Sarah: You can’t make this stuff up. Eighty-eight losses. First place in the NL East. The baseball world is still scratching its head over how the New York Mets pulled off the greatest collapse-induced miracle in modern sports history.
Tom: It’s a statistical anomaly that will be studied for decades. But while the rest of MLB is confused, the Mets are already looking at the hot stove and trying to figure out who actually belongs on this team for 2027.
Tom: Hey everyone. We’re diving deep into roster battles today. It’s November, so the dust has settled on the season, but the real drama is just beginning.
Sarah: Here is what we are covering today: First, we break down the bizarre new reality of Bo Bichette playing third base. Second, we look at the catcher’s room and whether Francisco Alvarez has truly won the job. And finally, we predict which veterans are getting cut before spring training.
Tom: Right. We talked about Bo staying yesterday, but seeing him listed at third base on the official roster? That changes the entire defensive geometry of this infield.
Sarah: Let’s get right into it. Segment One: The most important position battle right now. Bo Bichette exercised his $42 million option. He’s not going anywhere. But he’s moving from shortstop to third.
Tom: It’s a massive shift. You have Brett Baty coming back from injury, Ronny Mauricio in the mix, and now Bo. For those who don’t know, Bo was drafted as an infielder but played mostly second base early in his career with Toronto. Third base is a different animal.
Sarah: And we have Francisco Lindor locked in at shortstop. So Bo isn’t fighting for a starting job; he’s being installed there. What does that do to the defensive metrics?
Tom: It’s a gamble on offense. Bo has elite plate discipline and launch angle data. He’s a high-OBP machine. At third, you sacrifice some range, but you keep his bat in the lineup. If Brett Baty can’t stay healthy, Bo becomes your everyday third baseman.
Sarah: But what if Baty IS healthy? Do you bench Bo? Or do you play both? Because having two power hitters like that creates a platoon issue if one side of the stadium is tough against lefties.
Tom: That’s the tactical question. If Baty is good enough to start, Bo might need to be the designated hitter or move to first base occasionally. But the roster lists him at third. That tells me management believes his bat is too valuable to sit, even if his defense takes a step back.
Sarah: So, Bo is the starter unless Baty forces their hand. What about Christian Cairo? He’s listed at shortstop too. Does he have any shot at displacing Lindor?
Tom: Not really. Lindor is an All-Star caliber defender. Cairo is more of a utility guy here. The battle is really between Bo and Brett Baty for the hot corner spot. And honestly? Bo wins it by default because of his contract and experience.
Sarah: Okay, so Bo is the man at third. Let’s pivot. Segment Two: Two more battles. First up, the catching corps. Francisco Alvarez, Hayden Senger, Luis Torrens. Who starts behind the plate?
Tom: This is interesting. Alvarez is the future. He’s young, he hits for power, and he’s been developing his framing. But Torrens has experience. Senger is likely a depth piece or trade bait.
Sarah: Alvarez had a breakout year last season. Do you trust him to handle Sean Manaea’s pitching staff full-time?
Tom: I think they split time. Alvarez gets the bulk of the starts because his bat is elite for a catcher. But Torrens stays on the roster to mentor him and handle games when Alvarez needs a day off. Senger is probably gone unless he shows something huge in October workouts.
Sarah: What about the infield again? Marcus Semien at second base. Is he locked in? Or is Kyren Paris pushing him?
Tom: Semien is the veteran presence. He knows the system. Paris is athletic, but Semien’s contact skills and ability to hit behind Lindor make him the safer bet for a contender mindset. Even after a bad year, teams often stick with proven commodities.
Sarah: So Semien holds the job. And what about first base? Mark Vientos, Christopher Morel, Eric Wagaman. It’s crowded.
Tom: Vientos is the clear favorite if he stays healthy. Morel is a wild card—great power, questionable consistency. Wagaman... well, remember our prediction yesterday? We said he’d be moved. The data doesn’t support him starting over Vientos.
Sarah: Morel is intriguing though. He’s got that raw power. Could he steal playing time from Vientos if Vientos struggles early?
Tom: He could. But until Vientos proves he’s broken, he’s the incumbent. This roster construction screams 'win-now' despite the record. They aren’t rebuilding; they’re patching holes.
Sarah: Let’s talk about the bullpen. This is where the magic happened last year. Kodai Senga moved to relief. Devin Williams added. Who else is competing for spots?
Tom: Senga is a lock. Williams is a lock. Then you have Reed Garrett, Jack Anderson, Daniel Duarte. It’s a mess of arms. Tobias Myers and Dedniel Nunez are also there.
Sarah: Who is trending down? Who is in danger of being cut?
Tom: Eric Wagaman. Again. We predicted it yesterday. He’s not hitting well enough to justify a roster spot when you have Vientos and Morel. He’s likely traded or released.
Sarah: And in the bullpen? Who is the odd man out?
Tom: Daniel Duarte. He’s reliable, but not elite. If they need a fifth starter, maybe he goes. But for pure bullpen cuts, I think Jonathan Pintaro or Pierson Ohl are vulnerable. They’re minor league options who haven’t forced the issue.
Sarah: So Wagaman is gone. Pintaro or Ohl go. And maybe Senger if Alvarez dominates. That clears up a lot of space.
Tom: Exactly. The Mets are trimming fat. They have the core—Lindor, Bichette, Alvarez, Senga, Williams—and they’re surrounding them with cheaper, flexible arms.
Sarah: Before we wrap up, I want to take a quick moment. If these daily breakdowns help you navigate your morning commute or keep you ahead of the news cycle, a small tip through the link in the episode description keeps this show free and daily. It means the world to us.
Tom: We’ll see you tomorrow. We’re predicting the Mets improve to 85-90 wins next year. It’s going to be fun.
Sarah: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go Mets!