Mets Roster Battles: The Senga Relief Experiment & Infield Chaos

New York Mets · 2026-10-25 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Sarah: You are looking at a 74-win team that somehow sits atop the NL East, and I am trying to figure out if we are looking at a fluke or a franchise reset. We have Juan Soto in left field, Bo Bichette at third base, and a bullpen that looks like a science experiment involving Kodai Senga.

Tom: It is not a fluke, Sarah. It is structural chaos managed by David Stearns. But right now, the roster is fluid. We are talking about position battles that haven't been settled because the season ended on a high note but with clear questions hanging over the depth chart.

Sarah: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Sarah, and this is your daily dive into the New York Mets. Tom is here to break down the tactical reality behind those 74 wins. Before we get into the meat of today’s roster battles, we want to say thank you. You keep this show free and daily, and if you’ve enjoyed our deep dives into the Senga experiment and the Alonso exit, please consider supporting us via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep bringing you this level of analysis every single day.

Tom: Thanks for listening, everyone. Today we are focusing on three specific areas where the Mets need to make decisions before spring training. First, the starting rotation who actually gets the ball. Second, the infield logjam created by new acquisitions. And third, the bullpen arms that might be sleeping on the couch.

Sarah: We’ve got a lot to cover. Let’s jump straight into Segment One: The Starting Rotation Battle. Who is locking down the back end of the staff?

Tom: Okay, so look at the names on the roster list. We have Sean Manaea, Nolan McLean, Christian Scott, Robert Stock, Zac Thornton, Jonah Tong. That is six starters. But we know the front office wants stability. The battle isn't just who starts Game 1; it's who survives the first month of injuries.

Sarah: Right. And we talked yesterday about how weird the 74-88 record was. They won the division despite that win total. How does that impact the rotation strategy? Are they going to ride the horses harder?

Tom: They have to. If you look at the pitching metrics from last year, the rotation was thin. Sean Manaea is the anchor. He’s the ace. But behind him, it’s a toss-up between Christian Scott and Robert Stock. Stock has experience, but Scott has upside. Then you have Nolan McLean, who is young and raw.

Sarah: So it’s essentially a four-man rotation with two guys fighting for the fifth spot? What about the veterans like Zac Thornton or Jonah Tong?

Tom: Thornton and Tong are likely competition camp invites. They aren’t locking down spots yet. The real battle is between Stock and Scott. Stock knows the system. Scott has the stuff. If Scott’s command doesn’t click early, Stock is there. It’s a classic veteran vs. prospect dynamic.

Sarah: And where does Kodai Senga fit in? We know he’s listed as a reliever now, but his arm is built for starting. Does he eat up innings in the rotation when someone gets hurt?

Tom: That is the key question. Senga in the bullpen has been a massive success story. He provides a high-leverage option that doesn’t rely on pitch count limits. But if the rotation breaks, yes, he can slide back. However, the front office seems committed to keeping him in relief to maximize his value against lineups.

Sarah: Got it. So Manaea is the one, Senga is the swingman/reliever hybrid, and then it’s a fight for the rest. Let’s move to Segment Two: The Infield Logjam. This is where things get messy.

Tom: Oh, this is interesting. Look at the positions. We have Bo Bichette at third base. We have Francisco Lindor at shortstop. We have Marcus Semien at second base. And then we have Christopher Morel and Mark Vientos and Eric Wagaman all listed at first base.

Sarah: Wait, Bo Bichette at third? That was a shocker when it happened. Is he settling in there? I remember the defensive concerns from last time.

Tom: He is settling in. His range is still limited compared to Lindor, but his arm is strong enough for third. The bigger issue is the infield defense alignment. When Lindor is in, he covers more ground. When Bichette is at third, you need better positioning from Semien and the outfielders.

Sarah: And what about the first base battle? We lost Pete Alonso. Now we have Morel, Vientos, Wagaman, and Jared Young. That’s four guys for one job.

