Pirates Roster Battles: Griffin at SS, Bullpen Void & Playoff Hopes

Pittsburgh Pirates · 2026-10-05 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Megan: It’s a walk-off win, a historic season, and now... the real work begins. Konnor Griffin didn’t just hit the homer; he signaled a shift in Pittsburgh’s entire infield identity.

Steve: And let’s not forget Kirby Yates hanging up his cleats after twelve years. That’s a massive void to fill if this club wants to bounce back in 2027.

Megan: Welcome to Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Megan O’Malley!

Steve: And I’m Steve Caruso. You are listening to The Pirate Press, your daily deep dive into the Pittsburgh Pirates.

Megan: We just wrapped up an 82-80 season that gave us our first winning record in eight years. But today, we’re looking forward. We’ve got three things coming up: the battle for shortstop, the new bullpen hierarchy, and who makes the opening day roster.

Steve: Exactly. It’s roster battles time. We’re talking position groups, depth charts, and the competition for spots as we head into the offseason.

Megan: Before we get into it, quick aside. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Please check out the link in the episode description to support the show.

Steve: We appreciate every bit of support. It helps us keep this analysis free and daily for all of you.

Megan: Alright, let’s jump right into Segment One. The most important position battle right now: Shortstop.

Megan: Konner Griffin ended the season with a walk-off home run against Detroit. He finished with a winning record for the team. But does that cement him as the everyday starter?

Steve: I think it does, Megan. Look, Jack Brannigan has been solid defensively, and Jacob Gonzalez brings some pop from the left side. But Griffin showed something special on Sunday.

Megan: Right, and remember last week we talked about his defensive metrics? They were trending upward.

Steve: They were. And combined with that clutch hitting, the front office has to be leaning toward him. Jared Triolo is also on the roster, but he feels more like a utility option than an everyday guy.

Megan: So if Griffin is the guy, where does that leave Brandon Lowe? He’s a veteran presence at second base, but can he handle a platoon role?

Steve: Lowe is interesting. He’s experienced, sure. But his plate discipline has dipped slightly over the last few years. If the Pirates want to compete in 2027, they might need to look elsewhere for secondary infield help.

Megan: Nick Yorke is there too. Third base is always a question mark for Pittsburgh.

Steve: Yorke is young. He’s got raw power. But defensively? He’s still developing. I think Lowe stays at second, Griffin takes short, and maybe we see a platoon at third involving Yorke and Gonzalez.

Megan: That sounds like a plan. Let’s move to Segment Two. The bullpen void left by Kirby Yates’ retirement.

Megan: Kirby Yates made his first start Saturday before announcing his retirement. Twelve years in the majors. A two-time All-Star. That’s huge.

Steve: It is. And when you look at the current roster, who steps up? Gregory Soto is obviously the closer. But who handles the setup role?

Megan: Luke Weaver has been reliable. And Hunter Barco has upside. But is that enough to replace Yates’ influence?

Steve: I don’t know. Weaver is good, but he’s prone to giving up big innings if he gets behind in the count. Barco is electric, but he’s inconsistent. This is a area that needs attention.

Megan: What about the younger arms? Lake Bachar, Wilber Dotel, Brandon Eisert...

Steve: They’re options. But relying on unproven guys for high-leverage situations is risky. I think the Pirates need to make a move in free agency or trades to get a proven arm.

Megan: Agreed. No more guessing games in the eighth inning. Speaking of guessing games, let’s talk outfield.

Steve: Outfield is crowded. Bryan Reynolds is the anchor in left field. Oneil Cruz in center. And then you have Ryan O'Hearn, Ronny Simon, Esmerlyn Valdez, and Jake Mangum in right and corner spots.

Megan: O’Hearn provides power, but Simon and Valdez are speed guys. How do you balance that?

Steve: You play to your strengths. Reynolds and Cruz give you defense and contact. O’Hearn gives you middle-of-the-order power. The rest are bench pieces. It’s a balanced group, but not elite.

Megan: Billy Cook is also there. Does he have a shot at playing time?

Steve: Cook is a fourth outfielder type. He’s versatile. But unless someone gets injured, he’s likely a call-up option rather than a starter.

Megan: Okay, let’s wrap up Segment Two. Catching is another spot. Henry Davis and Rafael Flores Jr.

Steve: Davis is the clear starter. He’s improving behind the plate. Flores is a backup. Simple as that. The battle here isn’t really a battle. It’s a confirmation.

Megan: First baseman Spencer Horwitz looks settled too. So the main battles are shortstop and bullpen.

Megan: Segment Three! Roster cut predictions and who’s trending up or down.

Steve: Let’s start with the rotation. Paul Skenes is the ace. Jared Jones is the rising star. Braxton Ashcraft, Bubba Chandler, Khristian Curtis, Thomas Harrington.

Megan: That’s six starters. Who gets sent down?

Steve: Thomas Harrington is the odd man out. He’s had ups and downs. If the Pirates want to be competitive, they need five reliable arms. Harrington might need more minor league seasoning.

Megan: And the bullpen? We have Luke Weaver, Gregory Soto, Hunter Barco, Kirby Yates (retired), plus Isaac Mattson, Carmen Mlodzinski, Mason Montgomery, Noah Murdock, Yohan Ramirez, Evan Sisk, Antwone Kelly, Brandon Eisert, and Lake Bachar.

Steve: Whoa. That’s a lot of arms. Yates is gone. So you have about ten left. Not all will make the team.

Megan: Who’s trending up?

Steve: Hunter Barco. His velocity is up. His strikeout rate is strong. He’s trending up. Greg Soto is steady. Luke Weaver is safe.

Megan: Who’s trending down?

Steve: Evan Sisk. He’s struggled with consistency. And Noah Murdock hasn’t shown much since his debut. Those two are likely candidates for Triple-A.

Megan: So, final roster prediction. Skenes, Jones, Ashcraft, Chandler, Curtis. Soto, Weaver, Barco, Mattson, Mlodzinski.

Steve: Sounds about right. Plus the infielders we discussed. Griffin, Lowe, Gonzalez, Yorke. Reynolds, Cruz, O’Hearn. Davis.

Megan: And that leaves a few extras. Who knows, maybe one of those relievers shocks everyone.

Steve: But realistically, that’s the core. The Pirates are building something special here.

Megan: We covered Griffin at shortstop, the bullpen void, and our roster cuts. Don’t forget, we predict the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027.

Steve: And Konnor Griffin starts at least 100 games at shortstop next year. Mark my words.

Megan: If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share it with a fellow Bucs fan.

Steve: Thanks for listening to The Pirate Press. Go Bucs!