Sun Devils vs Buffaloes: Can ASU Bounce Back After BYU Heartbreak?

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-11-07 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: The replay review admitted it was wrong. The Big 12 officially acknowledged an officiating error that cost the Sun Devils a first-quarter touchdown against BYU, but in college football, corrections come too late for the scoreboard. That 27-20 loss dropped Arizona State to 4-4 and left them staring down a must-win moment against Colorado tonight.

Paul: It’s a frustrating way to lose, Amanda. You give up points on a play that wasn’t even called correctly, and suddenly your margin for error vanishes. But we aren’t here to dwell on what happened last Saturday night at Provo. We are here to look ahead to tonight, November 8th, when the Colorado Buffaloes walk into Tempe.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily home for everything Arizona State Sun Devils football. Joining me as always is our lead analyst, Paul. Paul, you’ve been watching the tape from the BYU game closely.

Paul: I have, Amanda. And honestly, looking past the officiating controversy, there were some real tactical issues on both sides of the ball that we need to address before kickoff against the Buffaloes. It’s 4-4 going in. This isn’t just about pride anymore; it’s about survival in this conference.

Amanda: Exactly. So here is what we are tackling today. First, we break down the biggest storylines heading into this matchup with Colorado. Second, we look at the key players who need to step up, including Jake Fette’s passing game and Cardae Mack’s rushing attack. And finally, we’ll give you our keys to victory and a bold prediction for tonight’s game.

Paul: And remember, we predicted back on Thursday that Arizona State would defeat Colorado in their upcoming home game. We also said Jake Fette would improve his completion percentage due to better pocket stability. Let’s see if those predictions hold water tonight.

Amanda: Let’s get right into it. Segment One: The Matchup and the Storylines. Paul, the headline everywhere is that replay review error. How much does that weigh on a team that is already 4-4?

Paul: It weighs heavily emotionally, but tactically, it shouldn’t change how Colorado plays them. The Big 12 admitted the error, which means the NCAA or conference officials reviewed it. For ASU, the takeaway should be resilience. They lost by seven points anyway. If they had gotten that call right, maybe it’s a one-point game, maybe they win. But now they are chasing a deficit regardless. The story isn't the whistle; the story is how they respond to adversity.

Amanda: Right. And Colorado comes in at 3-5. On paper, this looks like a trap game where ASU should crush them. But we know how volatile the Big 12 can be. What do you see as the primary mismatch or concern coming out of the BYU loss?

Paul: The concern is still Jake Fette’s efficiency. He finished with 22 completions out of 42 attempts. That is barely above fifty percent. Against a Colorado defense that has struggled all year, you cannot afford that level of inefficiency. Bear Bachmeier threw for 236 yards for BYU, but he only had one interception. Fette didn’t throw any picks, but his 166 passing yards is low for a home game where you need to put up points.

Amanda: One hundred sixty-six yards. That feels incredibly low for a quarterback who threw two touchdowns. Were the targets distributed well?

Paul: They were spread out, which is good for volume, but not necessarily for explosiveness. Derek Eusebio had seven receptions for 48 yards. Omarion Miller caught a 20-yard pass. Anthony Miller had a one-yard score. It’s methodical, but it’s not explosive. Colorado needs to force Fette to make big plays downfield, and if the offensive line doesn’t provide that extra half-second of pocket stability, we saw last week what happens. Sione Moa recovered a fumble in the endzone for BYU because the protection broke down.

Amanda: That fumble recovery was huge for BYU. It shifted momentum completely. Do you think the offensive line issues are resolved heading into this week? We talked about roster battles earlier this week.

Paul: We’ll see. The lineup includes guys like Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, and Desean Bryant Jr. on the interior. If they can get Jalen Thompson contributing more on the edge—Thompson had one sack against BYU—the run game opens up. And Cardae Mack ran for 123 yards on 23 carries. That is solid production. If ASU can lean on Mack and keep Fette clean, they control the clock against Colorado.

