Pirates Power Rankings: Breaking the Curse, The Skenes Factor, and 2027 Playoff Hopes

Pittsburgh Pirates · 2026-10-01 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Megan: Konnor Griffin just sent that ball into the stratosphere in Detroit, sealing an 82-80 record and ending an eight-year drought. But is this a fluke or the real deal? We’re ranking the Pirates right now.

Steve: It’s more than just one home run, Megan. It’s about whether the foundation holds up when you look at the rotation depth and the bullpen usage patterns from this final series against Detroit.

Megan: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Megan, and this is your daily stop for everything baseball. Joining me as always is Steve, our resident analyst who sees the game in ways most fans miss.

Steve: Good morning, everyone. It’s great to be here on this historic day for the Pirates. Eighty-two wins feels like a milestone, but we need to dig into what actually got us there.

Megan: So here is what we are tackling today. First, where do the Pirates actually stand in the NL Central after finishing third? Second, we’re breaking down the strengths of Paul Skenes versus the question marks in the back end of that bullpen. And finally, we’re giving you a realistic outlook and win projection for 2027.

Steve: And we’ll touch on how the retirements of Kirby Yates and Justin Verlander in that same series frame the emotional transition for Pittsburgh’s clubhouse.

Megan: Let’s dive right into Segment One. The standings. The Pirates finished 82-80, which is good, but they were third in the NL Central. That’s not exactly a playoff position. How do you view that standing in the broader context?

Steve: Well, Megan, if you look strictly at the division race, third place means you were out of contention for quite a stretch. But you have to contextualize the strength of schedule and the injuries. This wasn’t a collapse; it was a stabilization.

Megan: Right, because going from sub-.500 to 82 wins is huge. But being third in the Central suggests there’s still a gap between them and the top teams. Did you see the defensive positioning issues that plagued them earlier in the year?

Steve: They did. And frankly, until Konnor Griffin stepped up at shortstop, the infield defense was a liability. Finishing third isn’t a failure when you consider the roster turnover. They held their own against better records.

Megan: Exactly. And let’s not forget the finale. Beating Detroit 4-2, with Griffin hitting that walk-off homer, gave them the winning record. That momentum shift is real. Does that close-out performance change how you view their divisional standing?

Steve: It changes the narrative, yes. But statistically, finishing third means they missed the cutoff by a margin that was likely within one or two games of a wild card spot, depending on how the rest of the league played out. It’s a ‘so close’ season.

Megan: So, no silver medal, but definitely not a bronze. They’re in the thick of the pack. Now, moving to Segment Two. Strengths and weaknesses. Paul Skenes is obviously the crown jewel. What else stands out?

Steve: Skenes is elite, obviously. But the bigger surprise might be Braxton Ashcraft. When he’s healthy, his stuff plays up. And then you have Bryan Reynolds providing consistent offense from left field. The core is young and talented.

Megan: I love that. Reynolds has been the steady hand. But what about the weaknesses? The bullpen looked shaky in that final series against Detroit. Jackson Jobe allowed two runs in five innings, but the Pirates lost that one 8-7 before bouncing back.

Steve: That’s the key. The relief pitching depth is the question mark. You’ve got Gregory Soto, Luke Weaver, and guys like Lake Bachar and Hunter Barco, but consistency is hard to find. After Kirby Yates retired, the veteran presence took a hit.

Megan: Yates retiring after his first start is such a weird chapter. He was a two-time All-Star. His absence leaves a void in terms of leadership, even if his arm isn’t what it used to be.

Steve: It does. And without that high-leverage experience, you rely on younger arms like Noah Murdock or Evan Sisk to step up. That’s risky in tight games. The platoon splits also hurt them sometimes; they struggled against left-handed power late in the season.

Megan: So, strong starting pitching from Skenes and Ashcraft, solid offensive production from Reynolds and Griffin, but a bullpen that needs proven closers. Got it. Before we get to the outlook, I want to pause for a second.

Megan: We know you love the daily breakdowns. But putting together fresh, honest analysis every single day takes time, research, and a lot of coffee. A small contribution from you helps keep this show free and running smoothly. If you can spare a few bucks, please check the link in the episode description. It really keeps the magic alive.

Steve: Thanks for that, Megan. Let’s move to Segment Three. Realistic outlook. Last week we predicted the Pirates would make the playoffs in 2027. With 82 wins this year, does that prediction hold water?

Megan: It’s optimistic! But looking at the roster, with Konnor Griffin potentially starting 100 games at shortstop next year, the upside is massive. Do you think 90 wins is a realistic target?

Steve: I do. If Mitch Keller and Braxton Ashcraft stay healthy, the rotation becomes formidable. Add a healthier bullpen, and those 82 wins easily jump to 90 or 92. The ceiling is higher than the floor.

Megan: I agree. The pieces are there. Henry Davis behind the plate provides stability, and the outfield defense with Oneil Cruz and Tyler Callihan is improving. This feels like a team poised to break through.

Steve: Agreed. My prediction stands: Pittsburgh makes the playoffs in 2027. It won’t be easy, but the trajectory is undeniable. They have the youth, the talent, and now, the belief.

Megan: There you have it. The Pirates broke the curse, Griffin stole the show, and 2027 looks bright. Thanks for listening! Please subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Go Bucs!