Mariners Power Rankings: Dan Wilson Gone, Gilbert Shines

Seattle Mariners · 2026-10-06 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: You just heard that final out of the 2026 regular season, and let me tell you, it wasn’t the clean ending Seattle hoped for. They finished 76 and 86, third in the AL West, and the very first move of the offseason is already here: Manager Dan Wilson is out. But before we get into who’s next, let’s look at where they actually stand in the hierarchy of this league right now.

Kevin: It’s a stark contrast to last year’s ALCS run, Nicole. When you’re looking at power rankings, you have to separate talent from results, and right now, the Mariners are sitting in a weird limbo. High-upside pitching, but an offense that couldn't quite close games until the final weekend.

Nicole: That’s exactly what we’re breaking down today on the Beatline Podcast Network. I’m Nicole, and I’m joined by Kevin. We’ve got three big things coming up: First, we’ll rank the Mariners in the AL West context and see if they’re truly contenders or just pretenders. Second, we’ll dig into the strengths of their rotation and the glaring question marks in their bullpen usage. And third, we’ll give you our realistic outlook for 2027, including whether Cole Young really is the answer at second base.

Kevin: And we’ll definitely touch on that wild finale against the Angels. Logan Gilbert went eight scoreless innings with eight strikeouts in a no-hit bid before the bullpen cleaned up the rest. It was a beautiful note to end on, even if the record tells a different story.

Nicole: So, grab your coffee, get comfortable, and let’s dive straight into the rankings. Kevin, if you had to put the Mariners in a tier of teams right now, where do they land?

Kevin: They’re firmly in the 'Project' tier. Not a rebuild, but not a contender. The 76 wins show they were below .500, which is tough to swallow after making the playoffs last year. In the broader MLB landscape, they’re probably around the 15th or 16th best team in baseball right now—too much talent to be bad, not enough consistency to be elite.

Nicole: Let’s zoom in on the AL West. They finished third, behind Houston and Texas, obviously. But looking at the gap between them and the fifth-place Angels—who went 62 and 99—that margin feels bigger than the win total suggests. How do you view that divisional standing?

Kevin: It’s misleading because the Angels were historically bad. If you take the Mariners’ performance against non-Angels teams, they were mediocre. The real issue is the ceiling. In the AL West, you need to be better than 76 wins to make noise. Last year, they peaked late. This year, they stalled out in August. Finishing third looks okay on paper, but it highlights a lack of durability.

Nicole: Right, and part of that durability issue seems tied to managerial decisions. Dan Wilson is gone. He led them to the ALCS last year, so firing him feels aggressive, but he admitted the results weren’t what anyone expected. Do you think the locker room needed a change of scenery?

Kevin: I think it was about energy. When you strike out 12 times in a game or can’t string together hits against average pitching, the manager often becomes the scapegoat. Wilson was a player’s guy, sure, but sometimes you need someone who can shake up the lineup construction. Remember how they handled platoon splits? Sometimes they stuck with underperforming veterans when a younger guy like Ryan Bliss was hot.

Nicole: That’s a fair point. And speaking of young guys, Cole Young was called up and showed flashes. On our previous shows, we predicted he’d be the primary second baseman in 2027. Does his presence help elevate their ranking within the division?

Kevin: Absolutely. If Cole Young starts 140 games at second base, as we discussed, he brings defensive value and speed that J.P. Crawford doesn’t provide in that spot. It shifts the Mariners from a team that relies on Crawford’s bat alone to a more balanced infield. That moves them from a 'bottom-tier contender' to a 'wild card dark horse' in my mind.

Nicole: Okay, so we’ve established they’re not terrible, but they’re not great either. Before we move on to the specific roster strengths, I want to take a quick breath. Hey everyone, if you love hearing us break down these daily sports updates, please consider supporting the show. A small contribution through the link in the episode description helps cover our daily research costs, pays for the editing, and keeps this feed running free for all of you. It means the world to us.

Kevin: Thanks for that. Now, let’s talk strengths. The rotation. Logan Gilbert, George Kirby, Bryce Miller. Three solid arms. Gilbert’s finale was electric—eight strikeouts, no hits through four innings before the hook. That’s ace-level stuff.

