Megan: Konnor Griffin just homered to seal the first winning season in eight years for this franchise, but is he really the everyday shortstop of the future? And with Kirby Yates hanging up his cleats, who actually closes games in Pittsburgh now? We are answering your mailbag questions right now.
Steve: That is right, Megan. Eighty-two wins. First time above .500 since 2018. It’s a massive shift in culture for this organization.
Steve: And remember, we predicted last week that the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027. Let’s see if the roster construction supports that bold claim.
Megan: Before we dive into the questions, I want to take thirty seconds to talk about you, our listeners. This show is free because of people like you. Your support covers the daily research, the editing, and keeps this feed running every single morning. If you can spare a coffee, it helps us keep digging deep for these insights. Just check the link in the episode description to help out.
Steve: This is the big one. Steve here. We talked about this yesterday. Konnor Griffin had that clutch hit to finish the season with a win, which is huge for morale. But we need to look at the defensive metrics and plate discipline. Griffin has shown flashes, but Jacob Gonzalez has more experience handling the pitching staff. However, Griffin’s arm and range are elite. I think the front office leans toward Griffin starting at least 100 games next year based on his upside.
Steve: Good point. Gonzalez does have a slightly higher batting average in limited samples, but Griffin’s OBP is driven by his ability to get on base via hits and walks combined with his baserunning. If they want offense, Griffin is the play. If they want defense and contact, it’s Gonzalez. I’d start with Griffin and bring Gonzalez up as the super-sub or trade chip.
Megan: Okay, let’s move to another question. @BucsFan412 asks: 'Kirby Yates retired after twelve seasons. He was a two-time All-Star. Who steps up in the bullpen now? Is Hunter Barco ready to be the closer?'
Steve: Oh man. That is a tough pill to swallow. Kirby Yates was a rock. His retirement leaves a massive hole in the late-inning leverage spots. Hunter Barco has been excellent in setup roles, but closing requires a different mindset. Barco has the stuff, but do they have the confidence to hand him the ninth inning immediately?
Steve: Luke Weaver has been inconsistent in high-leverage spots historically. He’s capable, but I’m not sure he’s the day-one closer. I think you might see a committee approach early in 2027. Maybe Barco takes the eighth inning, and they test someone like Evan Sisk or Isaac Mattson in save situations to see who handles the heat best. It’s a risk, but it’s necessary given Yates’ departure.
Steve: Absolutely. Skenes and Jones are the anchors. Braxton Ashcraft is also solid in that top three. If the offense stays healthy and the starters eat innings, the bullpen doesn’t have to carry the load every night. But if Skenes gets hurt, the margin for error shrinks significantly. The reliance on the top of the rotation is real.
Steve: Great context. Misiorowski led the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average—a historic feat. To beat teams that have that kind of pitching dominance, Pittsburgh needs their own offensive explosion. They can’t just rely on Skenes. They need Bryan Reynolds to stay healthy and productive. They need Oneil Cruz to find consistency in the outfield. And they need that infield to score more runs.
Steve: Griffin’s launch angle is promising. If he keeps driving the ball, he’ll hit 20-plus homers. But it’s about volume. Can he stay healthy? Can he handle the grind of 150 games at shortstop? That’s the key. If he starts 100+ games and performs, the Pirates’ ceiling goes up dramatically.
Steve: It is crowded. Oneil Cruz has the most tools—power, speed, arm—but his strikeout rate is always a concern. Billy Cook is a contact specialist who gets on base. Jake Mangum is the ultimate hustle guy, great defender. I think Cruz gets the nod simply because of his talent level. Even when he struggles, his upside is too high to bench. But Cook could steal playing time if Cruz slumps.
Megan: I agree. Cruz is the face of the franchise in many ways. But what about the right field spot? Ryan O'Hearn, Jhostynxon Garcia, Ronny Simon, Esmerlyn Valdez. It’s a mess. Who emerges?
Steve: Wow, that is a wide-open competition. O'Hearn provides veteran presence and left-handed power. Garcia has raw power but needs refinement. Simon and Valdez are young prospects. I think O'Hearn starts the year, but Garcia could push hard in spring training. If Garcia shows improvement in his plate discipline, he might take the job permanently.
Steve: Davis is a defensive catcher. His bat isn’t elite, but he frames pitches well. Flores has more pop but less experience. I think Davis stays behind the plate. Moving him to first base would block Spencer Horwitz, and Horwitz is already established. So, Davis catches, Horwitz plays first, and they figure out the rest.
Steve: Gonzales is versatile. He can play third, second, even short. That versatility makes him valuable. But if Yorke develops, they might need to move Gonzales. For now, though, Gonzales holds the job. He’s consistent, and the Pirates value consistency.
Steve: Chandler has good stuff, but he’s still refining his secondary pitches. Harrington is a ground-ball pitcher. Both could be swingmen out of the bullpen if the rotation gets injured. But right now, they’re depth pieces. Skenes, Jones, and Ashcraft are the core.
Steve: Ooh, tough call. I’m going with Paul Skenes. If he stays healthy, he’ll win 20 games and lead the league in strikeouts. That’s MVP territory for a pitcher. But if I had to pick a position player, it’s Bryan Reynolds. He’s the engine. If he hits .300 with 30 steals, the Pirates are dangerous.
Megan: I’ll go with Konnor Griffin. If he starts 100 games and hits 20 homers with 30 steals, he’s the breakout star of the year. The narrative writes itself.
Steve: Sad news. Sam McDowell was a dominant force in his prime, leading the AL in strikeouts four times. His work as a counselor for athletes struggling with addiction and depression later in life was incredibly impactful. A true pioneer both on and off the field.
Steve: Yes. Tears on the mound with his daughter. 21-year career. Incredible. The Tigers rallied to beat the Pirates 4-3 in that game, but it was all about Verlander’s legacy.
Steve: The ABS tracker ranks teams on challenges. If the Pirates use it strategically, they can win close calls. But it’s not a silver bullet. You still need to pitch strikes. The Pirates need to focus on their own execution first.
Steve: Don’t forget, we predict the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027. Subscribe, rate, and review. Go Pirates!