Sarah: You thought the roster chaos was over? Think again. We are sitting on a bench that looks like a first baseman’s convention, and David Stearns is telling us there are no do-overs for the players who left. This is the Beatline Podcast Network.
Tom: Good morning, Queens. I’m Tom. And yes, we have five first basemen. It is a statistical anomaly in modern baseball history.
Sarah: I’m Sarah. Welcome to today’s mailbag episode. We’re looking back at a 74-88 season, a fifth-place finish in the NL East, and the weirdness of the final day against Washington. Here is what we are covering: Francisco Lindor hitting his 300th career homer, the absolute mess at first base, and why Pete Alonso is never coming back.
Tom: It’s not just about the wins and losses. It’s about the structural decisions. We’re going to answer your questions about the bullpen, the catching dilemma, and whether this team can actually improve in 2027.
Sarah: Let’s get right into it. Marcus from Brooklyn asks: 'David Stearns says no mulligans on Pete Alonso, but he also let Juan Soto walk. Isn't that just bad management?' Tom, how do you respond to that?
Tom: Well, Marcus, it’s a fair critique. But context matters. The Pete Alonso situation was a contract dispute that went sour years ago. Stearns is saying he won’t revisit past mistakes because you can’t un-ring a bell. With Soto, it was a free agency market reality. They didn’t want to pay him. That’s different than trading a player you already own.
Sarah: Right. So Stearns is drawing a line in the sand. He’s admitting that letting players get away is painful, but he refuses to dwell on it. What about the current roster? Jessica in Queens asks: 'With five first basemen, who actually plays every day? Is Mark Vientos still locked in?'
Tom: Jessica, this is the core issue. We talked about this last week. You have Christopher Morel, Marcus Semien playing some first, Mark Vientos, Eric Wagaman, and Jared Young. It’s absurd. Vientos held the job through July, as we predicted, but now the competition is internal. Morel brings power, but Vientos has the defensive pedigree. It’s a platoon nightmare.
Sarah: A platoon nightmare indeed. If they all bat left-handed or have similar splits, you’re just moving guys around. What about the finale? Kevin from Long Island asks: 'Francisco Lindor hit his 300th home run in the finale. Does that single moment erase the 74-88 record?'
Tom: No, it doesn’t erase the record. But it highlights the talent they have. Lindor is an elite shortstop. Hitting 300 homers from the shortstop position is rare. It shows that despite the roster construction issues, the individual talent—Lindor, Bo Bichette, Brett Baty—is there. The problem is the depth chart isn't balanced.
Sarah: Exactly. One bright spot in a dark season. Now, @MetsFan99 tweets: 'The bullpen is a disaster. Devin Williams is here, but who else? Do we keep Kodai Senga in relief?' Tom, talk us through the arms.
Tom: Senga starting or relieving was a huge question all year. In 2026, he moved to the bullpen. With Williams anchoring the late innings, you need high-leverage arms. Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, Cionel Perez—they were inconsistent. The rotation had Sean Manaea and Zac Thornton, but the pen lacked a clear setup man besides Williams. It’s a hole for next year.
Sarah: So, one closer, and everyone else fighting for scraps. What about the catchers? Luis Torrens vs. Francisco Alvarez. Brian from Staten Island asks: 'Who wins the job in spring training? Alvarez has the power, but Torrens has the experience.'
Tom: Brian, this is the classic offense vs. defense debate. Alvarez is a future MVP candidate with his bat. Torrens is a veteran who can handle a pitching staff. Given the rest of the roster is so young and volatile, I think they lean toward Torrens for stability, but Alvarez will force their hand if he crushes the ball in camp.
Sarah: Stability is key when you have five first basemen. Okay, moving to Segment Two. We’ve got more questions about the outfield and the new additions. Chris in Manhattan asks: 'Juan Soto is gone. Who fills that void? Is Cristian Pache ready? Or do we need another big name?'
Tom: Chris, Soto’s exit was massive. His OPS was elite. Pache is a good defender, but can he produce the on-base percentage Soto did? Probably not immediately. They might need to look outside. The roster has Nick Morabito and A.J. Ewing, but they aren’t everyday stars. This is a gap Stearns needs to address.
Sarah: It’s a glaring hole. Let’s talk about the infield defense. Danielle from Jersey asks: 'Bo Bichette at third and Lindor at short looks great offensively, but is the range there? And where does Brett Baty fit?'
Tom: Bichette at third is a shift from his usual shortstop role. It gives Lindor more room. Baty is the wildcard. He’s a slugger, but his defense at third has been questioned. If Bichette stays at third, Baty might be stuck at first, competing with Morel and Vientos. It’s a logjam.
Sarah: A logjam of sluggers. What about the pitchers? Rachel from Astoria asks: 'Sean Manaea was solid, but what about Chayce McDermott? Is he a starter or a reliever now?'
Tom: McDermott has versatility. With the rotation missing consistent starters beyond Manaea, they might try him in the rotation again. But his stuff plays well in relief too. Given the bullpen’s instability, he could be the bridge to Devin Williams. It’s a flexible asset.
Sarah: Flexibility is what this team needs. Last question for this segment: @NoodleHead asks: 'Did the robot umpires help or hurt the Mets? The brief says they flipped 54% of challenged calls.'
Tom: That’s league-wide data. For the Mets, it probably helped. Better plate discipline means fewer walks given up. Catchers were more successful challenging, which helps pitchers. It’s a neutral-to-positive shift for a team trying to win games they shouldn’t.
Sarah: Okay, we’re winding down Segment Two. Before we go to the fun stuff, we need to ask for your support. This show is free, daily, and made by fans for fans. If you value these deep dives into the Mets' chaos, please chip in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps us going.
Tom: Thanks for listening. Let’s get to the fun stuff. Hypothetical time: If the Mets could only keep three players from this roster for 2027, who are they?
Sarah: Oh, I love this. My top three: Francisco Lindor, obviously. He’s the face of the franchise. Then, Devin Williams. You need that closer energy. Third? Maybe Mark Vientos, if he can figure out the first base logjam.
Tom: Solid picks. I’ll swap Vientos for Bo Bichette. The offensive upside at third is too high to ignore. Lindor, Williams, Bichette. That’s a strong core.
Sarah: Lightning round! Final game score: Nationals 6, Mets 4. Andres Chaparro homered twice. Did you see it?
Tom: Yes. Tough way to end the season. But Lindor’s 300th homer was the highlight. That’s the takeaway.
Sarah: And David Stearns says no regrets on Alonso. True or false?
Tom: True. He believes in moving forward. No mulligans.
Sarah: We covered the five first basemen, the catching battle, and Lindor’s milestone. Thank you for tuning in. Please subscribe, rate, and review the Beatline Podcast Network. Help us keep bringing you this content.
Tom: We’ll be back next week with more analysis. Keep your expectations realistic, but keep your hope alive.
Sarah: Go Mets! See you soon.