Giants Mailbag: Vitello's Ejections, Rookie Battles & What's Next

San Francisco Giants · 2026-09-29 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: It’s a hard pill to swallow, but we’re diving straight into the wreckage of a season that ended with a whimper rather than a bang. The Giants are done. 65 and 97. Fourth in the NL West. But before you turn off this podcast, let me tell you why looking at the roster right now might be the most exciting thing for a Giants fan all year.

Paul: I know, Amanda. It feels like the end of the world. But if you look past the losses to the Dodgers, past Tony Vitello’s seventh ejection, and past the injuries to Adames and Brubaker, there is actually a lot of raw talent waiting in the wings. We have so much to unpack today.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we bring you the daily pulse of your favorite teams. I’m Amanda, joined by my analyst partner Paul. We are live from the Bay Area, or at least, as close as we can get while mourning a 65-97 campaign. If you’re new here, you’re in the right place for unfiltered, honest baseball talk.

Paul: That’s right. And today is special because it’s our mailbag episode. We’ve got questions coming in from across the country about the future of this franchise, the pitching staff, and exactly what went wrong in those final series against Los Angeles.

Amanda: Here is what we are covering today. First, we’re tackling the big questions about manager Tony Vitello and his record-breaking number of ejections. Second, we’ll dive deep into the infield depth chart and who actually gets to play next year. And third, we’re doing a lightning round of hypotheticals and quick takes to wrap things up.

Paul: Before we get to the questions, I want to take a quick second to talk about how we do this. This show is free. There are no ads, no paywall, nothing in between us and you. That sustainability only works because listeners like you chip in to keep the lights on.

Amanda: Exactly. If you love hearing real talk about the Giants without any commercial interruptions, please consider supporting us directly. Just check out the link in the episode description. It helps us keep this daily, ad-free content going for every single fan out there. Thank you for being part of the family.

Paul: With that said, let’s get into the mailbag. The first question comes from Marcus in Denver, and he asks something that has been on everyone’s mind. 'Paul, Tony Vitello was ejected for the seventh time this season, an MLB-leading mark. Is this lack of control a reflection of his coaching ability, or just his personality?'

Amanda: Oh, Marcus, you hit the nail on the head. It was Sunday. The Giants lost 5-1 to the Dodgers, and Vitello got booted for arguing a checked swing call. Seventh ejection. That’s insane. Paul, what’s your read on this? Is it just him losing his cool, or is there more to it?

Paul: It’s a mix of both, Amanda. When you look at the tactical side, Vitello is clearly frustrated with the officiating standards, especially regarding called strikes and checked swings which are notoriously subjective. But leading the league in ejections isn’t just a personality quirk; it disrupts the team’s focus. You can’t build a culture of discipline when your manager is constantly in the dugout arguing calls instead of managing the bullpen.

Amanda: Right. And think about the timing. It happened in the final game of the season against the Dodgers. They had already secured their division title, but the intensity was still high. Kiké Hernández had homered earlier, Andy Pages crushed a three-run shot in the tenth, and suddenly Vitello is gone. It feels like a loss of composure at the worst possible moment.

Paul: Exactly. And remember, we talked about this back on September 26th when we previewed these series. We discussed the strategic challenges of facing the league’s top team. The Giants were outmatched. Willy Adames was injured, JT Brubaker was out. The pressure was immense. Vitello’s ejections suggest he couldn’t handle the emotional weight of watching his young team get dismantled game after game.

Amanda: So, does this mean he’s not the guy long-term? The front office needs to decide soon. We predicted in our last episode that they might prioritize a veteran starter, but maybe they need a more stable voice in the dugout too. What do you think, Paul? Is Vitello coachable enough to fix this?

Paul: It’s tough. He’s passionate, which you want in a leader, but seven ejections is a systemic issue. If he can’t regulate his emotions in front of the players, how can he expect them to regulate theirs in tight games? I think the organization will give him some space over the offseason, but if this carries into spring training, it’s a major red flag.

Amanda: Ouch. Okay, let’s move to the next question. This one is from '@SFFanatic44', and they ask: 'The bullpen has a ton of arms—Camilo Doval, Tristan Beck, Duncan Davitt, Jason Foley—but who actually stays? With the season over, who do you see getting the majority of innings next year?'

