Megan: You just won’t believe what’s happening in Pittsburgh right now. We’re talking about a team that finally broke an eight-year drought with a winning record, but here’s the kicker: their entire future hinges on a few specific guys holding down the fort. Konnor Griffin is staring down the barrel of becoming the everyday shortstop, Paul Skenes is locking in as the undisputed ace, and the bullpen? It’s wide open after Kirby Yates hung up his cleats. Stick with us.
Steve: It’s a fascinating pivot point for the Pirates. They finished 82-80, third in the NL Central, and while the celebration is nice, the real story is the internal competition. We’ve got position battles at second base, catching depth issues, and a rotation that looks terrifyingly good on paper if you actually look at the arms behind Skenes.
Megan: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Megan, and this is your daily dose of Pirates analysis. Joining me as always is Steve, our resident baseball tactician. Steve, we talked yesterday about Griffin’s emergence, but today we’re going deeper into the roster battles that will define 2027.
Steve: Right. And let’s not forget, we predicted back in October that Griffin would start at least 100 games next year. If he wins this job now, that prediction becomes a guarantee. But it’s not a foregone conclusion yet. There are other guys in camp looking to steal those innings.
Megan: So here’s what we’re covering today: First, we’re settling the debate on who takes the shortstop job for sure—Griffin versus Jacob Gonzalez or Jared Triolo. Second, we’re looking at the catching battle between Henry Davis and Rafael Flores Jr., and finally, we’re breaking down the outfield logjam and who gets cut when spring training rolls around. Let’s get into it.
Megan: Let’s start with the elephant in the room. Shortstop. Konnor Griffin homered in the final game against Detroit, helping secure that 4-2 win and the winning season. It was a huge moment. But does one homer equal everyday starter status?
Steve: It’s more than just the homer, Megan. It’s the defensive metrics. Griffin has shown elite range in the hole. The question isn’t whether he can play there; it’s whether the other options offer enough upside to displace him. Jacob Gonzalez has the power profile, but defensively, he’s been inconsistent. Jared Triolo is reliable, but he’s more of a utility player type.
Megan: I agree. Triolo is solid, but he doesn’t have that ceiling. When you’re building a young core, you want the guy with the highest floor AND ceiling. Griffin has the arm strength for deep shifts and the bat to drive in runs from the leadoff or two-hole spot. Remember, he hit that walk-off style bomb to seal the season.
Steve: Exactly. And look at the platoon splits. Griffin handles left-handed pitching well enough to stay in the lineup every day. Gonzalez struggles a bit more against southpaws, which forces the manager into difficult decisions. In a 162-game season, you can’t afford to bench your starting shortstop three times a week.
Megan: So, are you saying Griffin is the lock?
Steve: I’m saying he’s the heavy favorite. But here’s the nuance: if Griffin starts slow in spring training, Triolo could eat some early innings until he gets hot. But by May? It’s Griffin. The organization sees him as the face of the infield alongside Nick Yorke at third.
Megan: And what about Nick Yorke? He’s playing third base, but we know the Pirates love versatility. Do you see Yorke moving around, or is he locked at the hot corner?
Steve: Yorke is locked at third. He’s got the size, the plate discipline, and the OBP skills to be a staple there. The real battle is at second base. Brandon Lowe is veteran presence, but Tyler Callihan is coming up from the minors with serious pop. That’s where the real roster battle is brewing for the infield spots.
Megan: Oh, interesting. So Callihan vs. Lowe for second base? That changes the dynamic. If Callihan wins that job, does Triolo get pushed to utility?
Steve: Precisely. Triolo’s value drops if Callihan takes the everyday gig. But if Callihan doesn’t hit, Triolo remains the safety valve. It’s a classic organizational dilemma. You have youth vs. experience. I think they’ll go with Callihan if his spring stats show he can handle major league velocity.
Megan: That makes sense. Okay, so Griffin is likely the SS, Yorke is the 3B, and Callihan might challenge Lowe at 2B. This infield looks dangerous. Let’s move to the battery. Catching.
Steve: Henry Davis has had ups and downs, but his framing ability is top-tier. He keeps pitchers in rhythm. Rafael Flores Jr. has better raw power, but can he handle a staff like this? With Paul Skenes and Jared Jones leading the way, you need a catcher who can manage the strike zone precisely.
Megan: Davis has matured. He’s not just a prospect anymore; he’s a MLB regular. But Flores Jr. is tempting because of the power. If the Pirates are going for playoff contention in 2027, maybe they need that extra oomph off the bench. Or do they stick with Davis as the primary?
Steve: I think Davis starts. But Flores Jr. will make a strong case for the backup role. If Davis gets injured—or even just needs rest—Flores is ready. The key is how much playing time Flores gets in extended spring training. If he shows he can handle lefties, he’s a valuable asset. If he’s a liability against southpaws, he’s strictly a backup.
Megan: Got it. Davis gets the nod, but Flores is the dark horse. Alright, Steve, let’s talk about the big guns. The rotation. We’ve got Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Braxton Ashcraft, Bubba Chandler, Khristian Curtis, and Thomas Harrington. Who are the locks, and who is fighting for the fifth spot?