Amanda: Control the clock is key. Colorado is 3-5 for a reason. They can score, but they also turn the ball over. If ASU can just execute the basics, this is a winnable game. Let’s move to Segment Two. Key Players and the Injury Picture. Paul, you mentioned Cardae Mack. Is he the engine for this offense?

Paul: He absolutely is. Look at the backup options. You have David Avit, Kyson Brown, Jason Brown Jr., Marquis Gillis. Mack is the clear workhorse. When he is healthy and getting touches, the offense flows. He got 23 carries last week. If Colorado stacks the box to stop him, then Fette has to hit the intermediate routes. But if they respect the run, Fette gets space.

Amanda: What about the wide receiver corps? Derek Eusebio had seven catches, but only 48 yards. That’s less than seven yards per catch. Does that worry you?

Paul: It worries me a little bit. You want more separation. Guys like Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., and Harry Hassmann are on the roster. We need someone to stretch the field. If Fette is completing short passes like he did against BYU, the yards after catch need to be higher. Eusebio is reliable, but he isn’t a deep threat yet. If Colorado plays tight coverage, ASU needs a bigger play from the secondary group.

Amanda: On the defensive side, Owen Long had ten tackles against BYU. Faletau Satuala had nine for BYU. Who stands out for the Sun Devils defense?

Paul: Owen Long is the heart of that defense. Ten tackles is a lot. It shows he is everywhere. Jalen Thompson with that sack is also important. The injury report is completely clean. No injuries listed for either team. That means everyone is available. For Colorado, their quarterback situation might be fluid, but for ASU, Fette is the guy. He needs to play like the starter who wants to keep his job.

Amanda: Clean injury report helps. It allows the coaches to go with their best units. Paul, before we get to our keys to the game, I want to take a quick second to talk about something important. This show is free every single day because of listeners like you. We love breaking down these games, finding those hidden stats, and giving you the deepest dive into the Sun Devils. But keeping this production running costs money. If you value these insights, please consider supporting us directly via the link in the episode description. Your contribution keeps the mic open and the analysis sharp.

Paul: It really does make a difference. We don’t use ads, so your support goes straight into keeping the show daily and independent. Thank you for listening and for helping us keep this content free for everyone.

Amanda: Thank you, Paul. Now, let’s finish strong. Segment Three: Keys to the Game and Bold Prediction. Paul, give us the three keys for ASU to win tonight.

Paul: Key one: Protect Jake Fette. If he gets sacked five times like he might have against BYU, the game is gone. The offensive line needs to set up better. Key two: Establish the run early. Get Cardae Mack going in the first quarter. It takes pressure off Fette and lets the play-action work. Key three: Turnovers. Colorado has been sloppy. ASU needs to force one mistake. A turnover swing wins this game.

Amanda: I agree with all three. Protect the QB, establish the run, force turnovers. Simple football. But we have to talk about that prediction. We said back on Thursday that ASU would beat Colorado. Are you sticking with that?

Paul: I am. Despite the loss to BYU, I think ASU is the better team at home. Colorado is inconsistent. If Fette improves his completion percentage—even if it’s just to 55% or 60%—and Mack runs for over 100 yards, ASU wins comfortably. My bold prediction: Jake Fette throws for over 200 yards and no interceptions tonight. He bounces back.

Amanda: Over 200 yards, zero picks. I like that confidence. It’s exactly what we need to hear before kickoff. Arizona State hosts Colorado tonight at 7:30 p.m. EST. Don’t miss a minute of the action.

Paul: Remember, check the official injury reports an hour before kickoff. Sometimes things change. But right now, the path is clear for the Sun Devils. Win this game, stay relevant in the Big 12 race.

Amanda: If you enjoyed this preview, please subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen. It helps other fans find us. Share this episode with your fellow Sun Devil faithful. Let’s get this W together.

Paul: See you next time. Go Sun Devils.

Amanda: This is Amanda and Paul signing off from the Beatline Podcast Network. Keep your eyes on the prize. See you tomorrow!