Carly: Vinnie Pasquantino went yard twice in the finale, but behind that power surge was a bullpen that looked like it was held together by duct tape and hope. Is this the core we build around, or do we tear it down?
Doug: It’s a valid question when you look at the roster list. We have Seth Lugo anchoring the rotation, sure, but who is actually closing games next April? That’s the battle.
Carly: Welcome to Beatline Podcast Network, the home of daily baseball analysis. I’m Carly Hunt, and joining me is our lead analyst, Doug Mientkiewicz.
Doug: Hey everyone. It’s good to be back for one final look at the 2026 Kansas City Royals before the offseason begins.
Carly: Today is a Roster Battles episode. We’re looking at three key areas: the immediate infield competition, the catching hierarchy, and the chaotic bullpen decisions heading into winter.
Doug: Exactly. The record is 69-93, fifth in the AL Central, but the stories are about who stays and who goes.
Carly: Let’s start with the most critical position group: the infield corners. Specifically, third base. We have Maikel Garcia, Nick Loftin, and Josh Rojas on the roster. Who wins the job?
Doug: If we’re talking pure defensive projection and offensive upside, Maikel Garcia is the favorite. He’s young, he’s athletic, and he showed flashes of brilliance last season.
Carly: But what about consistency? In the finale against Cleveland, did we see enough from him to justify keeping him over someone more experienced?
Doug: Look, the Guardians beat them 3-2 in the finale. Vinnie hit two homers, which was huge. But defensively, Garcia had his moments. The issue is plate discipline. If he doesn’t improve his OBP, he’s just a glove guy.
Carly: And Josh Rojas? He’s veteran depth. Does he push Garcia for playing time?
Doug: Rojas is a platoon piece. He’s not starting every day. But if Garcia struggles in spring training, Rojas is there to stabilize the left side of the infield. He provides safety, not excitement.
Carly: So, Nick Loftin? He’s also listed as a third baseman. Where does he fit?
Doug: Loftin is intriguing because he can play second base too. Michael Massey is currently at second, so Loftin might be competing for a utility role rather than a starter spot. Unless Garcia falls off, Loftin is fighting for bench space.
Carly: Right. So the headline here is Maikel Garcia is the incumbent, but the pressure is on him to show he’s more than just potential.
Doug: Precisely. And if he doesn’t lock up third base, the Royals might need to look externally. But internally, he’s the guy.
Carly: What about the shortstop spot? Bobby Witt Jr. seems set, but Tyler Tolbert is on the roster. Is Tolbert really a threat?
Doug: No. Witt Jr. is an All-Star caliber player. Tolbert is backup depth. There’s no battle there. It’s Witt every single day unless he gets injured.
Carly: Okay, so the infield battle is really just Garcia vs. the rest of the world. Let’s move to Segment Two: Catching. Carter Jensen and Luke Maile. Who is the starter?
Doug: This is interesting because Salvador Perez is listed as DH now. He’s transitioning away from full-time catching duties. So whoever wins this battle becomes the primary battery-mate for Seth Lugo and the rest of the staff.
Carly: Luke Maile has been with the organization longer. Does tenure win out?
Doug: Maile is the defensive specialist. He knows how to handle a pitching staff. But Carter Jensen has more pop at the plate. If the team wants offense from the catcher spot, Jensen makes sense.
Carly: But managing pitchers is key. With the bullpen injuries we saw all year, having a catcher who can calm things down is vital.
Doug: That’s why Maile might edge it out. He’s reliable. Jensen is volatile. In a tight division race, reliability often beats volatility.
Carly: So Maile is the likely starter, Jensen is the trade bait or depth option?
Doug: I think Jensen gets exposed on waivers if they need to clear room. Maile stays. He’s the glue.
Carly: Alright, let’s take a quick break. Stick with us, because we’re going to talk about the biggest mystery of the offseason: who closes the game for the Royals?
Carly: We’re back. Let’s talk about the outfield. We have Jac Caglianone in right, Isaac Collins in left, Kyle Isbel in center, Matthew Lugo in left, and John Rave in right. Who makes the team?
Doug: Kyle Isbel is probably the safest bet for center field. He’s got speed, he’s got defense. But the corner spots are wide open.
Carly: Jac Caglianone had some power. Did he show enough to hold onto right field?
Doug: Caglianone is a strikeout machine. His launch angle is great when he makes contact, but the miss rate is high. John Rave is another bat-first guy. If they want offense, Rave or Caglianone could win it.
Carly: And Isaac Collins? He’s in left. Is he locked in?
