Carly: Vinnie Pasquantino with a two-homer game to end the regular season, but the bigger question is whether this team can survive the winter without their bullpen.
Doug: We are looking at a 69-93 record, fifth in the AL Central, and a roster that needs some serious structural changes before spring training.
Carly: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we break down every MLB team from top to bottom. I’m Carly, and I’m joined by Doug. Today we’re doing our annual Power Rankings deep dive on the Kansas City Royals. We’ve got three things for you: where they stand in the division right now, the glaring holes in the middle relief corps, and what a realistic win projection looks like for 2027.
Doug: It’s been a long year, Carly. But as we always say, even in the losses, there are data points that tell us exactly where the franchise needs to go.
Carly: Before we get into the rankings, quick favor if you found yesterday’s mailbag useful or learned something new about Maikel Garcia’s defense today — please consider chipping in to keep the show free and daily. Just head to the link in the episode description. Your support keeps these deep dives happening. Now, let’s talk standings.
Doug: So, first up: Where do the Royals rank in the AL Central? They finished 69-93. Fifth place. It’s a stark contrast to last year, but it’s also a reflection of a division that was incredibly tight until the final week.
Carly: Right. And we saw it play out live. The Guardians clinched their third straight AL Central crown. They had an 85-76 record. That’s a massive gap between Cleveland and Kansas City. When you look at the final weekend, the Guardians beat the Royals 3-2 in the finale, but they had already secured the title with that 12-9 win earlier in the week.
Doug: The math was simple. Cleveland maintained a one-game lead over Chicago heading into the final series. And then the White Sox, ironically, clinched a playoff spot by beating the Royals 9-1. So Kansas City effectively helped eliminate a rival while failing to climb above .500 themselves.
Carly: It’s funny how those narratives shift. You have the White Sox going from back-to-back 100-loss seasons to making the playoffs, while the Royals slip to fifth. In terms of power rankings, this puts KC squarely in the 'rebuild' tier, not the 'contender' tier. They aren’t just behind Cleveland; they’re behind Minnesota and Detroit too, likely, given the 69 wins.
Doug: Agreed. The gap isn’t just about talent; it’s about consistency. The Royals had moments, like that 3-2 victory over Cleveland to snap a three-game skid, but they couldn’t sustain momentum. They were swept or dropped close games against teams they should have beaten more often.
Carly: And let’s be clear, finishing fifth in the AL Central means no postseason. No October baseball for Bobby Witt Jr. and company. That has to sting, especially after the hype train earlier in the year.
Doug: It does. But here’s the nuance: losing five games below .500 gives you clarity. You know exactly what you don’t have. And that brings us to the biggest weakness of this roster.
Carly: Let’s talk strengths and weaknesses. We mentioned the bullpen injuries all week. What did we see from the staff in 2026?
Doug: The bullpen was decimated. Craig Kimbrel was there, Lucas Erceg, Alex Lange, Nathan Pearson. But when you lose middle relievers mid-season, you’re left with guys like Spencer Bivens, Mason Black, and Tony Gonsolin trying to fill gaps they weren’t built for.
Carly: And yet, in that finale against Cleveland, the bullpen held on for the 3-2 win. Vinnie hit two homers, but the relief pitching had to be sharp to keep it close.
Doug: They did. But it’s a small sample size. The broader trend is that the Royals lack reliable middle relief. Last night, and indeed the whole series, we saw how exposed they are when the starter doesn’t go deep or the setup man is missing.
Carly: So, strength? Offense. Specifically, the core. Bobby Witt Jr. at shortstop, Salvador Perez behind the plate, and Vinnie Pasquantino at first base. Vinnie’s two-homer game wasn’t just a highlight; it showed he can carry the load when the pitching struggles.
Doug: Exactly. The offense is young and promising. Jac Caglianone in right, Isaac Collins in left, Kyle Isbel in center. They have speed and power potential. But the rotation is another story. Seth Lugo, Michael Wacha, Randy Dobnak, Noah Cameron. It’s a mix of veterans and rookies who need development.
Carly: We predicted last week that Noah Cameron and Randy Dobnak would be tested as rotation anchors next season. Do you still think that’s the case?
Doug: Absolutely. With the current injury situation, those two will be thrust into the #3 and #4 spots immediately. If they can’t handle that pressure, the Royals won’t improve in 2027.
Carly: And the catching battle? Luke Maile versus Carter Jensen. Who wins that job in spring training?
Doug: Jensen has the upside, but Maile has the experience. Given how much the team values defensive stability behind a young pitching staff, I’d bet on Maile starting, unless Jensen shows elite pitch-framing skills in November.
Carly: Interesting take. I think Jensen gets the nod because the team needs to build for the future, not the present. But that’s a debate for tomorrow. Let’s move to Segment 3: Outlook and Projections.
Doug: Okay, realistic outlook. 69 wins this year. Where does that go in 2027? Are we looking at 75 wins? 80?
Carly: I think we’re looking at incremental growth. Not a jump to 90 wins overnight. The division is tough. Cleveland is entrenched. Minnesota is strong. Detroit is rising. For KC to make a leap, they need specific fixes.
Doug: And those fixes are in the bullpen. As we said yesterday, the Royals must prioritize bullpen reinforcement in the offseason. Whether that’s via free agency or trades, they cannot rely on internal call-ups alone.
Carly: Right. If they sign a high-leverage reliever, and if Bobby Witt Jr. takes another step forward, I see them hitting 78 or 80 wins. Enough to be competitive in the second half, maybe fighting for a wild card spot late in the year.
Doug: But not a division title. Not yet. The gap between 69 and 85 is significant. It requires multiple players to exceed expectations. Maikel Garcia needs to solidify his role at third base over Nick Loftin or Josh Rojas. Tyler Tolbert needs to find consistency at shortstop when Witt rests.
Carly: And what about the infield battles we discussed? Third base is crowded. Maikel Garcia, Nick Loftin, Josh Rojas. Who starts opening day?
Doug: Garcia. He has the best tools. Loftin is a platoon piece. Rojas is a utility option. Unless Garcia struggles early, he’s the guy. The Royals need him to be the everyday player to unlock that offensive ceiling.
Carly: I agree. Garcia’s defense and arm are too valuable to bench. But the real key is health. If the rotation stays healthy, and the bullpen isn’t a black hole, 80 wins is very achievable.
Doug: Prediction time: I see the Royals finishing 4th in the AL Central in 2027, with 79 wins. They’ll miss the playoffs, but they’ll be relevant again.
Carly: I’ll match that. 79 wins. Fourth place. It’s a rebuilding year, but a productive one. If they can fix the bullpen, they’re dangerous.
Doug: So, to recap: The Royals finish 69-93, fifth in the AL Central. The bullpen is the biggest hole. Vinnie Pasquantino provided a bright spot with two homers in the finale. And 2027 is about fixing the middle relief and testing the young arms.
Carly: If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review the Beatline Podcast Network. It helps us reach more Royals fans. Thanks for listening, and Go Birds!