Mets Mailbag: 74 Wins, First Place, and the Alonso Ghost

New York Mets · 2026-10-24 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Sarah: You’re listening to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we don’t just cover the game—we live it. Welcome back, Mets fans. If you think a 74-win season is boring, you haven’t been paying attention this October.

Tom: It’s Wild Card Saturday. We are sitting in first place in the NL East with a record that defies conventional baseball logic. I’m Tom.

Sarah: And I’m Sarah. Today is a mailbag episode, so let’s get right into it. We’ve got three big topics: the Pete Alonso exit, the weird bullpen usage of Kodai Senga, and what’s actually happening with Bo Bichette at third base.

Tom: Right. And remember, we predicted last week that this team would make the NLCS. We stand by that. But first, let’s answer your questions about how they got here.

Sarah: Let’s dive into Segment One. Marcus from Queens asks: 'David Stearns said there are no mulligans on the Pete Alonso exit. How do you look at this roster now without him compared to last year?' Great question, Marcus.

Tom: Well, Marcus, if you look at the lineup construction, the Mets didn't just replace power; they replaced plate discipline. You have Juan Soto and Francisco Alvarez now anchoring the top two spots. That changes the entire run environment for the middle of the order.

Sarah: Exactly. And while Alonso was a monster in the Bronx, he wasn't exactly a model of OBP consistency. With Soto leading off or hitting second, you’re seeing more walks, more pitches for the rest of the lineup to see.

Tom: But here’s the nuance: the defense behind them has shifted. You’ve got Brett Baty at third and Bo Bichette also at third? No, wait, Bichette is at shortstop, Baty at third. The infield alignment is different. It’s less about raw power and more about platoon splits.

Sarah: Which brings us to our next question. @SodaPopNYC asks: 'Is the bullpen really that bad? We have Devin Williams, but then who? It feels like a lottery ticket every night.'

Tom: That’s the structural flaw we talked about. Yes, Devin Williams is an elite closer. But look at the depth. You’ve got Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, Justin Hagenman, Nate Lavender, Chayce McDermott... it’s a long list of relievers who are either recovering from injury or finding their role.

Sarah: And Tobias Myers? Cionel Perez? They’re talented, but can you trust them in a one-run game in October? That’s the fear. The front office knew this going in. They prioritized the starting rotation and the core hitters over bullpen depth.

Tom: Which is why the strategic use of Kodai Senga in the bullpen was so critical. It wasn’t just a gimmick; it was a way to keep his stuff fresh while giving the actual relievers a breather. Smart management of resources.

Sarah: Speaking of rotations, Rachel in Brooklyn wants to know: 'Sean Manaea had a solid year, but what about the guys behind him? Is Zac Thornton ready for a bigger role?'

Tom: Zac Thornton has upside, but right now, the rotation is anchored by Manaea, Christian Scott, and Nolan McLean. You also have Jonah Tong and Robert Stock pitching out of the pen or as long man. It’s not a traditional five-starter setup anymore.

Sarah: It’s flexible. And in the playoffs, that flexibility might be your best asset. Let’s move to Segment Two. Roster battles.

Sarah: Stick with us. We’re breaking down the infield logjam and what it means for 2027.

Tom: Okay, Segment Two. Chris in Jersey asks: 'Bo Bichette to third base? Isn’t that a defensive downgrade? Why not keep him at short?'

Sarah: Great point, Chris. You have Francisco Lindor at short. He’s still one of the best defenders in the game. Putting Bichette at third allows you to keep both elite bats in the lineup. It’s an offensive play disguised as a positional change.

Tom: But defensively, yes, it’s a risk. Bichette isn’t Lindor. However, if you look at the pitch framing and the defensive shifts against left-handed hitters, the Mets are trying to maximize launch angle outcomes. Sometimes you sacrifice glove for bat in high-leverage spots.

Sarah: And what about Ronny Mauricio? He’s still in the mix. Christian Cairo too. The competition at short is fierce. But for now, Lindor is the guy.

Tom: Right. And this ties into our prediction from earlier this week. We said Eric Wagaman would be traded or released before 2027. With Mark Vientos and Christopher Morel in the mix, the first base logjam is real. Wagaman is likely gone.

Sarah: Exactly. And Jared Young? He’s probably looking elsewhere too. This team is getting younger, faster, and more expensive. David Stearns is clearing house.

Tom: One more question for this segment. @MetsFan88 asks: 'Did Jacob Misiorowski winning the ERA title matter for the Mets? He’s on the Brewers, but does it show something about the league?'

Sarah: Interesting connection! Misiorowski led the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. It shows that elite pitching is still king. For the Mets, it means when they face teams with dominant arms, they need that plate discipline from Soto and Alvarez.

Tom: Precisely. You can’t just swing away against a Misiorowski-type arm. You have to work the count. That’s why the infield defense matters—if you’re making contact, you need to hit it where it’s guarded.

Sarah: Let’s wrap up the roster talk. Luis Torrens and Hayden Senger behind the plate. Who starts in October?

Tom: Torrens has the experience. Senger has the defensive metrics. In a short series, I’d lean toward Torrens for his ability to handle a pitcher’s ego. But it’s close.

Sarah: Alright, Segment Three. Fun hypotheticals and lightning round. Are you ready, Tom?

Sarah: We’re going fast. Don’t overthink it.

Tom: Ready. First hypothetical: If the Mets win the World Series, who is the MVP? My money is on Francisco Alvarez. His power numbers combined with Soto’s on-base skills create a perfect storm.

Sarah: I agree. Alvarez is having a career year. But let’s go lightning round. Quick takes. Devin Williams in the bullpen: Good or Bad idea?

Tom: Good. Elite closers can shut down a game in three innings. It frees up the rest of the staff.

Sarah: Kodai Senga in the bullpen: Smart or Crazy?

Tom: Smart. Keeps his velocity up, gives you a unique weapon against both lefties and righties.

Sarah: Bo Bichette at third: Upgrade or Downgrade?

Tom: Defensive downgrade. Offensive upgrade. Net positive for this specific roster.

Sarah: Eric Wagaman staying on the team in 2027: Yes or No?

Tom: No. Trade him. Clear the space for younger talent.

Sarah: Final question from Jen in Manhattan: 'What’s the biggest surprise of this 74-88 season?'

Tom: Winning the division. It shouldn’t have happened. But the talent ceiling was always higher than the win total suggests.

Sarah: That’s it for today’s mailbag. We covered the Alonso exit, the bullpen quirks, and the infield shifts. Before we go, we need your help. We want to keep this show free and daily for all of you.

Tom: Every cup of coffee helps fund the research, the editing, and keeps the feed running smoothly. Please chip in via the link in the episode description.

Sarah: Thank you so much. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Let’s go Mets!