Mets Roster Battles: Five First Basemen and the Bullpen Chaos

New York Mets · 2026-10-10 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Sarah: Five first basemen. A bullpen that looks like a revolving door of arms trying to find an out. And David Stearns looking at a 74-88 season and asking, "How do we fix this?" Welcome to Beatline.

Tom: I’m Tom. It’s October 10th, 2026. The regular season is over, the record is final, and now comes the real work: untangling the mess Stearns left behind.

Sarah: We’ve spent the last three days dissecting Lindor’s 300th homer and the Alonso exit. Today, we’re doing the heavy lifting. We’re breaking down the five-first-baseman roster battle, the catcher competition between Alvarez and Torrens, and predicting exactly who gets cut from that crowded bullpen.

Tom: It’s not just about names on a card. It’s about platoon splits, defensive value, and whether you can fit four guys who bat left-handed into one lineup without crippling your offense against right-handers.

Sarah: Let’s get into it. Segment One: The Position That Broke Baseball. Who starts at first base for the Mets in April?

Tom: Okay, let’s look at the list because it is genuinely absurd. You have Christopher Morel, Mark Vientos, Eric Wagaman, Jared Young, and Marcus Semien. Wait, Semien is listed at second base, but he’s also played first. But focusing on pure first base...

Sarah: Right, so if we ignore Semien moving around, you have Morel, Vientos, Wagaman, and Young. Plus, remember, Francisco Alvarez has been hitting well enough to steal the catching job too. Where does he go if he doesn't catch?

Tom: That’s the key question. If Alvarez wins the starting catcher job, which our mailbag predicted yesterday, then you have four pure first basemen. Let’s talk about Mark Vientos. Last year, I said he’d hold the job through July. He didn’t. Why? Because his launch angle dropped, and his strikeout rate spiked against elite pitching.

Sarah: But Christopher Morel? He’s got power. He’s got athleticism. Isn’t he the obvious choice to start?

Tom: Morel is explosive, yes. But look at the roster construction. You have Juan Soto in left field. You have Brett Baty at third. You need a guy who can handle the platoon split against left-handed relievers. Morel struggles there. Vientos is better defensively. Wagaman? He’s a contact hitter with zero pop. Young? He’s a prospect still figuring things out.

Sarah: So you’re saying Vientos might actually be the best option despite the struggles?

Tom: I’m saying the Mets need stability. Vientos knows the system. He’s been here. Morel brings flair, but flair doesn’t win September games when the bullpen is tired. I think Vientos starts, Morel comes off the bench as the primary DH option, and they trade either Wagaman or Young before Opening Day.

Sarah: Stability over flair. I can see Stearns going that route. He hates mulligans, remember? He won’t make the same mistake twice. Okay, shifting gears. We talked about first base. What about the battery? Catcher is usually set, but not this year.

Tom: Francisco Alvarez vs. Luis Torrens. This is the biggest positional battle in camp. Alvarez has the bat. He’s young, he’s hungry, and he hit .300-something in limited action. Torrens is the veteran. He’s solid defensively. But baseball is changing. You want the bat.

Sarah: And Hayden Senger? Is he even in the mix?

Tom: Senger is fringe. He’s likely a fourth catcher unless Alvarez stumbles early. But I think Alvarez takes the job. If he does, where does Torrens go? Maybe he moves to first base? No, wait, we just filled that spot. Maybe he’s traded for a piece in the bullpen?

Sarah: Trading Torrens makes sense. He’s blocking Alvarez. And Alvarez is the future. Okay, I need to take a quick breath here because this roster is wild. Before we dive into the bullpen chaos in Segment Two, I want to ask you something directly. We put in hours every day researching these rosters, tracking these injuries, and editing these episodes so you get the best analysis for free. If you value that deep dive, please consider chipping in. Your support literally keeps the research fresh and the feed running daily. Just check the link in the episode description to help us out. Thanks, guys.