Paul: Great question. The bullpen is a mystery box right now. You have Camilo Doval as the closer, obviously. He’s the ace of the relief corps. Then you’ve got guys like Tristan Beck and Duncan Davitt who have shown flashes. But Jason Foley and Sam Hentges are also on the roster. It’s going to come down to who shows the best stuff in winter ball and spring training.

Amanda: I feel like Doval is the only sure thing. Everyone else is a gamble. Remember, we saw Matt Wilkinson pitch well in those final starts, but he’s a starter. For the bullpen, I worry about consistency. If Doval struggles, who steps up? Seth Lonsway? Joel Kuhnel? It’s a crowded logjam.

Paul: Agreed. The depth is there, but the quality is questionable. Unless someone like Landen Roupp or Matt Wilkinson can transition to long relief, the starters won’t help the bullpen situation. I think Foley and Doval are the anchors, but the rest of the group will likely see significant turnover in the offseason.

Amanda: Let’s shift gears to the infield. A listener named Sarah from Rochester writes in: 'We have Osleivis Basabe and Marcelo Mayer at second base, and Brett Harris and Shay Whitcomb at third. Who is winning those jobs? Are any of these kids ready for the majors right away?'

Paul: This is the exciting part, Amanda. The prospect pool is actually quite strong here. Marcelo Mayer is a elite defender at second. Even if his bat isn’t fully developed yet, his glove gives him a path to playing time. Basabe provides versatility. At third, Brett Harris has power, but Shay Whitcomb is more polished defensively.

Amanda: Right. And don’t forget Christian Koss at shortstop. He’s a solid option there. So we have Basabe/Mayer at second, Koss at short, and Harris/Whitcomb at third. It’s a young, athletic infield. But are they ready for the grind of a full MLB season? Paul, be honest.

Paul: Honest answer? Maybe not all of them. Mayer and Koss could start. Harris might need more time in AAA to refine his plate discipline. The Giants need to be careful not to rush them. They’ve already dealt with injuries to Adames and Brubaker. Adding more injuries because young players weren’t ready would be catastrophic.

Amanda: That’s a fair point. We predicted last week that they needed a middle-of-the-order power hitter. Maybe they should use that money to support these kids rather than forcing them into roles they aren’t ready for. But the potential is there. Mayer at second looks really good on paper.

Paul: Absolutely. And look at the catchers. Drew Cavanaugh and Andrew Knizner. They need to provide leadership for this young battery. If the infield is green, the catching staff needs to be experienced. It’s a balancing act that the front office has to manage carefully.

Amanda: Okay, let’s get to the outfield. Jonny Cox, Grant McCray, Drew Gilbert. It’s wide open. Who stands out? And while we’re at it, let’s address the elephant in the room. The Dodgers swept us. Andy Pages hit a homer, Alex Call had an RBI double. How do we bounce back from that humiliation?

Paul: You don’t dwell on the humiliation. You look at the data. The Giants scored five runs total in those final two games against LA. That’s not a pitching problem; that’s an offensive problem. We need production from the top of the order. Cox and McCray showed some spark, but they need to be consistent. Gilbert is still developing.

Amanda: Alright, it’s time for our lightning round! Quick hits. First question: If you could trade one current Giant for a guaranteed All-Star, who goes? Paul, go.

Paul: I’d trade nobody from the current roster because none of them are All-Stars yet. But if I had to pick someone to flip for impact, I’d look at trading a rental arm or a veteran reliever for a proven hitter. We need that middle-of-the-order power we talked about yesterday.

Amanda: Fair enough. My turn. Who is the biggest surprise of the 2026 season for the Giants? Not the losses, but a bright spot.

Paul: Matt Wilkinson. Despite the losses, his performance was solid. He held the Dodgers’ lineup in check multiple times. It’s easy to forget his work when the team loses, but he was a bright spot in a dark season.

Amanda: I agree. Wilkinson deserves more credit. Okay, final hypothetical. If the Giants win the World Series next year, who is holding the trophy? Give me one name.

Paul: Marcelo Mayer. He’s the face of the franchise moving forward. Young, talented, and ready to lead.

Amanda: There you have it. Mayer with the hardware. A lot to chew on today, folks. From Tony Vitello’s ejections to the future of the infield, we’ve covered it all. The Giants may have finished 65-97, but the foundation is being laid right now.

Paul: Yes. It’s a rebuilding year, but a promising one. Keep listening, keep analyzing, and keep believing. The best is yet to come for San Francisco.

Amanda: If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share it with a friend who needs some Giants hope. Until next time, Go Giants!