Steve: Skenes is the ace. No debate. He’s dominant. Jones is the clear number two. Ashcraft is the number three. That’s your top three. The battle is for four and five. Chandler and Curtis are both intriguing. Chandler has that slider that misses bats, and Curtis has velocity. But Harrington? He’s the wild card.
Megan: Harrington was impressive in his last few outings. He’s got a unique delivery that disrupts timing. But can he sustain it over 15-20 starts? That’s the concern. Injury history is always a factor with that kind of motion.
Steve: True. But if Harrington stays healthy, he might edge out Chandler or Curtis because of his command. Pitchers who can throw strikes win games in the late innings. Chandler relies too much on swing-and-miss stuff, which can be volatile. Harrington’s approach is more sustainable for a full season workload.
Megan: So Harrington could be the surprise fifth starter? That would be huge for them. Because if they can get quality starts from all five guys, they don’t need to lean on the bullpen as hard. And speaking of the bullpen...
Steve: Kirby Yates retired. That’s a massive loss. He was a two-time All-Star. Now you’ve got Gregory Soto, Luke Weaver, Lake Bachar, Hunter Barco, Wilber Dotel, Brandon Eisert, Antwone Kelly, Isaac Mattson, Carmen Mlodzinski, Mason Montgomery, Noah Murdock, Yohan Ramirez, and Evan Sisk. It’s a crowded group, but no established closer.
Megan: Who steps up? Soto has the track record, right? He’s proven at this level.
Steve: Soto is the logical choice for high-leverage innings. But the closer role? It’s wide open. Maybe Weaver tries to close, or maybe they use a committee. The ABS challenge system data shows some of these younger arms like Mlodzinski have great spin rates, but do they have the mental toughness for save situations? That’s the question.
Megan: It feels like a rebuild of the bullpen from scratch. That’s risky. If Soto struggles, who’s next? Weaver? Or do they call someone up from the minors?
Steve: They’ll likely promote from within. Guys like Barco and Dotel have MLB experience. But the lack of a definitive closer is a weakness. In the playoffs, you need that one guy who can shut the door. Without Yates, they’re searching for identity in relief pitching.
Megan: Okay, so before we head to Segment 3, where we’ll talk about who’s staying and who’s going, I want to take a quick moment. If you enjoyed this deep dive into the Pirates’ roster dynamics, please consider supporting the show. Your contributions keep this network free and daily. Check the link in the episode description to help us out. Thanks, you guys.
Steve: Thanks, Megan. Alright, let’s get to the cuts. Who’s trending up and who’s trending down? Based on the roster list, I think Billy Cook is in trouble. He’s competing with Oneil Cruz and Ryan O'Hearn in the outfield. Cruz has speed and defense. O'Hearn has experience. Cook is just... surplus.
Megan: Ouch. Billy Cook. He’s a fan favorite, though. But statistically, he hasn’t separated himself. Jake Mangum is also in that mix. Mangum is great on defense, but can he hit enough to stick? If the offense stalls, managers often turn to contact hitters. Mangum might be a trade chip rather than a roster spot.
Steve: Agreed. Mangum is a trade candidate. Cook is probably DFA material unless he puts up monster numbers in spring training. On the flip side, Jhostynxon Garcia is trending up. He’s got the power from the right side and fits well in RF. If he can’t make the MLB club, he’s still valuable as a prospect. But he’s likely making the team out of camp.
Megan: Garcia is a good bet. What about the infield again? We mentioned Callihan vs. Lowe. If Callihan doesn’t win the job, where does he go? Does he get designated for assignment?
Steve: If Callihan doesn’t win the second base job, he’s likely sent to Triple-A to start the year. They need to give him at-bats against major league pitching to develop. Sending him down isn’t a failure; it’s part of the process. But if he dominates there, he’ll be back up by July.
Megan: So, final roster predictions. Griffin at SS, Yorke at 3B, Lowe at 2B (with Callihan waiting), Davis at C, Cruz/Spencer Horwitz/Bryan Reynolds in the outfield. And Soto as the primary reliever. Anyone else jump out at you?
Steve: I’d add Spencer Horwitz to the mix at first base. He’s versatile and can play first. But really, the biggest surprise will be who emerges from the bullpen chaos. I wouldn’t be shocked if a rookie like Noah Murdock finds himself in a save situation by August. These guys are hungry.
Megan: Murdoch in a save situation? That’s bold, Steve. But I love the energy. The Pirates are young, hungry, and finally healthy. They have a chance to surprise everyone in 2027. Speaking of surprises, remember our prediction? We said the Pirates would make the playoffs in 2027. With this roster structure, I’m sticking by it.
Steve: I am too. The foundation is there. Skenes, Griffin, Yorke, and a developing bullpen. If the hitting clicks, they’re dangerous. I predict Griffin hits 20 home runs and steals 20 bases next year. That’s the profile of a modern shortstop.
Megan: Twenty homers and twenty steals for Griffin. I’ll take that bet. Steve, thanks for breaking down all the battles. Fans, if you loved this breakdown, subscribe, rate, and review the podcast wherever you listen. Share it with a fellow Pirate fan. Let’s keep the momentum going. Up PNC!
Steve: Up PNC. See you tomorrow.