Sarah: You’re listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. If you love baseball, you are in the right place.
Tom: I’m Tom, and I am ready to dive into the stats.
Sarah: And I’m Sarah. Today is a mailbag episode, folks. We have questions coming in from all over about that insane 74-88 record that somehow still won us the NL East, the pursuit of Tarik Skubal, and who exactly is starting on Opening Day.
Tom: It’s a fascinating structural anomaly. The standings don’t always reflect the talent level, but they do reflect the wins. And we have plenty of wins to dissect.
Sarah: We’ve got three big segments. First, we tackle the Skubal pursuit and what it means for the rotation. Then, we break down those crazy roster battles at catcher and third base. Finally, a lightning round of quick takes. But first, let’s get to your questions.
Sarah: Starting with @MetFan99 in Queens. He asks: 'If the Mets sign Tarik Skubal, does Sean Manaea get moved? Is there room for both?'
Tom: That is the million-dollar question. Right now, the Mets have Sean Manaea and Tylor Megill as their clear top two starters. Robert Stock was just re-signed, and he’s a veteran arm. If you bring in Skubal, you’re looking at four elite arms.
Sarah: But here’s the thing, Tom. The rotation isn’t just Manaea and Megill. You have Nolan McLean, Christian Scott, Jonah Tong, and Zac Thornton. It’s crowded.
Tom: Exactly. And remember, Skubal is a lefty. Manaea is a lefty. You can’t play two lefties in the same spot every day unless you’re managing a specific platoon advantage, which is rare for a true ace like Skubal. He needs to be the number one.
Sarah: So, if Skubal comes in, Manaea might have to shift or become a high-leverage reliever? That seems drastic.
Tom: It’s possible. Or, the Mets trade Manaea. His value is high because he’s a proven starter. Moving him to the bullpen would be a massive risk given his age and recent workload. I think the more likely move is keeping the rotation tight and letting the competition happen in spring training.
Sarah: Next up, Marcus in Denver asks: 'How did we win 74 games and take the division? Did everyone else just suck?'
Tom: Well, Marcus, it wasn’t just that everyone else sucked. It was that the NL East was historically weak. A 74-88 record winning a division is a statistical outlier. It shows how parity works when no team crosses the 80-win threshold.
Sarah: But our bullpen was real. Devin Williams, Reed Garrett, Jack Anderson... that relief corps kept games close even when the offense was quiet.
Tom: Right. The defense behind them helped too. Francisco Lindor and Bo Bichette (wait, Bichette is at third this year?) provided stability. Actually, checking the roster, Bichette is listed at third base. That’s a new look.
Sarah: Yes! Bichette at third. That changes the infield dynamics completely. We’ll get to that in segment two. Next question from Sarah in Rochester: 'What is the plan for the catcher situation? Alvarez vs. Torrens?'
Tom: This is a classic internal competition. Francisco Alvarez is young, has huge power potential, but his defense behind the plate is still developing. Luis Torrens is the experienced vet. He’s solid defensively but doesn’t offer the same upside.
Sarah: So, who starts? I feel like Alvarez gets the nod eventually because of his bat. But Torrens might hold the job longer in spring training.
Tom: I agree. Alvarez is the future. The team might use Torrens early in the season to keep Alvarez fresh, or maybe even trade Torrens if a deal comes up. But for now, it’s a battle.
Sarah: Let’s pause here. Before we dive into the roster battles, we need to talk about something important. This show is free, daily, and without ads or paywalls. That only works because listeners like you chip in to support the work. If you want to keep Beatline independent and ad-free, please check out the link in the episode description. Every bit helps keep the mic hot.
Tom: Thanks, Sarah. Let’s get into those roster battles. @BaseballNerdNYC asks: 'With Bo Bichette moving to third base, where does Brett Baty go? Is he out of luck?'
Sarah: Oh, this is a tough one. Baty has been a staple at third. Now Bichette is there. Baty is also playing first base sometimes. Mark Vientos is there too. And Christopher Morel is on the roster as well.
Tom: It’s a logjam. Baty is a versatile infielder. He could move to second base, but Marcus Semien and Kyren Paris are there. He might end up as a super-utility player or get traded. The Mets have too many bats for too few spots.
Sarah: Do you think they trade someone? Maybe Baty or Vientos?
Tom: I think they explore trades. Vientos has been injury-prone. Baty has more consistency. But neither is a guaranteed everyday starter anymore. The team might look to upgrade elsewhere if they can package these guys.
Sarah: Next question from Jen in Chicago: 'Who is the closer? Devin Williams or Reed Garrett?'
Tom: Devin Williams is an All-Star caliber reliever. He’s been dominant when healthy. Reed Garrett is reliable but not quite in Williams’ class. Unless Williams is dealing with injuries, he’s the guy.
Sarah: But Williams has had health issues. Garrett has been consistent. Do you trust Williams to stay healthy?
Tom: That’s the gamble. If Williams is 100%, he’s the closer. If not, Garrett steps up. The Mets have enough depth in the bullpen—Jack Anderson, Justin Hagenman, Cionel Perez—to handle either scenario.
Sarah: Last question for this segment from @MetsMagic: 'Is Kodai Senga staying? He’s listed as RP now.'
Tom: Interesting note. Senga was a starter last year. Moving him to the bullpen makes sense if the rotation is full with Skubal, Manaea, Megill, and others. His stuff translates well to relief.
Sarah: Do you think he prefers that? Or will he fight for a spot in the rotation?
Tom: He’ll probably take whatever role gives him the best opportunity to succeed. If the bullpen is deep, he might find a niche there. But I suspect he’d prefer starting.
Sarah: Alright, let’s light it up. Lightning round! First hypothetical: If the Mets sign Skubal AND acquire a star hitter, do they make the World Series?
Tom: They’d be favorites. Skubal anchors the rotation, and adding a bat strengthens an offense that was mediocre last year. But the NL East is competitive.
Sarah: Agreed. Quick takes: 1. Juan Soto is going to crush it in LF. 2. The bullpen is deeper than anyone thinks. 3. Eric Wagaman is definitely moving.
Tom: I’ll add: 4. Mark Vientos needs to stay healthy. 5. Francisco Alvarez will hit 20 home runs by July.
Sarah: And 6. The Mets will win 86 games next year, just like we said before!
Tom: We’ll see about that. But the data supports it.
Sarah: Thanks for listening! Subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Met fan.
Tom: Go Mets.
Sarah: See you tomorrow!