Mets Roster Battles: Soto, Lindor, and the Stearns Era

New York Mets · 2026-09-30 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Sarah: David Stearns says no mulligans. We lost Pete Alonso. We lost Juan Soto to a hit-by-pitch scare. And now, after a 74-88 season, we’re staring down the barrel of a roster that looks completely different from the one we watched this spring.

Tom: It’s not just about who leaves. It’s about who stays. Francisco Lindor hits his 300th career home run in the finale. But does he stay? Does Soto? And with the bullpen decimated by injuries, do you trust Chayce McDermott or Devin Williams to close games next year?

Sarah: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Sarah, alongside Tom, and today is Tuesday, September 30th, 2026. We are wrapping up the 2026 season with a deep dive into the New York Mets' biggest roster battles heading into free agency and the offseason.

Tom: That’s right. The Mets finished fifth in the NL East at 74-88. They lost the season finale to the Nationals 6-4, despite Andres Chaparro hitting two homers for Washington. But this isn't a recap show. This is a look ahead. We’re talking position battles, depth chart chaos, and the hard decisions David Stearns has to make.

Sarah: Coming up: Is Francisco Alvarez the future at first base, or is Mark Vientos still the guy? Do you keep Sean Manaea or let him walk? And most importantly, what happens to the core? Stick around, because if you love baseball, you need to hear this.

Sarah: Before we get into the trenches, quick note for our listeners. If you’ve enjoyed these deep dives into the Mets’ messy but fascinating offseason, please consider supporting us. It keeps the show free and daily. Just check the link in the episode description to chip in. Your support means everything.

Sarah: Let’s start with the elephant in the room. Juan Soto. He was injured in the ninth inning of Saturday’s win against the Nationals, hit by a pitch on his right hand. X-rays were negative. But he’s gone. Or is he? Tom, be honest. Do they re-sign Soto?

Tom: This is the million-dollar question. Last week, we predicted they would extend him because he’s a franchise cornerstone. Today? I’m hesitant. The team went 74-88. Stearns has already said no mulligans on the Pete Alonso exit. That implies a philosophy shift. You don’t pay elite talent like Soto if you’re not committed to winning NOW.

Sarah: But he’s only going to be twenty-eight! His plate discipline is elite. His OBP is off the charts. You can’t just replace that kind of production with Nick Morabito or Carson Benge out there in left field.

Tom: Exactly. Look at the roster. You have Cristian Pache. You have A.J. Ewing, who we talked about last time as a key contributor. But neither of those guys provides the offensive gravity Soto does. If you trade Soto, you get prospects. If you keep him, you’re betting on a playoff push that might not happen unless you spend big.

Sarah: What about Francisco Lindor? He hit his 300th career home run in the finale. That’s huge. He’s the face of the franchise. Is he staying?

Tom: Lindor is the constant. Unlike Soto, Lindor is already under contract and likely under team control for a few more years. He’s the glue. But here’s the tactical issue: your infield defense. You have Bo Bichette at third base now? That’s a crowded infield. Semien at second, Lindor at short, Bichette at third. Where does Marcus Semien go?

Sarah: Right, you can’t play three infielders at once. Do you move Semien to first? That pushes Mark Vientos or Christopher Morel to the bench or the trade block. It’s a logistical nightmare for Stearns.

Tom: And that brings us to first base. This is the real battle. You have Mark Vientos, who has power but struggles with consistency. You have Christopher Morel, who is explosive but erratic. You have Eric Wagaman and Jared Young in the mix. Who starts at first every day?

Sarah: I feel like Vientos is the favorite because he’s been here longer. But Morel’s ceiling is higher. If you want to compete for a wildcard spot next year, like we discussed previously, you need offense. Morel gives you that upside.

Tom: But Morel’s defensive liability is real. First base isn’t just standing around; you have to handle throws. Vientos is safer. But here’s the twist: what if you promote Francisco Alvarez from catcher? We saw him top the league in batting titles earlier this year—wait, no, that was Gabriel Moreno and Yordan Alvarez. But Alvarez showed promise behind the dish.

Sarah: Wait, hold on. Did you say Alvarez won a batting title? That was Gabriel Moreno in Arizona and Yordan Alvarez in Houston. Francisco Alvarez didn’t win a batting title. My bad!

Tom: My mistake too! Francisco Alvarez is a catcher. But his bat is good enough to play elsewhere. If Luis Torrens doesn’t click, or if Hayden Senger isn’t ready, Alvarez could slide to first base. That clears up the outfield mess with Soto potentially leaving.

Sarah: So, Alvarez at first, Lindor at short, Bichette at third... it’s a rebuild of the infield. But what about the pitching? Sean Manaea is a starter. Do you keep him?

Tom: Manaea is an ace. If you’re going to spend on Lindor and maybe Soto, you need Manaea. But look at the rest of the rotation. Chayce McDermott moved to the bullpen? No, wait, the roster lists him as RP. Kodai Senga is listed as RP too. That’s a massive change. Senga in relief? That’s a gamble.

Sarah: Senga in the bullpen is wild. He’s used to starting five innings. Can he handle high-leverage relief? You also have Devin Williams coming in. He’s a closer. So you have Williams closing, McDermott middle relief, and Senga... where does he fit?

Tom: If Senga isn’t starting, he’s a swingman. But why demote a guy like that unless you’re desperate? It suggests the front office doesn’t believe in the starting rotation beyond Manaea and maybe Robert Stock or Zac Thornton. It’s a thin group. Jonah Tong and Christian Scott are young arms. Nolan McLean is there too.

