Pirates vs Tigers Preview: Skenes Returns, Injuries Mount

Pittsburgh Pirates · 2026-09-26 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Megan: Eight runs on the board. A six-run lead that nearly vanished in the eighth inning. And a final score of 8-7 against Detroit last night. If you missed it, that was a wild one. But we are not dwelling on it here at Beatline.

Steve: Right. Jackson Jobe gave up two runs in five and a third, and Spencer Torkelson came up just short of a cycle. It’s a gritty loss for Pittsburgh, but this is preview season now. The focus shifts entirely to what happens next.

Megan: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, your daily home for all things baseball. I’m Megan, and I’m joined by Steve. Today, we are looking ahead to tonight’s matchup between the Pittsburgh Pirates and the Detroit Tigers. It’s a continuation of their series, with Pittsburgh sitting at 81-79 and Detroit at 74-85.

Steve: And both teams are fighting for pride in the standings. The Pirates are third in the NL Central, while the Tigers are fourth in the AL Central. No playoffs, but plenty of momentum to build or kill before October.

Megan: Here is what we are covering today. First, we break down the pitching matchup and see if Paul Skenes can bounce back after his final regular-season start. Second, we dive into the offensive keys, specifically how the Pirates’ depleted roster handles Detroit’s lineup. And finally, we look at the injury report, which is frankly scary right now, and give our bold predictions for the series.

Megan: Let’s start with the rotation. We know Paul Skenes finished his 2026 campaign with a 10-11 record and a 3.82 ERA. He said Thursday he won’t dwell on the season, but tonight is a new day. Who is starting for Detroit?

Steve: It looks like they will lean on their remaining starters. Given the context of last night, where Jackson Jobe struggled, Detroit might be trying to stabilize their outing. But for Pittsburgh, the question is whether they go with someone else or stick with the plan.

Megan: Wait, hold on. Earlier this week, we talked about Jared Jones dominating recently. With Mitch Keller and Braxton Ashcraft both on the 60-day IL, the rotation is incredibly thin. Do they have anyone left who can match Jones' energy?

Steve: That’s the crux of it. You have Bubba Chandler, Antwone Kelly, and obviously Skenes still in the mix for these final games. But the depth chart is getting stripped down. Last night, Jobe allowed two runs in just over five innings. That’s not the quality we want to see if they want to win this series.

Megan: Exactly. And remember, the Tigers hung on to beat the Pirates 8-7 despite that six-run lead. They clearly have some punch. If Skenes goes out there, he needs to keep the ball in the park early. One bad inning turns into an 8-7 game again.

Steve: Agreed. Launch angle matters more than ever here. Detroit has guys like Torkelson who can turn a ground ball into extra bases. Skenes needs to induce weak contact or strikeouts. If he allows hard contact, the bullpen—already decimated—is going to get exposed immediately.

Megan: Speaking of the bullpen, we’ll get to that in a second. But first, let’s talk about the ABS challenge system tracker. The headlines mention team and player rankings. Where does Pittsburgh stand in terms of challenging umpire calls this year?

Steve: It’s a strategic element. Teams are using challenges wisely. For a squad like Pittsburgh, which relies on small-ball tactics and precise plate discipline, every call counts. If they are getting borderline strikes called against them, saving those challenges for high-leverage situations could be the difference in a tight game like last night’s.

Megan: Right. So, my take for Segment 1 is that the Pirates need to win the pitching battle outright. They can’t rely on outscoring Detroit in a slugfest. They need to shut them down. Steve, do you agree, or do you think the offense picks up the slack?

Steve: I disagree slightly. The offense has shown flashes. Ronny Simon racing home on Spencer Horwitz’s sac fly in the Cardinals game was huge. But against Detroit? I think the pitching holds the line. If Skenes pitches well, they win. If he struggles, the bullpen is too thin to recover.

Megan: So it all comes down to Skenes tonight. Let’s move into Segment 2. We have to talk about the injuries. This list is getting longer every day. Ten players on the injured list. That is massive.

