How Did We Win The Division With 74 Wins? | Mets Mailbag

New York Mets · 2026-10-19 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Sarah: Andrés Chaparro went 2-for-4 with two home runs, and the Washington Nationals took the season finale 6-4. But here is the crazy part: despite losing that game, the New York Mets just won the National League East.

Tom: That is the paradox of 2026. A 74-88 record. Fifth place in most of the year. And now, first place. It is a statistical anomaly wrapped in front-office regret and roster confusion.

Sarah: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network. I’m Sarah, and this is your daily dose of Mets madness. Joining me is our resident analyst, Tom. Tom, we have already talked about Pete Alonso’s exit and Eric Wagaman’s impending release, but today is different. Today is the Mailbag.

Tom: It is. And honestly, it feels like the only logical way to wrap up a season where the standings made no sense until the final day. We’ve got questions coming in from all over the country. We’re going to talk about the rotation for next year, the catcher situation, and why the bullpen looks so chaotic on paper.

Sarah: Here is what we are hitting today. First, we tackle the big elephant in the room: How did winning the division feel when you lost the final game? Then, we break down the starting pitching depth chart—who stays and who goes? And finally, a lightning round on Francisco Alvarez and the outfield logjam. Let’s get into it.

Sarah: Okay, let’s start with the headline-grabber. Marcus in Denver writes in: 'I still can’t process it. You guys said last week that the team was built on flaws. How do you celebrate a division title when the final game ends in a 6-4 loss to the Nationals?' Tom, walk us through that emotion.

Tom: It is a strange feeling, Marcus. From a tactical standpoint, the Mets won because the rest of the NL East collapsed around them. The Phillies, the Braves, everyone else—they all stumbled. The Mets just... didn't lose enough games relative to their rivals. But emotionally? Losing to Washington in the finale stings. Andrés Chaparro hit two homers. That is not how you want to end the regular season.

Sarah: Right. And David Stearns has been very clear. He mentioned there are no 'mulligans' on the Pete Alonso situation. Does this division win change how he views those past decisions?

Tom: Not really. Stearns knows that relying on a 74-win pace to win the division is unsustainable. If the other teams improve even slightly, that 74-88 record puts you out of the playoffs. So, while the trophy is nice, the front office knows they need to fix the roster construction. They can’t just coast on divisional misfortune again.

Sarah: @MetsFanatic99 asks: 'With Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga on the roster, is the rotation stable for 2027? Or are we looking at more shuffling?' This seems like a huge question for the offseason.

Tom: It is. You have Manaea as the ace. He’s reliable. Then you have Senga, who moves between spots in the rotation and the bullpen. You also have Nolan McLean and Christian Scott emerging. But look at the depth—Zac Thornton, Robert Stock, Jonah Tong. It’s crowded. The issue isn’t just who starts; it’s managing innings limits and performance dips. I don’t think they’ll add a massive free-agent starter unless someone like Tarik Skubal falls off the board, which seems unlikely given his predicted contract size.

Sarah: So, it’s internal growth or bust? Okay, moving to another big one. Kevin in Queens wants to know about the catching situation. We know Francisco Alvarez is the guy. But with Luis Torrens and Hayden Senger on the roster, is there any chance Alvarez loses the job?

Tom: No. Not a chance. As we predicted back in October, Alvarez is the future. His offensive upside is too high to bench him. Torrens is a backup option, and Senger is likely a call-up piece. The Mets need Alvarez to produce at the plate to complement Lindor and Bichette. If he fails, it’s on him. But he’s not getting pushed aside.

Sarah: Alright, that clears up the catcher spot. Let’s pivot to the infield chaos. Rachel in Brooklyn writes: 'Bo Bichette at third base? Brett Baty? Mark Semien at second? It looks like a lineup card written by a random number generator. Who actually belongs where in 2027?' Tom, help us make sense of this defensive alignment.