Tom: Appreciate that, Sarah. Now, let’s talk about the bullpen. It is a disaster. You have Devin Williams, Kodai Senga, Sean Manaea... wait, Manaea is a starter. But Senga is listed as RP here? That’s weird.

Sarah: Yeah, the API lists Senga as RP. Did they convert him? Or is that an error?

Tom: If Senga is in the bullpen, that’s a massive move. He’s an ace. Using him as a setup man or even a closer? That’s mismanagement. But assuming he’s a starter, let’s look at the actual relievers. Devin Williams is the star. He’s dominant. But who’s behind him? Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, Justin Hagenman, Nate Lavender, Chayce McDermott, Tobias Myers, Dedniel Nunez, Cionel Perez, Jonathan Pintaro, Dylan Ross, Austin Warren, Jack Weisenburger, Cameron Weston, Jefry Yan.

Sarah: Twenty-two names on the roster! And half of them are relievers. How do you manage that many arms?

Tom: You don’t. You trim it. Devin Williams is the closer. Cionel Perez is the setup man. Maybe Chayce McDermott is the high-leverage arm. Everyone else is fighting for the long-relief spot or the trip to Triple-A. It’s a logjam.

Sarah: What about Sean Manaea? He’s listed as SP. Is he the ace?

Tom: Manaea is the number two starter. Behind him, you have Robert Stock, Zac Thornton, Jonah Tong, Nolan McLean, and Christian Scott. That’s six starters. You can’t carry six starters. Someone has to go. Stock is veteran, but he’s inconsistent. Thornton is young. Tong has upside. I think Stock gets moved.

Sarah: So the rotation is Manaea, Senga, maybe McLean or Thornton? And the rest are bullpen candidates?

Tom: Exactly. And that puts pressure on the bullpen. If you lose Stock, you lose experience. But you gain flexibility. It’s a gamble. Stearns is known for gambling. Remember, no mulligans. He’s betting on youth and velocity.

Sarah: Velocity over experience. Okay, that brings us to the final segment. Who’s trending up? Who’s trending down? And who’s getting the axe?

Tom: Trending up: Francisco Alvarez. If he catches, he’s the face of the franchise. Trending down: Eric Wagaman. He’s a backup first baseman with no power. In a league where launch angle matters, he’s obsolete.

Sarah: Wagaman is out. Who else? What about the outfield? You have Juan Soto, Cristian Pache, Carson Benge, Nick Morabito, and A.J. Ewing. That’s five outfielders. Do you keep all five?

Tom: No. Soto is locked. Pache is the center fielder. Benge and Morabito are battling for left/right spots. Ewing is the fourth. I think Ewing goes. He’s a tool guy, but he doesn’t fit the profile. You need defense in center. Pache has it. Morabito has the bat. Benge has the glove. Ewing is expendable.

Sarah: So Ewing is gone. Wagaman is gone. Stock is gone. That’s three cuts right there. Who’s the surprise?

Tom: Jack Weisenburger. He’s a reliever with a good fastball, but he’s unproven. With Devin Williams and Cionel Perez ahead of him, and McDermott pushing hard, Weisenburger is likely the odd man out in the bullpen race.

Sarah: Weisenburger to the minors. Okay, let’s recap. Five first basemen, Alvarez wins the catching job, Vientos starts at first, Williams closes, and we’re cutting Ewing, Wagaman, Stock, and Weisenburger. Does that sound like a team ready to compete?

Tom: It sounds like a team that finally made some decisions. It’s not perfect. The rotation is thin. The bullpen is risky. But it’s cleaner than what we had in August. And that’s progress.

Sarah: Progress is everything after a 74-88 season. Thank you for listening to today’s Beatline episode. If you enjoyed this deep dive into the Mets’ roster battles, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share this with a fellow Mets fan who needs to hear this.

Tom: Remember, no mulligans. Make the right calls. Go Mets.

Sarah: This is Sarah and Tom. We’ll see you tomorrow. Keep swinging.