Megan: It’s a winning record! After eight long years of watching from the sidelines while everyone else celebrated October baseball, the Pittsburgh Pirates are finally back in the conversation. The curse is broken.
Steve: 82 and 80. It’s not just a number; it’s a milestone. But in this league, finishing third in the NL Central with a winning record feels like more than just survival—it feels like the foundation has been poured.
Megan: Welcome to today’s episode of the Beatline Podcast Network, where we break down the team that matters most to you. I’m Megan, and I’m joined by Steve, who’s got his power rankings spreadsheet open and ready to argue with me.
Steve: Good morning, Pirate fans. We’re here to talk about exactly where this team stands heading into the offseason. Today on the show: first, we rank the Pirates in the brutal NL Central context. Second, we look at the biggest strength—the rotation—and the biggest question mark, which is the bullpen void left by Kirby Yates. And third, we give you our realistic win projection for next year.
Megan: We’ve got Konnor Griffin cementing his role as the everyday shortstop, Paul Skenes looking like an ace, and a whole new era starting right now. Let’s dive into Segment One: Where do the Pirates actually rank in their division?
Megan: Okay, Steve. Final standings. The Pirates are 82-80, sitting in third place in the NL Central. That’s up from last year, obviously, but they’re still behind the top teams. How do you grade that position relative to the rest of the league?
Steve: I’d say it’s a solid B-plus grade. You finish with a winning record, which is the primary goal, but you’re still three games out of the wildcard spot in many metrics. In the NL Central, you’re clearly better than the fourth-place Tigers, who finished 76-85, but you’re also not quite challenging the top dog yet.
Megan: Right, and let’s be clear about that final game. They beat Detroit 4-2, thanks to a Konnor Griffin homer. That was the exclamation point on the season. But does that victory really signal they’re ready to jump the Cubs or Cardinals?
Steve: Not yet. The gap between third and first in the Central is usually talent-based. Your run differential wasn’t elite. But look at the trajectory. Eight years of losing, and now you have a core that believes it can compete. The standing is third, but the mindset is first.
Megan: I love that mindset shift. It’s subtle, but it’s everything. When you start believing you belong in October, the draft picks get better, the free agents come easier. So, in terms of raw power rankings across MLB, where do you put them? Top 15? Top 20?
Steve: Top 15 is fair. If you look at the rotation, specifically the Skenes-Jones-Ashcraft trio, that alone puts you in the upper tier of pitching staffs. Offensively, you’re middle-of-the-pack, but you’re balanced enough to stay competitive every single day.
Megan: So, third in the division, but top-tier potential based on your starting five. That sets the stage for our next segment. What are the strengths, and what keeps you up at night regarding the roster construction?
Steve: The strength is undeniable: the starting rotation. You have Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, and Braxton Ashcraft. These are guys who can go head-to-head with anyone in baseball. Skenes especially has developed into a true frontline starter.
Megan: And don’t forget Bubba Chandler coming back into the mix, and Thomas Harrington providing depth. This isn’t a one-man show anymore. It’s a deep, dangerous rotation. But Steve, we talked about the bullpen yesterday. The void left by Kirby Yates’ retirement is massive.
Steve: It is. Yates was a two-time All-Star and a veteran presence. He retired after making his first start this year, which is a poignant end to a 12-year career. But leaving him means you have to fill those high-leverage innings with younger arms like Gregory Soto, Luke Weaver, and Hunter Barco.
Megan: Soto and Weaver have experience, but are they reliable for a full season? That’s the question mark. On offense, we know Bryan Reynolds is the engine, and Henry Davis has been solid behind the plate. But what about the infield battles?
Steve: The infield is interesting. You’ve got Nick Gonzales at third, Brandon Lowe at second, and then the shortstop situation. As we predicted in previous episodes, Konnor Griffin is taking over. His homer in the finale against Detroit shows he has the power to complement his speed.
Megan: Griffin hitting 20 home runs and stealing 20 bases? That’s the prediction we made last week, and he’s showing the tools for it. But defensively, can he hold shortstop? And what about the catching competition between Henry Davis and Rafael Flores Jr.?
Steve: Davis has the offensive upside, but Flores brings defensive reliability. For now, Davis starts because you need his bat. But the outfield is where you see flexibility. Oneil Cruz in center, Ryan O'Hearn and Jhostynxon Garcia in the corners. It’s a platoon-heavy approach, which works if the matchups are right.
Megan: Platoon splits are key. You can’t just throw bodies out there; you have to match them up. The Pirates are doing that better than most. But let’s talk about the big picture. With the rotation so strong and Griffin emerging, what’s the outlook for 2027?
Steve: Realistically? I’m sticking with my prediction: the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027. If the rotation stays healthy and the bullpen doesn’t collapse, 90 wins is a very reachable target. You don’t need to win the division; you just need to secure a wildcard spot.
Megan: 90 wins. That’s a huge jump from 82. Do you think they’ll add another piece before the winter meetings? Maybe a veteran reliever to help stabilize that back end?
Steve: They should. With Kirby Yates gone, someone needs to bridge the gap to the closer. If they bring in a guy like Edwin Díaz or even a mid-tier veteran, that bullpen becomes scary good. Otherwise, they rely on internal options like Isaac Mattson and Evan Sisk, which is risky.
Megan: Risky, but exciting. Because if those young arms develop, you’re set for a decade. Let’s talk about Griffin again. We said he’d start at least 100 games. Is he the everyday shortstop going forward, or do you see Jared Triolo pushing him?
Steve: Griffin is the guy. Triolo is more of a utility option. Griffin’s power-speed combo is too valuable to bench. He’s going to play every day, and if he hits that 20/20 mark, he’s an All-Star candidate. That’s the core around which this team builds.
Megan: All-Star candidate. I love hearing that. So, final thoughts on the power rankings. Third place today, but first place in ambition. The Pirates are no longer a rebuilding team; they’re a contending team.
Steve: Exactly. The foundation is laid. Skenes, Jones, Griffin, Reynolds. That’s a core any GM would kill for. Now it’s just about adding the right pieces around them.
Megan: Before we go, I want to say thank you. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or your commute, a small tip is what keeps us coming to you every single day, free and without ads. Please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description.
Steve: It helps keep the lights on and the research fresh. We appreciate every single one of you who supports the network.
Megan: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Pirate fan. Go Bucs!