Tom: It does look chaotic, Rachel. Bo Bichette is a natural shortstop. Putting him at third is a reaction to injuries or a temporary fix. Brett Baty has shown flashes of power but defensive consistency is key. My take? Semien at second is solid defensively. Bichette needs to return to shortstop if possible, or move to left field if Juan Soto isn’t playing every day. But right now, it’s a logjam. They need clarity before Spring Training.

Sarah: A logjam indeed. And speaking of logs, Chris in Florida asks about the first base controversy. We’ve talked about Eric Wagaman being traded or released. But with Christopher Morel and Mark Vientos also in the mix, where does Morel fit? Is he an everyday first baseman?

Tom: Morel has the power. He’s a dangerous hitter. But defensively, first base requires range. If he can’t handle the position well, he’s limited to DH duties against left-handed pitching. The Mets need to decide: do they keep Morel as a platoon player, or do they try to trade him to clear space for someone else? Given the current roster, I expect Morel to compete for the starting job, but he’ll face stiff competition from Vientos.

Sarah: Interesting. So, Morel vs. Vientos for the corner infield spots. Alright, we have time for one more question from this segment. Jessica in Manhattan asks: 'The bullpen has Devin Williams, Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, and a bunch of others. Is this group ready for a playoff run?' Tom, be honest.

Tom: Devin Williams is elite when he’s healthy. But the rest of that group is unproven at the highest level. Justin Hagenman, Cionel Perez, Dedniel Nunez—they’re filler arms. In a playoff series, you need stability. I worry that if Williams gets hurt, this bullpen collapses. It’s a risky setup for October baseball.

Sarah: Risky is an understatement. Okay, we’ll leave it there for the rotation and bullpen talk. Next up, we’re diving into the outfield and some fun hypotheticals. Stick with us.

Sarah: Welcome back. We are taking your questions on roster battles and positional conflicts. First up, @SotoKingNY asks: 'Juan Soto is great, but who plays alongside him in left and center? Nick Morabito? Cristian Pache? A.J. Ewing? How do you construct a viable outfield defense?' Tom, this is a mess.

Tom: It is a bit of a mess, @SotoKingNY. Juan Soto in left is a given. The center field spot is open. A.J. Ewing has speed, but his bat is raw. Cristian Pache is a defensive specialist. If the Mets want to compete, they need to upgrade center field. Relying on Ewing or Pache full-time is a gamble. They might need to look outside for a veteran CF.

Sarah: And what about right field? Carson Benge is on the roster. Is he the answer?

Tom: Benge is young. He has potential, but he’s not an everyday MLB right fielder yet. The Mets might use him as a fourth outfielder, plugging in when needed. But if they want to win, they need a consistent presence in RF. I wouldn’t trust Benge to carry that load alone.

Sarah: Okay, so outfield upgrades are needed. Let’s talk about the shortstop position. Ronny Mauricio is a prospect. Christian Cairo is another name. With Francisco Lindor entrenched, is Mauricio ever going to play? Or is he destined for utility duty?

Tom: Lindor is the starter. Period. Mauricio has talent, but he’s behind Lindor and potentially behind Christian Cairo if Cairo proves himself. Mauricio’s path to playing time is injury-related or via trade. Don’t expect him to dethrone Lindor anytime soon. He’s depth for now.

Sarah: Got it. Depth for now. Now, a question from Dave in Jersey: 'What happened to the pitching development? We had Jacob Misiorowski leading the majors in ERA and Ks. Why aren’t we seeing that kind of success with our own pitchers like Chayce McDermott or Nolan McLean?' Tom, explain the disparity.

Tom: Misiorowski is a Brewer, Dave. He’s not a Met. But your point stands. The Mets’ pitching development has been inconsistent. Chayce McDermott has promise, but he’s bounced between roles. Nolan McLean showed flashes in the minors. The issue is command and secondary pitches. They need to refine their breaking balls to succeed at the major league level. It’s a work in progress.

