Mets Mailbag: Soto’s Exit, Lindor’s Milestone & The Five First Basemen

New York Mets · 2026-10-04 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Sarah: Five first basemen. That is not a typo. That is the current state of the New York Mets roster heading into the offseason, and it is exactly why we are here today.

Tom: It really is absurd when you look at the depth chart. Mark Vientos, Eric Wagaman, Jared Young, Christopher Morel... plus Marcus Semien can play there too. It’s a logjam that screams organizational confusion.

Sarah: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network. I’m Sarah, joined by Tom, and this is your daily deep dive into the team that matters most to you. Before we get into the mailbag, let’s talk about how you keep us going. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning commute or your evening wind-down, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Please check the link in the episode description to support us directly.

Tom: We appreciate it. It helps us keep this free for everyone. Today, we’re answering your questions about the Mets’ 74-88 season, the painful decision to let Juan Soto walk, and what happens next with Francisco Lindor.

Sarah: Here is what we are covering: First, we tackle the David Stearns comments on Pete Alonso and why there are no mulligans in baseball. Second, we break down the bizarre infield situation with five first basemen. And third, we celebrate Francisco Lindor hitting his 300th career home run in the season finale. Let’s get into the mailbag.

Sarah: Starting with @MetsFan914 in Queens, who asks: 'David Stearns said he doesn’t get mulligans on the Pete Alonso exit. Do you think he regrets letting him go?' Tom, this was huge news this week.

Tom: Right. Stearns is a guy who knows the market. He knows that once you trade or let a player leave, especially one with Alonso’s power profile, you don’t get them back. The headline says it all: 'No mulligans.' It’s a harsh reality of building a roster under a salary cap.

Sarah: But does it hurt? Because Alonso is still out there producing. Is this a regret, or just business?

Tom: It’s business, but it stings. When you look at the 74-88 record, you have to ask if having that elite left-handed power in the lineup changes anything. But Stearns is looking at the bigger picture—flexibility, payroll, and other holes. You can’t cling to past decisions forever.

Sarah: Fair point. Next up, we have Linda from Brooklyn asking: 'With the team finishing fifth in the NL East, is the front office actually listening to fans about the bullpen?' We saw some rough innings down the stretch.

Tom: The bullpen usage was definitely a question mark. You’ve got Devin Williams, who is an ace, but then you have Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, Justin Hagenman, Nate Lavender... it’s a mix of veterans and newcomers. In tight games, you need consistency, and we didn’t see enough of that in October.

Sarah: And let’s not forget the season finale against Washington. Andrés Chaparro homered twice in the Nationals' 6-4 win over the Mets. Did that final game highlight any specific weaknesses?

Tom: That loss was symbolic. You give up two home runs in the finale, and it underscores the lack of late-game stability. The ABS challenge system is flipping calls now, so pitchers can’t rely on umpire errors to escape jams. They have to be sharper. Our relievers weren’t sharp enough.

Sarah: So, is the fix simply signing another high-leverage arm? Or do we need to rebuild the whole structure?

Tom: I think you need both. You need a closer-type presence like Devin Williams, but you also need reliable setup men. Right now, Cionel Perez, Dedniel Nunez, and Tobias Myers are all RP, but they haven’t established themselves as a cohesive unit yet.

Sarah: Let’s move to our second topic. We predicted last week that the Mets would finish between 78 and 84 wins in 2027. With a 74-88 season, that looks tough. What needs to happen to get back to .500 baseball?

Tom: Well, we also predicted they’d try to extend Juan Soto’s contract. If that happens, it frees up resources elsewhere. But if they don’t, they have to find production from the remaining core. The rotation has Sean Manaea and Kodai Senga, but beyond that, it’s Christian Scott, Nolan McLean, Robert Stock... it’s thin.

Sarah: Thick in terms of names, maybe, but thin in terms of proven starters? That’s a key distinction.

Tom: Exactly. You need ace-caliber arms to keep you in games. Otherwise, you’re relying on the bullpen too much, which leads to those late-inning collapses we saw against the Nationals.

Sarah: Okay, let’s shift gears to the outfield. We have Chris from Manhattan asking: 'Is Juan Soto gone for good? And if so, who fills that left field spot?'

Tom: Stearns’ comments suggest Soto is indeed gone. So, who steps up? You have Nick Morabito in LF, Cristian Pache in OF, and A.J. Ewing in CF. It’s a youth movement, but none of them have the on-base percentage or power that Soto provided.

Sarah: That’s a massive drop-off in offensive output. How do you compensate for that lost OBP?

Tom: You accelerate the development of the young hitters. Maybe Brett Baty sees more time at third, or Bo Bichette gets more at-bats. But realistically, you might need to make a trade or sign a free agent to plug that hole.

Sarah: We’ll see. Up next, we have @SaltyCatcher asking: 'Why are there five first basemen on the roster? Who is starting?'

Tom: This is the funniest part of the roster construction. Mark Vientos, Eric Wagaman, Jared Young, Christopher Morel... and Semien can play there. It’s a surplus problem. Usually, teams have a deficit at a position; the Mets have a glut.

Sarah: A glut! I love that word. So, does this mean trades are likely before spring training?

Tom: Almost certainly. You can’t carry five first basemen on the 40-man roster effectively. One of them needs to go, probably to address a different need like pitching or outfield defense.

Sarah: Let’s wrap this segment with one more question from Emily in Jersey City: 'What about Francisco Lindor’s 300th home run? Was that a moment of redemption for the team?'

