Natalie: Is Austin Hedges still the starter, or has Patrick Bailey earned the job? And who exactly is closing out the ninth when the playoffs hit? We’re diving into the toughest roster decisions of the year.
Scott: It’s not just about names on a page; it’s about how this 85-77 team survives October. The AL Central title is secured, but the real battle starts now.
Natalie: Welcome to Beatline! I’m Natalie, alongside Scott. You are listening to the daily sports podcast network that never sleeps. Today is September 30th, 2026, and we are talking Cleveland Guardians. The regular season is over. They won the division. But before they face the White Sox and Astros in their final home stand, we have three massive questions. First: Who wins the catching battle? Second: Is the bullpen too thin for a deep playoff run? And third: Which outfielders are trending up versus down as we look at roster cuts?
Scott: Right. It’s a roster battles episode. We’re looking at depth charts, platoon splits, and defensive positioning. Last week we talked about Ramirez and Bazzana, but today it’s about the guys behind them.
Natalie: Let’s start with the most critical position group behind the plate. Austin Hedges vs. Patrick Bailey. One is the veteran wall, the other is the offensive spark. Who gets the nod for Game 1 of the Wild Card round?
Scott: This is the classic catcher dilemma. Hedges brings elite defense and game-calling. He frames pitches like nobody else. But Bailey? Bailey hits. If you want a lefty specialist in the lineup against a right-handed reliever, Bailey is your guy. But can he handle the pitching staff's demands defensively?
Natalie: I feel like Hedges has been the consistent voice in the dugout all year. Remember back in September when he called off the pitcher on that inside fastball? That’s leadership. Does Bailey offer enough value to displace him?
Scott: Cooper Ingle is also on this roster. So we have three catchers. But if it’s two-man rotation, I’d stick with Hedges for the first two games. You need someone who can manage Gavin Williams and Tanner Bibee without letting them get away from their stuff. Bailey might be better suited for a pinch-hit role later in the series.
Natalie: Wait, so you’re saying Bailey isn’t starting? That feels bold. What about Travis Bazzana? He’s at second base, but his connection with the battery matters. If Bailey is hitting, does Hedges stay behind the plate regardless of the matchup?
Scott: No, I’m saying Hedges starts. Bailey provides the bat off the bench or starts against a tough lefty. It’s about maximizing plate discipline. Bailey has better OBP potential than Hedges. But in October, defense wins championships. Hedges protects the strike zone. That’s worth more than a single hit.
Natalie: Okay, so Hedges is the Game 1 starter. Bailey is the super-sub. Got it. Now, let’s talk about the support system. The bullpen. We’ve got Franco Aleman, Logan Allen, Shawn Armstrong, Daniel Espino, Matt Festa, Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin, Colin Holderman, Austin Peterson, Erik Sabrowski, Cade Smith, and Andrew Walters. That’s twelve arms. Some are starters, some are relievers. How do you organize this chaos?
Scott: It’s messy. You have Logan Allen listed as RP, but he was a starter earlier in the year. Same with Shawn Armstrong. Then you have pure relievers like Espino and Peterson. The key here is workload management. If Gavin Williams goes five innings, you need a long man. That’s where Holderman or Armstrong comes in. But if you’re playing a seven-game series, you need closers. Who is the closer?
Natalie: That’s what I wanted to ask. Is it Cade Smith? Or maybe Daniel Espino? They both have high velocity. But who has the best command in high-leverage spots?
Scott: Espino has the stuff. His slider is devastating. But Smith has experience. In baseball, experience matters. I’d trust Smith in the eighth inning. Espino might be better for the seventh. You need a bridge. That’s where Peterson or Gaddis fits in. It’s not a traditional nine-inning bullpen; it’s a hybrid model.
Natalie: Hybrid model. I like that. So, Espino bridges to Smith. Got it. Before we move to Segment 2, we need to take a quick breath. Hey everyone, if you love hearing us break down these roster puzzles every single day, please consider supporting the show. A small contribution helps us cover the costs of daily research, editing, and keeping the feed running so we can keep bringing you free content. Just click the link in the episode description to grab a coffee for us. Thank you!
Natalie: Welcome back. Let’s talk infield. We have Jose Ramirez at third, obviously the star. But who is at second? Travis Bazzana and Angel Genao. And then we have the corner infield spots. Rhys Hoskins, CJ Kayfus, Nathaniel Lowe, Kyle Manzardo. Four players for two spots. Who makes the cut?
Scott: Bazzana is locked in. He’s our everyday second baseman. He provides contact and plate discipline. Genao is the backup. But the corner infield is interesting. Lowe is the veteran presence. He’s reliable. Hoskins is the power threat. Manzardo is the young gun. Kayfus is the utility option.
Natalie: So Lowe stays. Hoskins is traded? Or is he the everyday first baseman? I thought Hoskins was acquired for his power. Does he fit the Guardians’ style of play?
Scott: Hoskins is a maverick in this system. He’s big, he pulls the ball, he launches it. It doesn’t always align with our launch angle optimization. But in the playoffs, you need power. I think Lowe starts against lefties, Hoskins against righties. It’s a platoon split nightmare for the opposition. Manzardo is the fourth option, likely sent down or kept as a late-inning pinch hitter.