Nicole: It was! But Kevin, you’re always the one talking about bullpen usage. Let’s talk about the relief corps. They had 12 strikeouts in that finale, but overall, was the bullpen reliable? Or did it collapse too often?

Kevin: It was inconsistent. Andres Munoz is still the setup man, and Michael Rucker has been impressive lately, but beyond that, it’s a mix of veterans and kids. Seranthony Dominguez, Hoby Milner, Gabe Speier—they’re capable, but they didn’t have the same dominance as last year. When the starters went deep, the bullpen held up. When they went shallow, the relievers got exposed.

Nicole: So the strength is clearly starting pitching depth, but the weakness is middle-inning reliability. What about the offense? Randy Arozarena and Julio Rodriguez are stars. Did they carry the load?

Kevin: Julio Rodriguez is always going to be elite, but he struggled with consistency this year. Arozarena provided clutch hits, like that pinch-hit two-run single against the Angels in the seventh. But overall, the OBP was down. They struck out too much. Look at that final game: 12 strikeouts as a team. That’s unsustainable. You can’t win 76 games striking out that much unless your defense is MVP-caliber, and theirs was just... average.

Nicole: Average defense isn’t enough when you’re giving up extra-base hits. And we saw that with Josh Naylor at first base. He’s a good hitter, but defensively, he’s limited. Does that hurt their ability to keep games tight?

Kevin: It does. Defensive positioning matters more now with the shift bans and all. If you’re giving up ground balls to Naylor, you’re allowing singles to turn into doubles. Combined with the high strikeout rate, it created a negative run prevention environment. They needed more contact hitters. Someone like Victor Robles or Lazaro Montes needs to produce more consistently in the outfield corners.

Nicole: Right. So, summary on strengths and weaknesses: Elite top-of-the-rotation pitching, star power in the center of the lineup, but a fragile bullpen and a contact-challenged offense. That feels accurate. Now, let’s look ahead. We predicted they’d finish 78-84 next year. Do we stick with that?

Kevin: We absolutely stick with that. Here’s why: The rotation stays the same. Gilbert, Kirby, Miller, and maybe Bryan Woo if he’s healthy. That’s a top-five staff in baseball. If the hitting improves even slightly—if Cole Young makes the leap and Julio gets back to his All-Star form—78 wins is conservative. I could see them hitting 82.

Nicole: But the managerial change is huge. Who comes in? That’s the biggest variable. If they hire a defensive-minded manager who emphasizes plate discipline, those strikeouts go down. If they hire a fire-and-forge type, maybe the offense wakes up. But realistically, rebuilding takes time.

Kevin: Exactly. And don’t forget the ABS challenge system. Robot umpires flipped 54% of challenged calls this year. That changes how pitchers pitch. They have to throw strikes. For a team with a strikeout-prone lineup, that might actually help—fewer walks, more balls in play. It’s a subtle factor, but it favors contact hitters. If Seattle develops more contact, they benefit from the new rule environment.

Nicole: That’s a great point. The automated ball-strike system forces efficiency. For a team like Seattle, that means their pitchers can’t rely on trickery; they have to miss bats. Which brings us back to Gilbert. His eight Ks in the finale? That’s the future. Can they replicate that across 162 games?

Kevin: If they do, they’re in the playoff hunt. My prediction remains 78-84, but I’m confident Cole Young will start 140 games. He’s the engine that makes the infield work. Without him, they’re stuck in mediocrity. With him, they’re dangerous.

Nicole: Dangerous is a good word. Not dominant, but dangerous. And that’s enough to keep fans excited for winter ball and spring training. Kevin, any final thoughts on the Dan Wilson firing? Was it necessary?

Kevin: In this business, yes. Results matter. 76 wins is a step back. You have to make moves. Whether it’s the right move or not, it’s the business move. Now the search begins. I hope they find someone who fits the pitching staff’s vibe.

Nicole: Well, there you have it. The Seattle Mariners are 76 and 86, third in the AL West, with a new manager incoming and a rotation that promises plenty of strikeouts. We predict a bounce-back to 78 wins next year, led by Cole Young at second base. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network!

Kevin: Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. It helps us reach more Mariners fans. See you next time.

Nicole: Go Mariner Go!