Mariners Roster Battles: Infield Chaos & Pitching Depth

Seattle Mariners · 2026-10-05 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: J.P. Crawford just hit a two-run homer in the finale, Taylor Ward came off the bench to drive in the go-ahead run, and now the front office is staring at a roster full of questions. Who stays? Who goes? And is Cole Young really the guy?

Kevin: It’s a rebuild in real-time, Nicole. We’ve got seven new arms on the roster list alone, plus infielders like Ryan Bliss and Patrick Wisdom fighting for minutes that didn’t exist last year when we were in the ALCS.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Nicole, and this is your daily deep dive into the Seattle Mariners. Kevin, you’re here with me as we break down the post-season roster battles.

Kevin: Thanks, Nicole. It’s been a wild ride from the ALCS run to this 76-86 finish. Dan Wilson’s out, the carousel is spinning, and now we look at who actually makes the team in spring training.

Nicole: Here’s what we’re tackling today. First, the biggest positional battle: second base and shortstop depth. Second, the bullpen war—do we keep nine arms or cut down to eight? And third, our final roster predictions for Opening Day. Let’s get into it.

Kevin: And remember, we talked about Cole Young being the primary second baseman yesterday. Today, we see if he holds up against the competition.

Nicole: Let’s start with the infield. J.P. Crawford is locked in at shortstop, but after him? It’s a mess. We have Michael Arroyo, Brock Rodden, and now Ryan Bliss and Cole Young pushing hard. Who do you trust more right now?

Kevin: I still think Cole Young has the edge. He’s young, he has high upside, and unlike Arroyo, he’s not coming off a rehab assignment. Bliss is intriguing because of his plate discipline, but Young feels like the future.

Nicole: But wait—what about Brendan Donovan? He’s listed at third base, but he can play everywhere. If they bring him in, does that push Young to second or even outfield?

Kevin: Donovan is a utility nightmare in the best way. He gives you defensive versatility. But if I’m GM, I’m keeping Young because he’s under team control longer. You don’t trade away youth for veterans unless it’s for an upgrade.

Nicole: Right. And then there’s Patrick Wisdom. He’s a power bat, but his defense at third? Risky. Leo Rivas and Weston Wilson are also on the list. Do any of those guys make the cut?

Kevin: Wisson is probably a trade chip. Rivas and Wilson are non-tender candidates unless they prove they can handle major league pitching consistently. I’d bet on Young and maybe one other infielder making the squad.

Nicole: So Young is the starter. What about the catching situation? Cal Raleigh is the anchor, but Willie MacIver and Jhonny Pereda are behind him. Any movement there?

Kevin: Raleigh is untouchable. The question is backup. MacIver has some pop, but Pereda is more of a defensive specialist. I think they keep both for depth, but MacIver might be the one to challenge Raleigh for starts late in the season.

Nicole: Okay, so Young at second, Raleigh starting, and maybe Donovan as the super-utility guy. That leaves the outfield. Julio Rodriguez is solid, but Randy Arozarena and Lazaro Montes are battling for left and right. Victor Robles is there too. Who gets the nod?

Kevin: Robles is speed, but his contact issues are real. Arozarena is a proven commodity. I think they stick with AJ and Robinson as the starters, with Montes as the fourth outfielder who can pinch-hit.

Nicole: Makes sense. Speed isn’t worth the strikeouts if you’re trying to win games. Alright, let’s shift gears to the battery. Logan Gilbert struck out eight in four no-hit innings in the finale. George Kirby is back. Bryce Miller is rising. Who’s the ace?

Kevin: Gilbert has the stuff, but Kirby’s consistency is unmatched. Miller is the dark horse—he’s got great command. I’d say Gilbert is the #1, Kirby the #2, and Miller the #3. That’s a strong top three.

Nicole: And the rest? Kade Anderson, Emerson Hancock, Carlos Vargas, Troy Watson, Cole Wilcox. It’s a crowded rotation. Which arm impresses you most in camp?

