Amanda: Jake Fette threw for two touchdowns against BYU, but he also completed just twenty-two of forty-two passes. That is not going to cut it in the Big 12.
Paul: And Cardae Mack ran for over a hundred yards, yet ASU still lost on the road because their defense couldn't contain Bear Bachmeier's efficiency. The margin for error is zero right now.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily pulse check on college football’s biggest stories.
Paul: And I’m Paul. We are breaking down the Arizona State Sun Devils’ power rankings after that gritty, frustrating loss to No. 8 BYU.
Amanda: Today we’re looking at where ASU stands in the Big 12 standings, why their offensive line stability is a massive question mark, and if Jake Fette can actually fix his completion percentage before Colorado shows up on Saturday.
Paul: We’ve been tracking these trends all week. If you listened to our film review yesterday, you know we predicted Fette needs better pocket stability to improve those numbers. Let’s see if the data supports that optimism or if we’re chasing ghosts.
Amanda: Let’s start with the big picture. The Sun Devils are sitting at 4-4. They are currently twelve in the Big 12 standings. That feels... precarious.
Paul: It is precarious. In a conference like the Big 12, where parity is high, being four-and-four means you are exactly average. You aren’t bad, but you aren’t dangerous. And being twelfth puts you firmly on the outside of any playoff conversation, let alone a division title race.
Amanda: Right. And looking at the rest of the league, teams around them are starting to separate themselves. How does this ranking impact their bowl outlook heading into November?
Paul: It keeps them in the New Year’s Six bubble conversation, but barely. If they lose to Colorado, which is also struggling at 3-5, they could easily slide out of the top fifteen entirely. The standing isn’t just about pride; it’s about selection committee perception.
Amanda: So they need a win. But they just lost a close one to a ranked team. Does beating BYU, even in defeat, help their case at all?
Paul: Marginally. Playing a Top 10 team and staying within seven points is a good story. But the fact that the Big 12 admitted a replay error incorrectly awarded BYU a first-quarter touchdown complicates the narrative. It suggests ASU was robbed of momentum early, which makes the loss sting more for evaluators.
Amanda: That’s a huge deal though. A missed call that changes the scoring dynamic. Do you think the committee factors in officiating errors when they look at close losses?
Paul: Rarely explicitly. They look at who won and who lost. The takeaway is still: Arizona State couldn’t close out a game against a elite defense. That’s the headline. The error is context, but not a get-out-of-jail-free card for the record.
Amanda: Okay, so they are stuck in the middle of the pack. Twelfth place. Now let’s talk about what is actually happening on the field. What are the Sun Devils doing right?
Paul: The run game. Cardae Mack is having a solid season. He had twenty-three carries for one hundred and twenty-three yards against BYU. That is efficient production. When Mack runs, the offense has life.
Amanda: We talked about this yesterday too. You said ASU must lean heavier on Mack. Did they do that enough against BYU?
Paul: They tried, but the passing game was so inefficient that it put too much pressure on the rushing attack to carry the load. Twenty-two completions on forty-two attempts is fifty-two percent. That is below league average for a starting quarterback in this era.
Amanda: Fifty-two percent. That’s rough. So the strength is the ground game, but the weakness is clearly the aerial attack and the protection around Fette?
Paul: Exactly. Bear Bachmeier only threw for 236 yards, but he was efficient. Fette struggled to find rhythm. We saw sacks from Cade Uluave, and while Jalen Thompson got one for ASU, the overall pass protection was inconsistent. That leads to third-down failures.
Amanda: Third down failures kill drives. And without sustained drives, you can’t control the clock. That seems to be the core issue here. The offense can’t stay on the field long enough to let the defense rest.
Paul: Correct. And that fatigue sets in for Owen Long and the defense. Long had ten tackles against BYU, which is high volume. If the offense goes three-and-out, Long is back on the field too soon. It’s a systemic issue tied to Fette’s accuracy and the O-line’s consistency.
Amanda: So, to recap: Strong run game with Mack, weak passing efficiency with Fette, and defensive fatigue as a result. Big 12 admits a replay error in that loss, which adds frustration. Now, we have to ask the hard question. What is the realistic outlook for the rest of the season?
Amanda: Before we dive into the predictions, I want to take a quick second. This show is built by fans who love the game as much as we do. Your support directly funds the daily research, the editing, and keeps this feed running every single day.
Paul: If you enjoy our deep dives and honest analysis, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep the content free and high-quality for everyone listening.
Amanda: Thank you for keeping the Beatline alive. Now, let’s get back to Colorado.
Amanda: Okay, projection time. Arizona State hosts Colorado on Saturday night. Colorado is 3-5. ASU is 4-4. On paper, this should be a win. But we’ve seen how close games get in this conference.
Paul: I am sticking with my prediction from earlier this week: Arizona State will defeat Colorado. The home-field advantage at Sun Devil Stadium matters, especially if Fette can capitalize on Colorado’s secondary.
Amanda: You mentioned pocket stability earlier. Do you think Fette actually improves his completion percentage against Colorado? Or is that asking too much given the O-line issues?
Paul: I believe he will. Facing a 3-5 team allows the offensive line to focus on scheme rather than pure athleticism. If Tana Alo-Tupuola and the linemen can hold their blocks for an extra second, Fette’s timing should return. He threw two TDs last week; that shows he can make throws.
Amanda: So, leaning on Mack again? Because if Fette is efficient, the play-action opens up big plays for Derek Eusebio or Omarion Miller.
Paul: Absolutely. Eusebio had seven catches for 48 yards against BYU. That’s reliable production. If the run game establishes itself early with Mack, Eusebio becomes a mismatch weapon. That is the key to unlocking this offense.
Amanda: What about the defense? Can they stop Sione Moa and the BYU run game again? Moa had two touchdowns last week.
Paul: Colorado’s run game is different. They don’t have Moa’s explosiveness. The defensive front, led by guys like Jalen Thompson, should be able to contain the ground attack if they maintain gap integrity. The bigger concern is the pass rush.
Amanda: So, final verdict. ASU wins at home. Fette gets his completion rate up. Mack continues to churn out yards. They climb out of the twelfth spot, maybe into the top ten or eleven.
Paul: That’s my take. Win the game, fix the stats, and keep the playoff bubble alive. It’s all on the line this Saturday.
Amanda: Great segment, Paul. For our listeners, if you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen. It really helps us reach new fans.
Paul: Go Sun Devils. Let’s get this W.
Amanda: This is the Beatline Podcast Network. Keep cheering loud.