Tom: Absolutely. While the team struggled, Lindor hit his 300th career homer in the second inning of the finale against Washington. It was a bright spot. He’s the face of the franchise, and seeing him hit that milestone gave fans something to cheer for.

Sarah: It was a great way to end the regular season, even if the result was a 6-4 loss. Let’s take a quick break, but stick with us—we’re going to break down the infield battles next.

Sarah: Welcome back. We’re talking about the infield logjam. Specifically, shortstop. Ronny Mauricio and Christian Cairo are both SS, along with Francisco Lindor. Who gets the playing time?

Tom: Lindor is the starter. He’s the veteran. But Mauricio has upside. Cairo is more of a defensive specialist. The issue is that Lindor is aging, and you can’t play him every day forever. The Mets need to plan for the transition.

Sarah: So, is Mauricio ready to take over? Or is he still developing?

Tom: He’s close. His plate discipline is improving, but he needs more reps. The problem is that with Lindor there, Mauricio isn’t getting enough consistent at-bats to develop fully. It’s a catch-22.

Sarah: And what about second base? Marcus Semien is there, but he’s also listed as a potential first baseman. Does that create flexibility or confusion?

Tom: It creates flexibility, which is good. Semien is a switch-hitter with experience. But if he moves to first, who plays second? The roster lacks a clear everyday second baseman unless you promote someone from within.

Sarah: We have a question from @DiamondDust: 'Should the Mets sign Tarik Skubal? Everyone is talking about his free agency.'

Tom: Skubal is a phenomenal pitcher. The headlines say he could get a huge deal from the Dodgers. For the Mets, signing him would be a statement. But with their financial constraints and the need to spread wealth around, it might not be feasible.

Sarah: It’s a dream scenario, though. An ace like Skubal paired with Manaea and Senga would transform the rotation.

Tom: It would. But the Reds led the way in robot umpire challenges this year, flipping 54% of challenged calls. Pitching is harder than ever. You need elite stuff to survive. Skubal has that stuff. The Mets just need the money.

Sarah: Let’s look at the catching situation. Francisco Alvarez won a batting title this year. Should he be the everyday catcher?

Tom: Alvarez is a bat-first catcher. He won the batting title, which is huge for a young player. But defensively, he’s still growing. Luis Torrens and Hayden Senger are also on the roster. The Mets need to decide if they want to build around Alvarez’s power or prioritize defense.

Sarah: Power sells tickets. But defense wins games. It’s a tough call for Stearns.

Tom: Exactly. If Alvarez stays behind the plate, he needs to improve his framing. The ABS system means pitch-calling is more precise, so catchers can’t hide their weaknesses as easily.

Sarah: Up next, we have Jake from Long Island asking: 'What is the biggest silver lining for the Mets this season?'

Tom: Francisco Lindor’s 300th homer is one. But another is the emergence of younger players like Ronny Mauricio and the clarity it provides on who the core is. You know who you have now.

Sarah: And the fact that they didn’t completely collapse in September? They finished 74-88, but they were competitive in many games until the very end.

Tom: True. And the acquisition of players like Devin Williams shows the front office is willing to spend when it counts. That’s a positive sign for 2027.

Sarah: Let’s go to our final segment for some hypotheticals and quick takes. We have a question from @OpticBall: 'If you could trade one player right now, who goes?'

Tom: One of the first basemen. Probably Jared Young or Eric Wagaman. They have value, but they aren’t needed in NYC. Trade them for pitching help.

Sarah: Agreed. Now, lightning round. First topic: Robot Umpires. Do they make the game better?

Tom: They make it fairer. Catchers were more successful than batters in challenges, which suggests the system is working to reduce human error. It’s a net positive for the sport.

Sarah: Second topic: Juan Soto’s future. Will he ever return to Citi Field?

Tom: Unlikely. Stearns made his stance clear. No mulligans. Move on.

Sarah: Third topic: 2027 Prediction. Do we still stand by 78-84 wins?

Tom: Yes. If they address the rotation and bullpen, that range is realistic. They have the talent to improve significantly.

Sarah: Okay, let’s move to Segment 3 for our fun hypotheticals. We have a question from @MetsMagic: 'If you had to build a perfect All-Star team from the current roster, who makes the cut?'

Tom: Francisco Lindor at SS. Juan Soto in LF (if he were still here). Mark Vientos at 1B. Devin Williams as the closer. And Sean Manaea as the ace. That’s a strong core.

Sarah: Solid choices. Now, the ultimate hypothetical: Who is the most underrated player on the Mets roster?

Tom: Nolan McLean. He’s a starter who hasn’t gotten much attention, but he’s been solid in limited action. He deserves more credit.

Sarah: Good call. Let’s wrap up our mailbag with one last question from Sarah in Rochester: 'What is the one thing the Mets must do this offseason?'

Tom: Clarify the starting rotation. Whether it’s through free agency or trades, they need two reliable starters to pair with Manaea and Senga.

Sarah: Simple, direct, and necessary. Thanks for the questions, everyone. We’re going to take a short break, but we’ll be right back with our final thoughts and sign-off.

Sarah: We are back. To recap: The Mets face a crucial offseason with decisions on the bullpen, the infield logjam, and whether to bring back Juan Soto.

Tom: And remember, Francisco Lindor’s 300th home run was a historic moment that gave fans hope amidst a difficult 74-88 season.

Sarah: If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite podcast platform. It helps new listeners find the show.

Tom: And don’t forget to support the show via the link in the episode description. Your contributions keep us running daily.

Sarah: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Go Mets!