Amanda: Jake Fette threw for 166 yards and two touchdowns, but he also completed just 52 percent of his passes in a heartbreaking loss to BYU. If he doesn’t tighten up the pocket stability this week, the Sun Devils’ playoff bubble isn’t just popping—it’s evaporating.
Paul: And that is exactly what we are talking about today. The pocket is collapsing, the completion percentage is hovering around league average, and the margin for error against Colorado’s defensive front is non-existent.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and alongside me as always is our lead analyst, Paul. We are live from Tempe, Arizona, and you are listening to the only daily show dedicated to keeping you ahead of the curve in college football.
Paul: Hey everyone. It is Friday, November 6th. We have got a massive weekend ahead of us with the Sun Devils hosting the Colorado Buffaloes on Saturday night. This is a must-win game if ASU wants to stay relevant in the Big 12 standings.
Amanda: That’s right. We’ve got three big things to break down today. First, we’re looking at the matchup angles between ASU and Colorado, specifically how the Sun Devils can exploit the Buffaloes' secondary. Second, we’re diving into the key players to watch, focusing heavily on Cardae Mack’s rushing attack and Derek Eusebio’s role in the passing game. And third, we’re giving you our keys to victory and a bold prediction to settle the debate.
Paul: Before we get there, let’s acknowledge the elephant in the room. The Big 12 admitted there was an officiating error in the BYU game. That incorrectly awarded BYU a first-quarter touchdown. While it didn’t change the final score—BYU won 27-20—it added to the frustration for an offense that struggled to find rhythm all night.
Amanda: It did add to the noise, Paul. But as we discussed yesterday, the real story here is internal. Jake Fette’s inefficiency and the offensive line’s need for better consistency. Let’s jump straight into Segment One: The Matchup and Biggest Storylines.
Amanda: Okay, so we are 4-4. Twelfth in the Big 12. We are coming off a home loss to a ranked BYU team that held us to 20 points. Now we go home again to face Colorado, who is sitting at 3-5. On paper, this looks like a winnable game. But the storylines going in are heavy.
Paul: On paper, yes. In reality, Colorado has been playing some physical defense recently. The biggest storyline for me is not just the scoreboard, but the situational football. Remember last week? Sione Moa recovered a fumble in the end zone for a touchdown. That is special teams play, but it reflects a lack of discipline by ASU on the back end.
Amanda: Right. And we saw Bear Bachmeier throw for 236 yards against us. He found Legend Glasker for 87 yards and Kyler Kasper for a touchdown. Colorado’s secondary gave up those same types of chunks. If Jake Fette can replicate even half of that efficiency, we are in trouble. Wait, no—we are in good trouble for Colorado.
Paul: Exactly. And look at the personnel. Colorado is 3-5, which means their defense might be tired, or they might be desperate. They are coming into Tempe knowing they need a win. The matchup angle here is the wide receiver corps. ASU has Derek Eusebio, who had seven receptions for 48 yards last week. Against Colorado, if the safeties creep up, Eusebio needs to win on intermediate routes.
Amanda: And what about the offensive line? Luke Baklenko, Tana Alo-Tupuola, Desean Bryant Jr.—they faced Cade Uluave last week, who got one sack. But Uluave is a disruptive force. If Colorado brings pressure, Fette’s time to throw is going to be measured in seconds, not minutes.
Paul: Which brings us back to pocket stability. We predicted yesterday that Fette would improve his completion percentage because of better pocket stability. I stand by that, but it requires the O-line to execute their blocks. If they don’t, Fette has to check down. And when he checks down, he loses the element of surprise.
Amanda: So, the biggest storyline is whether ASU can protect their quarterback enough to make Colorado pay for their mistakes. Because Colorado is making plenty of them. They lost to BYU earlier in the year, and they’ve been inconsistent all season. But in the Big 12, inconsistency is a luxury teams can’t afford.
Paul: Agreed. And remember, the replay error admission adds a layer of psychological complexity. Did the referees miss something else? Are the officials watching ASU extra closely? It’s a minor detail, but in close games, margins are razor-thin.