Steve: It’s brutal. Jack Flaherty, Justin Verlander, Kyle Finnegan, Burch Smith, Parker Meadows, Esmerlyn Valdez, Isaac Mattson, Mitch Keller, Braxton Ashcraft, Endy Rodriguez. That’s ten names. For Pittsburgh, losing Keller and Ashcraft hurts the rotation, but losing guys like Rodriguez impacts the infield defense significantly.

Megan: And for Detroit, losing Verlander and Finnegan changes their entire approach. They don’t have their ace or their closer. Does that make the Pirates favorites tonight?

Steve: It definitely opens the door. Gregory Soto is with Pittsburgh now, and he’s a veteran presence in the bullpen. With Kirby Yates also there, they have some experienced arms. But the workload is the issue. Luke Weaver, Carmen Mlodzinski, Evan Sisk—they are being stretched thin.

Megan: Let’s talk offense then. Who is stepping up? We saw Ronny Simon make big plays. What about Oneil Cruz? He’s in center field, but his bat is crucial.

Steve: Cruz is vital. His ability to hit for average and get on base is key for a team missing so much power. Bryan Reynolds is always a threat in left field. And Spencer Horwitz, driving in runs like he did against St. Louis, is the engine here.

Megan: What about Brandon Lowe? He’s at second base. Does he provide the power spike they need against Detroit’s shaky pitching?

Steve: Lowe has been solid. Platoon splits favor him against left-handed pitching. If Detroit starts a lefty, Lowe becomes even more dangerous. Pair him with Nick Gonzales at third, and the middle infield is strong. That’s a bright spot for Pittsburgh.

Megan: I love that. Gonzalez and Lowe. Strong defense, good contact. But here is the reality check: the injury list is scary. How many guys do you think they need to activate from the minors or call up to fill these spots?

Steve: They might not have many options left. Jacob Gonzalez and Konnor Griffin are at shortstop. Rafael Flores Jr. is catching behind Henry Davis. The roster is compressed. Every single player tonight has to perform above their typical level. There is no margin for error.

Megan: Before we get to our predictions, I want to take a quick moment to ask for your help. Our show is completely free, with zero ads and no paywall. That’s only possible because listeners like you chip in to keep us running. If you enjoy our deep dives and honest takes, please consider supporting us via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep the lights on and the stories flowing.

Steve: Thanks for that, Megan. Now, let’s lock in our keys to the series. We’ve covered pitching, injuries, and offense. What is the one thing that decides this game for Pittsburgh?

Megan: For me, it’s early outs. Last night, they blew a six-run lead. That means they got into trouble late. If they can avoid baserunners in the first three innings, the Tigers’ young arms will fatigue, and Pittsburgh’s steady hitters will capitalize.

Steve: I agree. Control the strike zone. Plate discipline is everything when you’re facing tired arms. Don’t chase sliders outside. Wait for the pitch you can drive. Also, defensive positioning. Detroit hits to gaps. Shift the defense accordingly.

Megan: Okay, bold predictions time. On September 23rd, Steve, you predicted a 4-2 Pirates victory against the Cardinals. Then on the 24th, you went with 5-3. Last night, we lost 8-7. So, what is your prediction for tonight against Detroit?

Steve: I’m going to adjust. With the injuries piling up, I think Detroit fights hard. But I think Pittsburgh’s experience in close games pays off. I predict a 5-3 Pirates victory. Skenes dominates, and the bullpen holds on.

Megan: Interesting shift. I had predicted the Pirates would win two out of three earlier in the series. I’m sticking with that spirit. I think they sweep this series. Why? Because Detroit is reeling from that loss, and Pittsburgh has the momentum of securing their first non-losing season since 2018.

Steve: A sweep? That’s bold. But given the Tigers’ own injuries, it’s plausible. However, I’ll hedge slightly. I think they win one more, maybe split the final two. But I respect the confidence, Megan.

Megan: We’ll see how it plays out on the field. Tonight, the Pirates host the Tigers. Key storylines: Paul Skenes bouncing back, a depleted roster pushing through, and the quest for series pride. Thanks for listening to the Beatline.

Steve: If you enjoyed this preview, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share it with a friend who loves the Pirates. Let’s keep this community growing.

Megan: Up, Pukes! See you tomorrow for another episode.