesar Perdomo, Braxton Roxby, Reiver Sanmartin, Carson Seymour, Dylan Smith, Ryan Walker. That is a deep list.
Paul: It is deep, but depth isn’t stability. As we predicted yesterday, significant turnover is expected outside of Camilo Doval. Doval is the guy. Everyone else is either a project or a reliever looking for a new home.
Amanda: So Doval is the strength. What about offense? Jung Hoo Lee in right field, Bryce Eldridge at DH, Willy Adames at shortstop.
Paul: Adames provides some power from the left side of the infield. Lee has speed and contact ability. But we need more middle-of-the-order power. That was our prediction last week too. We need someone to hit behind Lee and Adames.
Amanda: And the rookies? Marcelo Mayer at second base. Nate Furman. Osleivis Basabe. Brett Harris at third. Shay Whitcomb.
Paul: Marcelo Mayer is the centerpiece. He’s young, he’s talented, but he’s still developing. The middle infield is a strength of the future, not necessarily the present. Same with the outfield—Jonah Cox, Drew Gilbert, Grant McCray, Victor Bericoto, Turner Hill, Bo Davidson. Lots of names, lots of potential, but no established stars yet.
Amanda: So, the strength is the foundation. The question mark is whether that foundation can hold up in the major leagues. And then there’s the managerial aspect. Tony Vitello was ejected seven times. An MLB-leading seventh time.
Paul: Seven ejections. In his first season. Arguing about checked swings, arguing calls... it’s chaotic. It shows passion, but it also shows a lack of discipline. Does that help or hurt the young players? That’s the question.
Amanda: It’s definitely a talking point. And speaking of talking points, Buster Posey’s comments on the Pride Night controversy. Several players added Bible verses to their caps, and Posey said the team must learn from its handling of it.
Paul: That’s a cultural reset. Posey is stepping in to say, 'We need to get this right.' It’s about respect, inclusivity, and leadership. It sets a standard for the clubhouse that goes beyond baseball.
Amanda: Before we move to our final segment, I want to ask you directly. This show is free every day, and it’s made possible by listeners like you. If you’ve enjoyed our breakdowns of the Giants’ roster and the deeper tactical takes, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps the analysis sharp and the coverage daily. Thank you for being part of the network.
Amanda: Segment Three: Realistic Outlook and Win Projection. So, 65 wins this year. What do we think for 2027?
Paul: I’m not going to say 90 wins. Not yet. The rotation needs help. We predicted the front office would prioritize acquiring a veteran starting pitcher in the offseason. If they do that, and if Logan Webb stays healthy, we could see a jump.
Amanda: What’s your number, Paul?
Paul: I’ll say 75 to 80 wins. That’s a solid step forward. It gets you into the conversation in the West, even if you’re not quite ready for the playoffs yet.
Amanda: I agree. And it hinges on that veteran pitcher. Plus, we need that middle-of-the-order power hitter. Someone to drive in runs for Jung Hoo Lee and Willy Adames.
Paul: Exactly. And the bullpen needs to stabilize. If Camilo Doval is the only reliable arm, that’s risky. They need to add at least one or two proven relievers.
Amanda: So, 75-80 wins. A veteran starter. A power bat. And Tony Vitello learns to control his temper—or maybe he’s gone? Just kidding. Probably not.
Paul: We’ll see. But the priority is clear. Build around Webb, Mayer, and Lee. Add experience elsewhere. And fix the culture.
Amanda: Alright, Paul. We’ve ranked the team, analyzed the roster, and projected the future. What’s the takeaway for the fans?
Paul: The foundation is there. It’s not pretty yet, but it’s real. Marcelo Mayer is the future. Logan Webb is the present. And Buster Posey is building something sustainable.
Amanda: Love it. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Giant fan. Let’s keep the conversation going.
Paul: Up the Giants.
Amanda: Up the Giants!