Pirates Mailbag: First Winning Season in 8 Years, Kirby Yates Retires, and What's Next?

Pittsburgh Pirates · 2026-09-29 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Megan: Konnor Griffin just launched a walk-off homer to end the season, Paul Skenes is looking like a generational talent, and the Pirates are finally, officially back. But how do you build on that? That’s what we’re answering today.

Steve: It’s been a long road for this franchise. Eight years without a winning record. We broke it down yesterday with Konnor’s hit, but now it’s time to look at the future. The roster, the rotation, the bullpen.

Megan: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Megan, and I’m joined by Steve. This is your daily dose of Pittsburgh Pirates news, analysis, and fan interaction. Today, we’re doing a mailbag. We’ve got questions about the new era, the retirement of Kirby Yates, and where Oneil Cruz fits in.

Steve: That’s right. It’s a big day. The Pirates finished 82-80, third in the NL Central. They beat the Tigers 4-2 in the final game. Justin Verlander cried on the mound, Kirby Yates hung up his cleats, and Konnor Griffin delivered the win. Let’s get into your emails.

Megan: First up, let’s talk about the biggest story. You predicted a sweep against Detroit, Steve. Did you see the 4-2 finish coming?

Steve: I predicted a 5-3 win. Close enough. But the real story isn’t the score. It’s the fact that we have a winning record. For the first time in eight years, the lights are on in Pittsburgh.

Megan: And you said getting Mitch Keller and Braxton Ashcraft healthy was the key for 2027. Are they ready?

Steve: We’ll see. But right now, Paul Skenes is the anchor. He’s dominating. And with Jared Jones and Bubba Chandler, this rotation is scary good.

Megan: Let’s dive into Segment 1. Your questions on the current state of the team.

Megan: First question comes from @BucsFan412. He asks: 'With Konnor Griffin hitting that walk-off homer, is he the everyday shortstop moving forward? Or does Oneil Cruz still hold the job?' This is huge. The infield defense matters.

Steve: Great question. Konnor Griffin had a monster moment. But Oneil Cruz has the experience and the defensive profile. However, Griffin’s bat is real. If he keeps making contact and driving runs, like he did against Detroit, he earns playing time. But Cruz is the veteran leader here.

Megan: So you think they split time? Or maybe Cruz plays more when Griffin needs rest?

Steve: Exactly. You don’t bench Cruz. But if Griffin is hot, he stays in. It’s about maximizing offense while keeping the defense solid. Jacob Gonzalez is also there as depth. The competition is real.

Megan: Next up, Sarah from Pittsburgh asks: 'Kirby Yates retired. Who closes games now? Is Gregory Soto the guy?' The bullpen was shaky all year.

Steve: Gregory Soto is the favorite. He’s had success before. But Luke Weaver and Lake Bachar are options too. It’s a committee until Soto proves he can handle the ninth inning consistently. Kirby Yates was a legend here, so it’s a tough hole to fill.

Megan: Agreed. Kirby Yates deserves all the applause. He made his first start Saturday before retiring. A classy move. Next question from Marcus in Oakdale: 'Did the Pirates miss the playoffs because of the injuries or just bad luck?'

Steve: Both. Ten players on the injured list at one point. You can’t win with ten guys out. But even with a full roster, the NL Central is tough. The standings were tight. 82-80 is good, but it wasn’t enough for October.

Megan: Right. And Brian Reynolds was solid all year. Bryan Reynolds kept them in games. But the pitching depth was tested. Spencer Horwitz at first base was a bright spot though. He’s young and improving.

Steve: Spencer Horwitz is key. His plate discipline helps the lineup. And Billy Cook in center field? He’s fast. He creates problems on the bases. These are the pieces that add up to 82 wins.

Megan: Last question for this segment from @PirateSlayer: 'Is Paul Skenes the Cy Young favorite next year?'

Steve: He should be. He’s dominant. If he stays healthy, he’s top three. Maybe top two. The strikeout numbers are insane. He’s the face of the franchise now.