Natalie: Platoon splits. Yes. That’s smart. So Lowe and Hoskins share time. What about shortstop? Brayan Rocchio is the starter. Is there any competition there? No, it’s just him. So the infield is set: Bazzana, Rocchio, Ramirez, and the Lowe/Hoskins duo.
Scott: Exactly. And don’t forget the defensive range. Rocchio covers a ton of ground. Bazzana is solid. Ramirez is elite. This infield can defend well. That’s crucial if the starting pitchers struggle early. If Williams or Bibee give up a lead, the infield needs to make plays. They can.
Natalie: Okay, so infield is stable. Now, the outfield. This is where it gets messy. Jo Adell, Chase DeLauter, David Fry, Petey Halpin, Steven Kwan, Angel Martinez, Blake Perkins, Daniel Schneemann, Kahlil Watson. Nine outfielders. For three spots. Who is making the team?
Scott: Steven Kwan is the everyday center fielder. He’s the heart of the order. Chase DeLauter is the right fielder. He has the power and the arm. That leaves one spot. Left field. It’s between Adell, Martinez, and Perkins. Fry is primarily a DH/first baseman, though he can play outfield. He’s a valuable asset.
Natalie: So Kwan, DeLauter, and... who? Adell has the speed. Martinez has the contact. Perkins has the defense. Who gives you the best chance to win?
Scott: Adell. He’s the wild card. He can change a game with one swing. If you’re playing a team with a weak bullpen, Adell is your guy. If you’re playing a strong defense, maybe Martinez is safer. But in October, you want volatility. You want something to happen. Adell is that spark.
Natalie: Volatility. I love that word. So Kwan, DeLauter, and Adell. Fry is the utility piece. What about the others? Halpin, Martinez, Perkins, Schneemann, Watson? Are they going to Triple-A?
Scott: Most likely. Unless someone gets injured. But having that depth is good. If Kwan gets a bruised rib, Perkins can step in. It’s about insurance. But for the Opening Day roster, it’s Kwan, DeLauter, and Adell.
Natalie: Okay, so we have our core. Catchers: Hedges, Bailey. Infield: Bazzana, Rocchio, Ramirez, Lowe, Hoskins. Outfield: Kwan, DeLauter, Adell. Plus Fry. That’s eleven position players. Plus the pitchers. We’ve got five starters: Bibee, Williams, Espino, Cecconi, Griffin. And the rest are relievers.
Natalie: Let’s predict the final roster cuts. Who is staying on the bus, and who is going home? We have twelve pitchers. How many do you keep?
Scott: You need five starters. That’s Bibee, Williams, Cecconi, Griffin, and maybe Espino or Foster Griffin? Wait, Foster Griffin is a starter. So Bibee, Williams, Cecconi, Griffin, and... Yorman Gomez? No, Gomez is a starter too. So five starters. Then seven relievers. That leaves four pitchers cut.
Natalie: Who is getting cut? Who is trending down?
Scott: I think Andrew Walters and Erik Sabrowski are vulnerable. They haven’t shown consistent dominance. Also, Matt Festa. He’s a journeyman. In October, you want guys with proven track records. So Walters, Sabrowski, Festa, and maybe Parker Messick? He’s a starter who didn’t quite pan out.
Natalie: Messick is gone. Okay. So the pitching staff is Bibee, Williams, Cecconi, Griffin, Gomez, plus relievers Aleman, Armstrong, Espino, Holderman, Peterson, Smith, and... who is the sixth reliever? Hunter Gaddis? Tim Herrin?
Scott: Gaddis. He’s got the stuff. Herrin is older. I’d go with Gaddis. So the bullpen is Aleman, Armstrong, Espino, Gaddis, Holderman, Peterson, Smith. Seven arms. That’s a solid group. It’s not flashy, but it’s reliable.
Natalie: Reliable. That’s what we need. Now, position players. We have eleven. Do we keep twelve? Usually, teams carry twelve or thirteen. If we keep twelve, who is the extra guy? David Fry? He can play first and DH. That’s valuable flexibility.
Scott: Fry is definitely the guy. He’s versatile. He can hit lefties and righties. He’s a coach’s dream. So the roster is: Hedges, Bailey, Bazzana, Genao, Rocchio, Ramirez, Lowe, Hoskins, Kwan, DeLauter, Adell, Fry. Twelve players. Perfect.
Natalie: And the outfield depth? What happens if Adell gets hurt? Do you call up Martinez? Or Perkins?
Scott: Martinez. He’s younger. He has upside. Perkins is more of a defensive specialist. If you need offense, you go with Martinez. But honestly, you hope neither gets hurt. This is a balanced team.
Natalie: We’ve broken down the catchers, the infield platoons, the outfield volatility, and the bullpen hierarchy. The Guardians are ready. From the AL Central champs to the World Series contenders. What do you think? Did we miss anyone? Let us know on social.
Scott: Stay tuned for our preview of the White Sox series. And remember, subscribe, rate, and review. Share this with a fellow Guardian fan. Go Tribe!