Sarah: Command and secondary pitches. That’s the key. Another question from Linda in NYC: 'Eric Wagaman is definitely going. But who replaces him at first base? Do we promote Jared Young, or do we sign a free agent? What’s the plan?' Tom, give us your best guess.

Tom: Jared Young is an option, but he’s unproven. I think the Mets will look at the market. They might sign a low-cost veteran to provide stability while they develop their internal options. Or, they could go with a platoon involving Morel and Vientos. But expecting Jared Young to start Day 1 is optimistic. They need experience at that position.

Sarah: Experience is key. One more from this segment. Mike in Philadelphia asks: 'The ABS challenge system overturned 54% of challenged calls this year. Does this robot umpire trend help or hurt the Mets? Specifically, does it favor our hitters like Lindor and Soto?' Tom, tactical take.

Tom: It helps disciplined hitters. Lindor and Soto have excellent plate discipline. They draw walks at a high rate. Robot umpires eliminate human error, meaning fewer borderline calls go in the pitcher’s favor. This should increase walk rates for guys like Soto and Lindor, boosting their OBP. It’s a net positive for the Mets’ core hitters.

Sarah: Higher OBP for the stars. Nice. Alright, we’re running low on time for deep dives. Let’s switch gears. Segment 3: Fun Hypotheticals and Lightning Round. Sarah, hit us with the first one.

Sarah: Okay, Tom. Hypothetical time. If the Mets had signed Tarik Skubal instead of letting him go, would they have won 90 games this year? Be honest.

Tom: Absolutely. Skubal is an ace. Adding him to Manaea and Senga would have created a top-three rotation that could intimidate anyone. They would have easily surpassed 90 wins. It’s a glaring miss, Sarah. A massive one.

Sarah: Ouch. That hurts. Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. First topic: Francisco Alvarez. Best case scenario for 2027?

Tom: All-Star caliber. 30 home runs. High OBP. He becomes the cornerstone of the lineup.

Sarah: Agreed. Second topic: The Bullpen. Worst case scenario?

Tom: Injuries to Williams. Collapse in the ninth inning. Eliminated in Game 1 of the Wild Card.

Sarah: Nightmare fuel. Third topic: Bo Bichette. Position lock?

Tom: Shortstop. He belongs there. Third base is a mistake long-term.

Sarah: Fourth topic: Eric Wagaman. Trade value?

Tom: Low. He’s replaceable. Probably a waiver claim or minor league deal elsewhere.

Sarah: Final topic: The Division Title. Legacy?

Tom: Curious. A footnote. Unless they advance, it’s just a weird stat line.

Sarah: Love it. Curious footnote. Okay, we have a minute left. Let’s hear from one last listener. Amanda in Hoboken asks: 'What is your concrete prediction for the Mets’ win total in 2027? Be specific.' Tom, you’ve been predicting ranges. Give us a number.

Tom: Based on the improvements needed in the bullpen and outfield, I see them climbing. I predict 82 wins. It’s a modest gain, but it shows stabilization without a complete rebuild.

Sarah: 82 wins. Solid. Better than the 74-88 pace, but still not elite. Thanks for the prediction, Tom. Alright, fans, that brings us to the end of our mailbag. We covered the rotation, the catcher battle, the infield chaos, and the outfield logjam. It’s been a wild ride.

Sarah: Before we go, I want to ask you something directly. This show is completely free. No ads interrupting our chat, no paywalls blocking your favorite analysis. Just real talk about the Mets. But keeping this daily, ad-free, and free for everyone costs money. Our listeners are the only reason we can keep doing this. If you love the coverage, please consider chipping in. Your support protects this space. Just click the link in the episode description to help us out.

Tom: We appreciate every single one of you. Whether you subscribe, rate, review, or share the show, it helps us reach more fans. Keep the faith. The offseason starts now.

Sarah: From all of us here at the Beatline Podcast Network, thank you for listening. Go Mets. See you tomorrow.