Amanda: We’ll see. But let’s talk about the people who actually control the ball. Coming up next, we break down the key players and units to watch, including the injury picture—which, thankfully, is clean right now. Stick with us.
Amanda: If you love this show and want to keep it free for everyone, please consider supporting us. Just click the link in the episode description. Your support keeps our ad-free, daily coverage alive without any paywalls. Thank you!
Amanda: Welcome back. Let’s get into the trenches. Who are the key players for Arizona State heading into the Colorado game? We know Cardae Mack was the workhorse against BYU—he had 23 carries for 123 yards. That is solid production.
Paul: Mack is the engine. But look at the supporting cast. David Avit and Kyson Brown are on the roster. If Mack gets hit hard—and he will against Colorado’s defensive line—the backup running backs need to step up. Colorado tends to stack the box against run-heavy teams. So, how does ASU respond?
Amanda: By using the tight ends. James Giggey, Khamari Anderson, Anthony Miller. Anthony Miller caught a touchdown pass from Fette last week. He’s a red-zone threat. If Colorado focuses on stopping Mack, Miller becomes the safety valve.
Paul: And don’t forget Omarion Miller. He also caught a touchdown pass last week. Having two different receivers score TDs shows versatility. But against Colorado, if they play man coverage, the outside receivers like Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., and Jaren Hamilton need to create separation quickly.
Amanda: Let’s talk defense. Owen Long had 10 tackles last week. He’s a leader in that locker room. Jalen Thompson had a sack. These guys need to contain Bear Bachmeier’s counterpart. Colorado’s quarterback situation isn’t as high-profile as BYU’s, but they have weapons.
Paul: Right. And the injury picture is completely clean. No injuries reported for ASU. That’s huge. It means the starters we expect to start, starting. No surprises. That allows Coach Bielema to go with his best available lineup.
Amanda: So, key unit to watch: The Offensive Line. If Luke Baklenko and the gang can give Fette two extra seconds, the passing game opens up. If they can’t, we’re relying on Cardae Mack to carry the load.
Paul: And the defensive front. If Jalen Thompson and company can get pressure without blitzing, Colorado’s quarterback will have to make quick decisions. Quick decisions lead to mistakes. Mistakes lead to turnovers.
Amanda: We’re seeing a lot of potential here. But potential doesn’t win games. Execution does. Which brings us to our final segment: Keys to the Game and our Bold Prediction.
Amanda: Okay, Paul. What are your keys to victory for Arizona State? We need concrete steps. Not just 'play hard.'
Paul: Key number one: Third-down conversion rate. Last week, ASU struggled on critical downs. If you can’t move the chains, you can’t sustain drives. Key number two: Turnover margin. We gave up a fumble recovery TD. We cannot allow that kind of momentum shift.
Amanda: I agree. And key number three: Red zone efficiency. We scored two touchdowns against BYU, which is good, but we needed more points. Colorado’s defense will tighten up inside the 20. Fette needs to be precise.
Paul: Now, for my bold prediction. I am saying that Jake Fette will complete over 65 percent of his passes. Why? Because Colorado’s secondary is vulnerable to intermediate slants. Fette will target Derek Eusebio and Omarion Miller on those routes.
Amanda: I’m going bolder. I predict Arizona State wins this game. We beat Colorado at home. The energy in Sun Devil Stadium will be electric. And Cardae Mack will rush for over 100 yards again.
Paul: I’ll take that bet. But remember, the Bubble Watch is real. A win keeps ASU in the conversation. A loss puts them on the brink. This is a six-pointer in the playoff hunt.
Amanda: So, there you have it. Keys to the game: Third downs, turnovers, and red zone execution. Bold predictions: Fette improves his accuracy, and ASU takes the win. Now, before we go, a quick word from us to you.
Amanda: This show is completely free, with zero ads and no paywall. To help us keep doing this every single day, please chip in via the link in the episode description. It makes a huge difference.
Paul: Thank you for listening. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a friend who needs some Sun Devil optimism.
Amanda: Go Sun Devils! See you next time on the Beatline Podcast Network.