Megan: The face of the franchise. Love it. Let’s take a quick break. We’ll be back with roster battles and some fun hypotheticals. Stick with us.

Megan: Welcome back. Segment 2. Roster battles. We’ve got depth chart questions. First up, Tom from Erie asks: 'Who is the starting catcher? Henry Davis or Rafael Flores Jr.?'

Steve: Henry Davis. No contest. He’s more experienced. He handles the pitching staff better. Rafael Flores Jr. is a prospect, but Davis is the everyday guy. He’s got power and defensive skills behind the plate.

Megan: Does Flores get called up later in the season? Or is he staying in the minors?

Steve: If Davis struggles, Flores could be an option. But right now, Davis is the starter. The Pirates need him to produce offensively. He’s not just a defensive catcher.

Megan: Next, Jessica in Monroeville asks: 'Where does Ryan O'Hearn fit? Is he the everyday first baseman over Spencer Horwitz?'

Steve: O’Hearn is a platoon piece. He hits lefties well. Horwitz hits righties better. So you play both. It’s a platoon system. O’Hearn provides power, Horwitz provides contact and speed. Together, they’re stronger.

Megan: So no single everyday first baseman? That’s unusual for this team.

Steve: It’s smart baseball. Why pick one when you can maximize matchups? Brandon Lowe at second base stabilizes the middle infield. Nick Gonzales adds flexibility. The infield is deep.

Megan: What about the outfield? Oneil Cruz, Billy Cook, Jake Mangum, Ryan O'Hearn, Ronny Simon. Who starts every day?

Steve: Cruz in center. O’Hearn in right. Bryan Reynolds in left. That’s the core. Cook and Mangum provide speed and defense off the bench. Simon is a rookie who needs development. It’s a strong outfield.

Megan: Strong outfield. Good defense. Next question from @SteelCityFan: 'Will the Pirates sign any free agents this offseason?'

Steve: Maybe. They have budget constraints. But they might look for bullpen help. Or a backup infielder. They won’t go big. They’ll try to improve the margins. Keep the core intact.

Megan: Core intact. Paul Skenes, Jared Jones, Bryan Reynolds, Spencer Horwitz. Those are the guys. Now, before we get to our fun segment, we need to talk about something important.

Megan: Hey everyone. We love bringing you this daily show, but it takes work. Research, editing, keeping the feed running—your support makes it possible. If you enjoy the podcasts, please check out the link in the episode description to chip in. Even a small coffee helps keep the show free and daily. Thanks for listening!

Megan: Alright, Segment 3. Fun hypotheticals and lightning round. First, @PirateQueen asks: 'If you could trade away one player from the current roster to get a Hall of Famer, who goes?'

Steve: That’s a trick question. You don’t trade anyone. This team is built for the future. You keep the core. Maybe you trade a bench player. But not a starter. Not Paul Skenes. Definitely not Bryan Reynolds.

Megan: Right. You don’t tear it down. You build around Skenes. Lightning round. Quick answers. Konnor Griffin’s homer was...?

Steve: Clutch. Instant classic.

Megan: Justin Verlander’s farewell was...?

Steve: Emotional. Beautiful. He deserved that sendoff.

Megan: Kirby Yates’ retirement...?

Steve: Sad. But fitting. A great career.

Megan: NL Central standings...?

Steve: Tough. Always tough.

Megan: Final prediction. Will the Pirates make the playoffs in 2027?

Steve: Yes. If Skenes stays healthy. And if the bullpen holds together. I see them in the wildcard race.

Megan: Bold call. But I agree. The foundation is there. Konnor Griffin’s homer was the spark. Now it’s time to fuel the fire.

Megan: That’s it for today. The Pirates are 82-80. First winning season in eight years. Thank you for listening. Subscribe, rate, review, and share the podcast. Go Pirates!

Steve: See you tomorrow. Stay tuned.