Sarah: It feels like they’re preparing for a fire sale. Or a complete reset. Let’s move to Segment Two. We need to talk about the bullpen depth. With Williams, McDermott, and Senga all shifted or added, how do you manage late-game situations?

Tom: You don’t. Not really. You rely on Devin Williams. He’s the best reliever on the roster. But what happens when he gets tired? You have Philip Abner, Daniel Duarte, Justin Hagenman, Nate Lavender, Tobias Myers, Dedniel Nunez, Cionel Perez, Jonathan Pintaro, Dylan Ross, Austin Warren, Jack Weisenburger, Cameron Weston, Jefry Yan. That’s a lot of bodies.

Sarah: That’s twelve other pitchers! Most of them are minor leaguers or fringe majors. In a 162-game season, you burn through guys like Dustin May—wait, no, May isn’t here. Guys like Cionel Perez or Dedniel Nunez. Are any of these guys reliable?

Tom: Cionel Perez has had injury issues. Dedniel Nunez is volatile. The reality is, if you lose Williams and McDermott, you’re playing chicken with your bullpen every night. This is why the 74-88 record happened. You couldn’t close games. Remember the finale? Chaparro hit two bombs. That’s what happens when your back end is weak.

Sarah: So, do you trade for a reliever? Or do you sign one? With Stearns saying no mulligans, does he even have the budget? Or is he looking at internal options like Kodai Senga finally finding his role in relief?

Tom: Senga in relief is the wildcard. If he figures it out, you save millions on a free-agent closer. If he fails, you’re stuck with a mid-tier arm. It’s a high-risk, high-reward move. But honestly, I think they’ll try to trade for a veteran setup man. Someone like Josh Hader—no, wait, he’s not available. Maybe someone cheaper.

Sarah: Let’s pivot to the outfield. With Soto potentially gone, you have Juan Soto’s spot open. You have Nick Morabito, Carson Benge, Cristian Pache, and A.J. Ewing. Who wins the job?

Tom: Cristian Pache is the defensive specialist. If you’re building a winner, you need defense in center. But A.J. Ewing has shown flashes of power. We talked about him last week. He’s a fan favorite. But can he hit .250 consistently? Probably not yet. Morabito is a platoon option.

Sarah: So it’s Pache in center, Morabito in left, and Benge in right? That’s a young, fast outfield. But it lacks experience. If Soto stays, you have a monster lineup. If he goes, you have a gap.

Tom: And what about Ronny Mauricio? He’s at shortstop. With Lindor there, Mauricio is redundant. Unless... you move Mauricio to second base? No, Semien is there. You move Mauricio to the outfield? He’s raw. This roster is cluttered. Stearns needs to clear space.

Sarah: Cluttered is one word. Chaotic is another. Let’s talk about the catchers. Francisco Alvarez, Luis Torrens, Hayden Senger. Three catchers. Who’s the everyday guy?

Tom: Alvarez has the best bat. Torrens has the experience. Senger is the prospect. If Alvarez moves to first base, Torrens takes over catching duties. That simplifies things. But Torrens’ defense has been questioned. Alvarez behind the plate is smoother.

Sarah: So Alvarez at first, Torrens catching. That works. But then who plays third base? Bichette. Who plays second? Semien. Who plays short? Lindor. Who plays left? Morabito or Benge. Center? Pache. Right? Benge or Ewing. It’s a new look.

Tom: It’s a rebuilding lineup. Power from Lindor, Bichette, Alvarez. Speed from Mauricio, Pache, Ewing. But contact? That’s the question. You need to improve plate discipline across the board. Launch angles need to be optimized. Defensive positioning is critical with this athletic group.

Sarah: Okay, Segment Three. Roster cut predictions. Who’s definitely out? Who’s trending up?

Tom: Trending down: Robert Stock. He’s a starter, but the rotation is thin. If he’s not a top-five guy, he’s gone. Also, Ethan Small—wait, he’s not on the list. But guys like Zack Wheeler? No, he’s not here. Let’s stick to the roster. Cody Thomas? Not here. How about Christian Cairo? He’s at shortstop. With Lindor and Mauricio, Cairo is expendable.

Sarah: Cairo is gone. What about the bullpen arms? Who stays? Devin Williams is locked in. Chayce McDermott seems to have earned his spot. What about Cionel Perez? He’s been around a long time.

Tom: Perez is risky. I’d rather see Dedniel Nunez or Austin Warren fight for the last spot. Warren has strikeout stuff. Nunez has velocity. Perez has command issues. I’d bet on Warren making the club.

Sarah: So, final roster projection: Lindor, Bichette, Semien, Vientos/Alvarez, Soto (if signed) or Morabito/Benge/Pache/Ewing in OF, Torrens at C, Manaea/McDermott/Senga in Rotation, Williams/Closer. Who’s the surprise call-up?

Tom: A.J. Ewing. He’s too popular, too talented to send down immediately. He’ll get Spring Training invite. And maybe Ronny Mauricio gets one more shot in the outfield. But mostly, it’s about trimming the fat.

Sarah: Stearns said no mulligans. So this is it. The clean slate. 74-88 is painful, but it’s necessary. Now, the real work begins. Do you agree, Tom? Or do you think they’ll panic-buy?

Tom: I think they’ll be cautious. They have payroll flexibility, but Stearns is disciplined. He won’t repeat the Alonso mistakes. Expect a quiet offseason, focused on internal development and targeted free agent signings. No panic buys.

Sarah: There you have it. The Mets are entering a new era. Soto, Lindor, Manaea, and a rebuilt bullpen. It’s going to be an interesting winter. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Tom: If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review. Share it with your friends. Let’s keep the conversation going.

Sarah: We’ll see you next time. Go Mets!