Kevin: Hancock has the highest ceiling. If he develops his slider, he could be a frontline starter. Anderson is reliable, but less explosive. I’d watch Hancock closely.

Nicole: Got it. So, Young at second, Kirby/Gilbert/Miller at the top, and Hancock pushing for a spot. That’s Segment One. Coming up, we’ll talk about the bullpen wars—who keeps their job?

Nicole: Stick with us. The bullpen is where this team lives or dies.

Nicole: Welcome back. The bullpen. Andres Munoz is the closer, but after him? It’s chaos. Hoby Milner, Seranthony Dominguez, Gabe Speier, Josh Simpson, Cole Wilcox, Carlos Vargas, Eduard Bazardo, Cooper Criswell, Jose Ferrer, Michael Rucker, Troy Taylor. That’s eleven arms!

Kevin: Eleven is too many. They’ll need to trim that down to eight or nine. The question is: who gets cut? Milner is reliable, but his ERA has been up. Dominguez has high strikeout rates but walks a lot.

Nicole: Right. And Speier? He’s had ups and downs. Simpson is young. Rucker is electric. Where do you start cutting?

Kevin: I’d look at veteran contracts first. Bazardo and Criswell might be easier to move than Rucker or Simpson. Rucker has the stuff to be a high-leverage reliever. Simpson is a swingman.

Nicole: What about the setup man role? Munoz closes, but who’s the bridge? Milner or Dominguez?

Kevin: Dominguez has the better stuff. If he controls his walks, he’s the guy. Milner is more of a middle-innings arm. I’d give Dominguez the 7th/8th inning role.

Nicole: Okay, so Dominguez sets up, Munoz closes. That leaves five spots for Milner, Speier, Simpson, Rucker, and maybe one more. Who makes the cut?

Kevin: Rucker is a must-keep. He’s young and dominant. Simpson is versatile. Milner is experienced. I’d keep all three and maybe add one more lefty specialist if needed.

Nicole: What about the lefty specialists? Do we have any pure lefties in that mix? Vargas is a lefty, but he’s more of a starter-turned-reliever type.

Kevin: Vargas can work out of the pen. He’s got good stuff. I think they’ll use him as a long reliever or spot starter. It’s flexible.

Nicole: So, Dominguez, Rucker, Simpson, Milner, and Vargas? That’s five. Plus Munoz. Six. We need two more. Speier or someone else?

Kevin: Speier is the next logical choice. He’s been around, he knows the system. I’d keep him over the younger arms unless they blow you away in camp.

Nicole: Alright, so the core is Munoz, Dominguez, Rucker, Simpson, Milner, and Speier. That’s six. Maybe add one more lefty like Vargas or a new acquisition. Solid group.

Kevin: Exactly. It’s not flashy, but it’s stable. If Dominguez stays healthy, this bullpen could be top ten.

Nicole: We’re going to take a quick break, but before we go, I want to check in with you. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Point listeners to 'the link in the episode description' to support us. Thanks for helping us keep the show free and daily!

Nicole: We’re back. Final segment: Roster cuts and predictions. We said earlier that Cole Young would be the primary second baseman. Do you stand by that?

Kevin: Absolutely. Young has the tools. He might struggle early, but he’s the future. I predict he starts 140 games.

Nicole: And the managerial change? We predicted an internally-minded or analytically-focused replacement for Dan Wilson. Any names yet?

Kevin: Not officially, but I’d expect someone from within the org. Maybe a former player who understands the culture. The front office values continuity.

Nicole: Final prediction: The Mariners will finish 78-84 in 2027. Slight improvement, but playoff contention is still a year or two away.

Kevin: I agree. 78-84. It’s a building year. But with Gilbert, Kirby, and Young, the foundation is there.

Nicole: Thanks for listening! Subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Mariner fan. Go Marines!