Pirates Mailbag: Griffin's Future, Skenes' Ceiling & The Yates Void

Pittsburgh Pirates · 2026-10-08 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Megan: Konnor Griffin just homered in the season finale to seal a winning record, but does that mean he’s locking down shortstop for good? And with Kirby Yates retiring, who actually holds the closer role next year? We’re answering your mailbag questions right now.

Steve: It’s been a historic week for Pittsburgh. Eighty-two wins. First winning season in eight years. But the real story isn’t just the record—it’s the identity shift happening on this roster.

Megan: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Megan, and alongside me as always is Steve. Happy Wednesday, Pirates fans! You sent us dozens of emails, tweets, and voicemails, and we’ve narrowed it down to the three biggest topics dominating your inbox today.

Steve: That’s right. First up, we’re tackling the Konnor Griffin question. Is he the everyday starter at shortstop moving forward, or is this just a flash-in-the-pan breakout? Second, we’re looking at the pitching staff’s future, specifically how Paul Skenes and Jared Jones shape the rotation long-term. And third, we’re addressing the bullpen vacuum left by Kirby Yates’ retirement.

Megan: We’re going deep into the analytics, the roster battles, and yes, we’re even settling one debate about Henry Davis once and for all. So grab your Pirates gear, turn up the volume, and let’s get into the mailbag!

Megan: Let’s jump straight into Segment One. Our first question comes from @PirateParade84, who asks: 'Konnor Griffin hit that walk-off homer against Detroit. Does this performance guarantee him the starting shortstop job for 2027, or should we expect competition?'

Steve: Well, you have to look at the trajectory here. Griffin didn’t just have one good game; he emerged over the final stretch of the season. When you’re hitting .300 or better in September, managers listen. But guaranteeing a job? That’s a strong word.

Megan: Right, because Jacob Gonzalez was also in the mix earlier in the year. Did Gonzalez lose his spot entirely?

Steve: Gonzalez struggled with consistency. His plate discipline wasn’t where it needed to be against major league pitching. Griffin, on the other hand, showed he could handle high-leverage situations. The front office sees that composure. It’s not just about defense anymore; it’s about offensive output.

Megan: Okay, so Griffin looks like the favorite. But what about Nick Yorke? He’s playing third base mostly, right?

Steve: Yorke is an infielder, sure, but he’s more of a utility piece at this stage. He doesn’t project as an everyday shortstop. If anything, Yorke might push Brandon Lowe for second base, or move around if injuries occur. But for shortstop? It’s Griffin vs. nobody right now.

Megan: So, Steve, are you saying Griffin starts 100 games next year? Remember, we predicted exactly that back in October fifth!

Steve: I am standing by that prediction. The evidence supports it. His defensive metrics were solid, and his batting average spike wasn’t a fluke. He earned the reps when it mattered most against Detroit.

Megan: Moving on to our second question. Sarah from Rochester writes in: 'Paul Skenes had a great rookie year, and Jared Jones looked electric too. With both guys under team control, do the Pirates really have a top-five rotation in baseball already?'

Steve: This is the exciting part. Yes, they do. Skenes brings elite velocity and swing-and-miss stuff. Jones has that unique arm slot and deception that makes him hard to square up. Together, they form one of the most dynamic young duos in the NL Central.

Megan: And Braxton Ashcraft? He’s still there, right? Or is he more of a depth piece now?

Steve: Ashcraft provides stability. He’s not a strikeout artist like Skenes, but he gets ground balls and keeps the ball in the park. You want three guys who can eat innings and give you quality starts? Skenes, Jones, and Ashcraft is a very safe trio.

Megan: What about Bubba Chandler and Thomas Harrington? Are they locked in as four and five?

Steve: Chandler and Harrington are intriguing, but they’re still proving themselves. Chandler has the stuff, but consistency is key. Harrington needs to refine his secondary pitches. They’re likely fourth and fifth starters for now, but the ceiling is high.

Megan: So, top-five rotation? I think we’re being modest. This group is scary. Let’s pivot to the biggest concern: the bullpen. Kirby Yates just retired after making his first start. That’s huge news. Who steps up?

Steve: It’s a massive void. Yates was a two-time All-Star. His presence stabilized the late innings. Now, you have Gregory Soto, Luke Weaver, and Lake Bachar stepping into higher leverage roles. None of them have been closers before.

Megan: Gregory Soto has experience, though. He’s been around the league for a while. Do you trust him with the ninth inning?

Steve: Soto is the logical choice. He has the repertoire. But it’s unproven territory. The front office might need to look outside for a veteran arm in free agency. You don’t gamble the closer role on youth unless you have to.