Doug: Collins is raw. Matthew Lugo is also raw. This is a youth movement. Neither of these guys are guaranteed starters in 2027. They’re projects.
Carly: So the outfield is a mess of potential. Who do you trust to play everyday?
Doug: Isbel in center. Then it’s a platoon in the corners. Maybe Caglianone against lefties, Rave against righties. It’s messy, but it’s cheap.
Carly: Let’s pivot to the rotation. We have Seth Lugo, Tony Gonsolin, Michael Wacha, Randy Dobnak, Noah Cameron, Ben Kudrna, Carlos Duran, Steven Zobac, and Ryan Bergert. Who are the anchors?
Doug: Lugo is the ace. Gonsolin is the number two. Wacha is the veteran innings eater. Those three are set.
Doug: The real battle is for spots four and five. Noah Cameron and Randy Dobnak were mentioned in previous episodes as test cases. Do they hold those jobs?
Carly: They were tested late in the year due to injuries. Did they perform well enough to keep their spots?
Doug: Cameron showed promise. He has stuff. Dobnak has experience. But neither is dominant. This is where the Royals might need to add arms in free agency.
Carly: So the rotation is top-heavy. Lugo, Gonsolin, Wacha... and then a coin flip between Cameron, Dobnak, and maybe Kudrna?
Doug: Exactly. And if one of them gets hurt, you’re looking at calling up minors or signing a minimum-league veteran.
Carly: Let’s get to the big one. The bullpen. Craig Kimbrel, Alex Lange, Lucas Erceg, Spencer Bivens, Mason Black, Jose Cuas, Anthony Gose, Nolan Hoffman, Daniel Lynch IV, James McArthur, Easton McGee, Nate Pearson, Mitch Spence, Connor Thomas, Beck Way. That’s fifteen arms.
Doug: Fifteen! That’s absurd. How many of those guys are actually making the Opening Day roster?
Carly: Kimbrel is the closer, obviously. He’s proven. Alex Lange is the setup man. He’s been solid.
Doug: Lange is reliable. Erceg is versatile. Those three are locks. The rest? It’s a fight for survival.
Carly: Who are the cut candidates?
Doug: Nate Pearson has injury history. Anthony Gose is aging out. Daniel Lynch IV is a reliever now, which is weird for a former starter. He might not make the cut.
Carly: So Kimbrel, Lange, Erceg... and then four or five spots for the remaining nine guys?
Doug: Yes. And that’s why the Royals need to trim the fat. You can’t carry that many arms. It creates logjams in Triple-A and frustrates players.
Carly: It’s chaos. But it’s also opportunity for the younger guys to prove themselves in camp.
Doug: Opportunity for some, disaster for others. I’d say be careful with your savings, folks, because this roster isn't cheap.
Carly: We’ll be right back after we discuss who’s trending up and who’s trending down.
Carly: Welcome back. Let’s do our Trending Up and Trending Down. First, Trending Up. Who impressed you at the end of the season?
Doug: Vinnie Pasquantino. Two homers in the finale against the Guardians. He showed he can still drive the ball. If he builds on that, he’s a cornerstone.
Carly: Agreed. What about Noah Cameron? He got the call late in the year.
Doug: Cameron is trending up. He has the stuff to be a mid-rotation starter. If he refines his command, he’s a valuable asset.
Carly: And Trending Down? Who disappointed?
Doug: The middle relief corps. Too many injuries, too much inconsistency. Guys like Jose Cuas and Anthony Gose couldn’t find a rhythm. They’re likely gone.
Carly: Also, the team’s ability to close out games. They lost to the Guardians multiple times, including the finale. Mental toughness needs work.
Doug: Absolutely. You can’t win championships if you blow leads in September. That’s a culture issue.
Carly: So, final predictions. Who makes the roster?
Doug: Maikel Garcia at third. Luke Maile catching. Isbel in center. Lugo, Gonsolin, Wacha, Cameron, Dobnak in rotation. Kimbrel, Lange, Erceg in bullpen.
Carly: And who’s out? John Rave, Jac Caglianone, Carter Jensen, Nate Pearson, Anthony Gose.
Doug: Those are the names getting cut. It’s a harsh spring training for those guys.
Carly: Before we go, we want to ask for your help. Keeping this show free and daily takes real work—research, editing, and production. A small contribution via the link in the episode description helps us keep the feed running and brings you quality baseball talk every single day. Thanks for supporting independent sports media.
Doug: Thanks for listening. We’ll see you in the offseason.
Carly: Subscribe, rate, and review Beatline Podcast Network. Go Royals!