Tom: It’s a mess. Christopher Morel brings power but low OBP. Mark Vientos is the most polished hitter but struggles with strikeouts. Eric Wagaman is the utility piece. And Jared Young is the defensive specialist. David Stearns said no mulligans on the Alonso exit, which means they are building around these guys.

Sarah: So who wins the job? I’m hearing whispers that Wagaman might be moved, like we predicted on the podcast recently.

Tom: I think Wagaman is the most likely to be traded or released. He doesn’t offer a clear path to playing time over Vientos or Morel. Vientos has the bat. Morel has the pop. The battle is really between them. Maybe Semien plays some first occasionally, but that’s niche usage.

Sarah: And what about the catchers? We have Francisco Alvarez, Hayden Senger, and Luis Torrens. Alvarez had a breakout year. Is he the undisputed starter?

Tom: Alvarez is the starter. No debate. His offensive profile is elite for a catcher. Senger and Torrens are backups. Senger is great defensively but hits for average issues. Torrens is a project. Alvarez is the face of the franchise at the plate. He needs to stay healthy.

Sarah: Agreed. Alvarez is the star. Okay, let’s head into Segment Three: The Bullpen Depth Chart and Roster Cuts. This is where the magic happens with Senga, but who else is there?

Tom: The bullpen is loaded with arms. Devin Williams is the closer. He’s an All-Star caliber arm. Then you have Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, Justin Hagenman, Nate Lavender, Chayce McDermott, Tobias Myers, Dedniel Nunez, Cionel Perez, Jonathan Pintaro, Dylan Ross, Austin Warren, Jack Weisenburger, Cameron Weston, and Jefry Yan.

Sarah: Wow. That is a huge list. Devin Williams is the anchor, obviously. But who are the other setup guys? It seems like there are too many arms for the active roster.

Tom: Exactly. This is where the cuts happen. Cionel Perez has been solid in the past. Dedniel Nunez has velocity. But the competition will be fierce. Guys like Dustin May—wait, he’s not on the list. Right, he’s gone. So it’s Perez, Nunez, and maybe McDermott for the middle relief spots.

Sarah: So it’s Williams, Perez, Nunez, and Senga as the core four? What about the lefties? Do we have a dedicated lefty specialist?

Tom: Daniel Duarte is a lefty reliever. He could slot in there. Or maybe Cionel Perez handles some lefty matchups. It depends on how the spring training goes. But realistically, only five or six arms make the trip to St. Petersburg.

Sarah: Who do you think gets cut? Who is trending down?

Tom: I think Jonathan Pintaro and Dylan Ross are in danger. They don’t have standout stats or pedigree. Austin Warren might also be vulnerable. The Mets need balance. If they keep Senga, they need reliable arms. Pintaro and Ross might be the ones to go.

Sarah: Interesting. So the final bullpen looks like Williams, Senga, Perez, Nunez, Duarte, and one wild card. That leaves a lot of guys without jobs. It’s a good problem to have, but it creates pressure on the bench.

Tom: Pressure on the bench players too. Carson Benge, A.J. Ewing, Nick Morabito, Cristian Pache—they are fighting for the last outfield spot. Juan Soto is locked in left. But center and right are open. Ewing has speed. Benge has power. It’s tight.

Sarah: Alright, Tom. Final thoughts on the roster battles. What is the biggest surprise you see coming out of camp?

Tom: Bo Bichette at third base sticking. If he defends well enough, it opens up shortstop for Lindor to play more second or even DH. That flexibility changes the entire lineup construction. It’s a bold move, but it could pay off.

Sarah: Bold moves. That’s what the Mets are all about. From the Senga experiment to the Bichette shift, this team is reshaping itself in real time. Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline Podcast Network!

Tom: Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review. Your support keeps us digging into these details. See you tomorrow for more Mets coverage.

Sarah: Let’s go Mets!