Megan: You are not ready for the answer to this next question. Konnor Griffin just ended an eight-year drought with a walk-off homer, and now the whole league is watching his shortstop spot like a hawk. Stick with us.
Megan: This is the Beatline Podcast Network, America’s number one daily sports podcast. I’m Megan, and I’m joined by Steve. Steve, we did it. We actually broke the streak.
Steve: We did, Megan. 82-80. First winning season in Pittsburgh since... well, you know when it was. It feels surreal looking at that column now after years of staring at the bottom.
Megan: It really does. And before we dive into your mailbag questions, I need to do a quick favor ask. This show runs on your support. Every day, our team digs through the stats, edits the audio, and keeps the feed running so you get this content free. A small coffee helps cover those costs. Just check the link in the episode description. Thank you for keeping us going.
Megan: Alright, let’s get to it. Today is a mailbag episode. We’ve got questions about Konnor Griffin’s future, the bullpen void left by Kirby Yates, and whether that playoff prediction from last week still holds water. Let’s start with Segment One: The Big Picture.
Megan: First up, we have a question from Sarah in Austin. She writes: 'I loved watching Konnor Griffin hit that walk-off home run against Detroit. But he’s listed as a shortstop. Do you think he stays there long-term, or is this just a temporary fix while the farm system catches up?'
Steve: Oh, that was a huge moment. For both teams, technically, since Verlander was saying goodbye. But yeah, Sarah brings up a key point. Griffin played third base earlier in his career, but here he is, locking down shortstop in the final game of the season. It sends a message.
Megan: Right. And remember, in our prediction last time, we said Griffin would start at least 100 games at shortstop in 2027. Looking at the roster depth chart... Jack Brannigan, Jacob Gonzalez, Jared Triolo... none of them feel like franchise cornerstones right now.
Steve: Exactly. Brannigan has tools, but he’s young. Gonzalez is solid defensively but lacks the offensive pop. Griffin has that clutch gene. You saw it Friday night, you saw it Sunday. If he stays healthy, I don’t see why they wouldn’t keep him there. It’s about maximizing his bat while he learns the position.
Megan: Okay, next question comes from @PiratePride99 on X. He asks: 'Kirby Yates retired after just one start. That’s wild. Who steps up in the late innings? The bullpen looked shaky all year.'
Steve: Yates’ retirement is a massive loss. Two-time All-Star, veteran presence. He made his first start Saturday, then hung up the cleats. It’s abrupt. Now you look at the relievers: Lake Bachar, Hunter Barco, Gregory Soto, Luke Weaver... it’s a group of guys who have potential, but no clear closer.
Megan: And that’s the scary part for 2027. Last week we talked about bullpen stability being the #1 priority. Now Yates is gone. Do you think the front office goes out and buys a veteran closer in free agency?
Steve: They probably should. With Yates out, you’re looking at internal options. Brandon Eisert, Antwone Kelly, Isaac Mattson... these are guys who haven’t been tested in high-leverage spots consistently. I’d expect them to target a mid-tier reliever in December. Maybe someone like Evan Sisk gets more looks if he’s ready.
Megan: Evan Sisk. Right. He’s on the roster. Okay, let’s pivot. Segment Two: Roster Battles. We’ve got a question from Marcus in Denver. He wants to know about the infield. Spencer Horwitz at first, Nick Gonzales at third... where does Brandon Lowe fit in?
Steve: Good question, Marcus. Lowe was acquired, presumably to add power. But Horwitz is entrenched at first. Gonzales is playing third. So Lowe has to win second base. Or he becomes a DH/platoon guy. Given the roster construction, he might end up shifting around unless they move someone.
Megan: But wait, what about Nick Yorke? He’s also at third base. So you’ve got Gonzales and Yorke battling for third, Horwitz at first, and Lowe needing a spot. It’s crowded.
Steve: It is crowded. And that’s where platoon splits matter. Yorke is young, aggressive. Gonzales is contact-heavy. If Lowe can play second, he opens up a spot. Otherwise, one of them gets traded or designated. The Pirates aren’t keeping five infielders who can’t hit. They need OBP.
Megan: Speaking of hitting, Bryan Reynolds is back. He’s the heart of this lineup. But Tyler Callihan and Billy Cook are sharing center field duties. Who wins the job outright in spring training?
Steve: Callihan has the speed, but Cook has the experience. Jhostynxon Garcia is also in the mix for outfield spots. It’s going to be a camp battle. I think Callihan gets the nod because of his defensive upside in center, but Cook will be the primary DH/backup outfielder.
Megan: Okay, let’s talk pitching. Paul Skenes is the ace. Braxton Ashcraft, Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler, Thomas Harrington... that’s a deep rotation. Who’s the fifth starter?
Steve: That’s the strength of this team. Skenes, Jones, Ashcraft are top-three locks. Then it’s between Chandler and Harrington for four and five. Harrington has been consistent in the minors. Chandler has the stuff. I’d bet on Harrington starting because he’s proven he can eat innings.
Megan: And Khristian Curtis? He’s on the roster too. Does he push for a spot?
Steve: Curtis is probably the long-shot. Unless he dominates in November, he’s likely heading to Triple-A. The Pirates have too many arms. They’ll need to make a tough call.
Megan: Alright, Segment Three. Fun Hypothetical and Lightning Round. First, hypothetical: If the Pirates had $50 million to spend on ONE position this offseason, where do you put it?
Steve: Bullpen. No question. With Yates gone, you need a reliable setup man and a closer. Spend big on a veteran arm. Maybe bring in someone like Luke Weaver full-time as closer, or add a new name.
Megan: I agree. Defense wins games, but saves win pennants. Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. Henry Davis behind the plate. Good or bad for 2027?
Steve: Good. Solid defender. Rafael Flores Jr. is the backup. Davis is the starter.
Megan: Oneil Cruz in center field. Speed demon. Love it or hate it?
Steve: Love it. He changes the geometry of the outfield. Teams have to respect his speed on the bases.
Megan: Ryan O’Hearn in right field. Power bat. Essential?
Steve: Essential. You need that right-handed power in the lineup.
Megan: Final question from @SteelCityFan. Will the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027? Yes or No?
Steve: Yes. The foundation is there. Skenes, Griffin, Reynolds, a revamped bullpen. They’re going to compete.
Megan: There you have it. The Pirates are coming. 82-80 was just the beginning. Griffin is the face of the franchise, the bullpen needs work, and yes, we still believe in 2027.
Megan: If you enjoyed this mailbag, please subscribe, rate, and review us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Share this episode with a fellow Pirate fan. Let’s get this word out.
Steve: Thanks for listening. Go Bucs.
Megan: I’m Megan, with Steve. Keep cheering loud. We’ll see you tomorrow.