Megan: Fair point. Okay, Segment One done. We’ve got Griffin locked in, Skenes and Jones shining, and a bullpen mystery. Stick with us—Segment Two is where things get really tactical.

Megan: Welcome back. In Segment Two, we’re diving into the outfield and catching situations. Marcus in Denver asks: 'Bryan Reynolds is our best player, but who is the everyday center fielder? Oneil Cruz has flashes, but Billy Cook and Jake Mangum are also on the roster. How does this logjam resolve?'

Steve: This is a classic Pittsburgh problem—too much talent, not enough spots. Oneil Cruz has the highest ceiling. His speed and power make him a nightmare matchup. But his defense? It’s volatile. If he commits to CF full-time, he’s a star.

Megan: But what if he doesn’t stay healthy or consistent? Where does Billy Cook fit in?

Steve: Cook is the safety valve. He’s reliable, plays good defense, and puts the ball in play. He’s not a superstar, but he’s a complete player. If Cruz struggles, Cook takes over. It’s not a battle; it’s a backup plan.

Megan: And Jake Mangum? He’s fast, obviously.

Steve: Mangum is strictly a super-utility guy. He’s incredible defensively, but his bat is limited. He’ll play whenever someone gets hurt or needs a spark off the bench. He’s not the everyday starter.

Megan: So, Cruz is the favorite, Cook is the insurance, Mangum is the specialist. Got it. Next question: @HillCityHomer wants to know about Henry Davis. 'Is Henry Davis ready to be the everyday catcher, or does Rafael Flores Jr. have a shot?'

Steve: Davis is the incumbent. He has the defensive reputation. But his offense has been inconsistent. Flores Jr. is the prospect everyone is watching. He has raw power and a mature approach for his age.

Megan: So, is it a platoon? Or does one win it outright?

Steve: If Davis can improve his OBP, he stays. If not, Flores pushes hard. The front office likes Davis’s leadership, but they love Flores’s upside. It’s going to be a spring training battle.

Megan: Interesting. So no clear winner yet. What about the infield? Spencer Horwitz at first base seems set, right?

Steve: Horwitz is solid. He’s smart, he takes walks, and he defends well. There’s no immediate threat to his job unless he falls off a cliff. He’s the anchor at first base.

Megan: And Nick Gonzales at third? He’s bouncing around positions.

Steve: Gonzales is finding his niche. He’s versatile, which is valuable. But he’s not an everyday third baseman right now. Yorke or maybe a trade acquisition could take that job. Gonzales is a key piece of the puzzle, just not the centerpiece.

Megan: Alright, we’ve covered the outfield logjam and the catching hierarchy. Before we head to Segment Three, we need to talk about how we keep this show running every single day.

Megan: Putting out fresh, daily content requires effort, research, and a lot of coffee. But it’s the support from listeners like you that makes it possible. If you love hearing these deep dives, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Your contribution helps keep Beatline free and daily for all Pirates fans. Thank you!

Megan: Welcome back to Segment Three. Let’s do a fun hypothetical. If the Pirates could add one veteran player before Spring Training to complement their young core, who is it?

Steve: I’d say a veteran left-handed bat. Ryan O'Hearn is great, but we need more depth behind the main lineup. Someone who can DH and fill in at corner outfield spots. Experience matters in tight NL Central races.

Megan: I agree. Maybe a veteran reliever too? To help bridge the gap after Yates?

Steve: Definitely. A setup man who can handle high pressure. That’s the missing piece. Without it, the bullpen remains a question mark.

Megan: Lightning round! Quick takes. Sam McDowell died recently. He was an inspiration for 'Cheers.' How do you view his legacy?

Steve: A legend. Four-time AL strikeout leader. But his work counseling athletes for addiction and depression is what truly defines his character. A respected figure in baseball history.

Megan: Next: Yordan Alvarez won a batting title. Does that change how we view the rest of the league?

Steve: It shows the power landscape is shifting. Alvarez is elite. But it doesn’t impact Pittsburgh directly. We focus on our own house.

Megan: Final question: Will the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027? Be honest.

Steve: Yes. They have the core. Skenes, Jones, Griffin, Reynolds. They’re building momentum. 82 wins is the foundation. Next year, it’s 90 wins minimum.

Megan: I stand by that too. The pieces are there. It’s time to take the next step. Alright, that’s our mailbag. We answered Griffin’s status, Skenes’ ceiling, and the bullpen void.

Megan: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network! If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share it with a fellow Pirate fan!

Steve: We’ll see you next time. Keep your eyes on the standings. The climb continues.

Megan: Let’s Go Pirates!