Pirates Roster Battles: SS Shuffle & Bullpen Depth

Pittsburgh Pirates · 2026-09-30 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Megan: Is Konnor Griffin the future at shortstop, or is Oneil Cruz still the guy? And with Kirby Yates retiring and Justin Verlander hanging up his cleats, who are the next legends to watch in Pittsburgh? Stick around.

Steve: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network. I’m Steve.

Megan: And I’m Megan. Happy Tuesday, Pirates fans! We just wrapped the 2026 regular season with a historic 82-80 record, beating Detroit 4-2 thanks to that Konnor Griffin homer. But now comes the real fun: the roster battles for 2027.

Steve: Exactly. We secured our first winning season in eight years, but looking at the depth chart, there are some serious questions about where the talent sits right now. Especially in the infield and the bullpen.

Megan: Today we’re breaking down three key areas: the Shortstop shuffle between Griffin, Cruz, and Gonzalez; the Catcher’s room with Henry Davis versus Rafael Flores Jr.; and finally, who makes the cut from this massive relief corps as we look toward spring training.

Steve: It’s going to be a tight race. Let’s dive into Segment One: The Battle for Shortstop.

Megan: Okay, Steve. Last night, Konnor Griffin homered and sealed the win. He’s played SS. But Oneil Cruz has been the everyday starter for years. Where do you stand on this?

Steve: Well, Megan, you have to look at the defensive metrics and the platoon splits. Griffin showed flashes of elite range last night, but Cruz brings the experience. However, if we’re talking pure upside for 2027, Griffin might have the edge.

Megan: I agree he has the tools. But remember back on September 27th, we talked about how injuries were decimating both teams. Griffin’s health is always a question mark.

Steve: Right. And Jacob Gonzalez is also in the mix. He’s got that left-handed bat. If the Pirates want to optimize their lineup against right-handed pitching, Gonzalez becomes very valuable. It’s not just Griffin vs. Cruz anymore.

Megan: So it’s a three-way battle? Griffin, Cruz, and Gonzalez?

Steve: Basically. And don’t forget Nick Yorke can play third, which gives them flexibility. But at shortstop, I think Griffin’s offensive ceiling is higher. If he stays healthy, he wins the job.

Megan: I like that take. Griffin’s walk-off homer showed he can handle the pressure. But Cruz’s veteran presence matters too. This could be a platoon situation early on.

Steve: Platoon makes sense. You start Griffin against righties for that power, and Cruz against lefties for his defense and contact skills. It keeps everyone fresh.

Megan: Let’s move to Segment Two. We’ve got two more battles. First up: Catcher. Henry Davis vs. Rafael Flores Jr.

Steve: This one is closer than people think. Davis has the power, but Flores Jr. has shown better pitch framing in limited action. The pitching staff needs a catcher who can manage the game.

Megan: With Paul Skenes and Jared Jones coming back, having a steady hand behind the plate is crucial. Who do you trust to call the game?

Steve: I’d lean towards Davis for the starting role because of his ability to hit for power. But Flores Jr. might be the utility guy who saves your skin in high-leverage spots.

Megan: Agreed. Now, the big one: The Bullpen. We have Lake Bachar, Hunter Barco, Wilber Dotel, Brandon Eisert, Antwone Kelly, Isaac Mattson, Carmen Mlodzinski, Mason Montgomery, Noah Murdock, Yohan Ramirez, Evan Sisk, Gregory Soto, Luke Weaver... and now Kirby Yates is gone.

Steve: That is a crowded room. With Yates retiring after his first start, the closer role is wide open. Luke Weaver had some good stretches, but he’s inconsistent. Gregory Soto has the stuff, but can he close?

Megan: Soto’s velocity is scary. But I think they’ll go with a committee approach. Maybe Barco takes over setup duties?

Steve: Barco is young and has upside. But watch out for Evan Sisk. He’s been quiet all year, but sometimes those low-profile arms emerge in October. Or rather, in spring training.

Megan: Good point. The competition for those final four or five spots will be fierce. Let’s head to Segment Three: Roster Cuts and Predictions.

Steve: Who’s trending up? Konnor Griffin. That homer wasn’t luck. It was power meeting opportunity. Who’s trending down? Maybe someone like Ryan O’Hearn if he doesn’t show consistent production.

Megan: O’Hearn is solid, but with Bryan Reynolds and Tyler Callihan in the mix, outfield spots are tight. Billy Cook and Jake Mangum are speed guys, so they stay for defense.

Steve: I think the Pirates keep seven pitchers. That means some relievers get sent to Triple-A. It’s going to hurt the fanbase to see names like Noah Murdock or Mason Montgomery leave town.

Megan: But it’s necessary for the 2027 playoff push. Speaking of which, last time we predicted Griffin would earn significant playing time. Did we hit?

Steve: We did. And now I’m doubling down: Griffin starts at least 100 games at shortstop in 2027. He’s too good to bench.

Megan: Bold! I’ll take it. Final prediction: The Pirates make the playoffs in 2027, and Paul Skenes is an All-Star.

Steve: I’m sticking with that. The foundation is there. Skenes, Reynolds, and Griffin form a core that can compete.

Megan: What a season, what a future. Before we go, we need your help. This show is completely free, with zero ads and no paywall, because we love bringing you daily baseball coverage. Your support is what keeps us running. Please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description—it helps us keep the lights on and the analysis sharp.

Steve: Thanks for listening, Pirates fans. Keep that optimism alive. Go Bucs!

Megan: Catch you next time on the Beatline Podcast Network!