Amanda: The Big 12 admitted a replay error cost us points against BYU. We lost 27-20 on a technicality that shouldn't have been there. But here is the hard truth: even with those extra three or seven points, our depth chart is showing cracks in real time. Who is actually ready to step up when the starters go down? That is what we are breaking down today.
Paul: It’s not just about the officiating. It’s about personnel. When you look at the roster after that game against BYU, specifically looking at who can hold the line and who can execute under pressure, there are serious questions left unanswered. We need to talk about the battles happening right now on this practice squad and the active list.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Amanda. And I’m joined by Paul, your lead analyst for the Sun Devils. If you’re new here, we are America’s number one daily sports podcast network. We live and breathe college football, and today we are going deep into Arizona State’s roster battles heading into the home stretch against Colorado.
Paul: Good to be back, Amanda. Look, I know we’ve been talking about Jake Fette’s completion percentage all week. We predicted he’d improve it against Colorado. But before we get to the quarterback room, we have to look at the trenches. Because if the pocket collapses again like it did in parts of that BYU game, no amount of arm talent fixes it.
Amanda: Exactly. So here is what we are tackling today. First, we are diving into the most critical position battle right now: the offensive line stability and who is holding the fort. Second, we’re looking at the wide receiver corps—specifically, is Derek Eusebio enough, or do we need more from the younger guys? And finally, we’re making some tough roster-cut predictions and identifying who is trending up versus who is trending down as we head into November.
Paul: And let’s be clear, this isn’t just about playing time. This is about survival in the Big 12. We’re 4-4. We’re 12th in the conference. One bad snap, one missed block, and the season spirals. Let’s get into Segment One.
Amanda: Okay, Segment One. The Offensive Line. This is where the season lives or dies. In the last game, we saw Cardae Mack rush for 123 yards on 23 carries. That is solid. But Jake Fette was 22 for 42. That completion percentage is rough. Why? Because the protection wasn’t always clean. We had Jalen Thompson get a sack, and Bear Bachmeier only had to throw for 236 yards to beat us because our pass rush was sporadic, but our pass protection was worse.
Paul: Right. And look, I’ll give credit where it’s due. Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko are veterans. They know the scheme. But when you look at the depth behind them, you have Desean Bryant Jr., Brent Helton, Wade Helton, and Niniva Nicholson. These are the names on the roster. The question is: who can handle the physicality of the Big 12 defensive fronts?
Amanda: I remember watching the film from the BYU game. There were moments where the edge set was fine, but the interior got pushed back. That’s where you lose leverage. If Jalen Klemm or Rob Lapuaho aren’t getting off blocks quickly, Fette is standing in a collapsing pocket. He threw two touchdowns, sure. Two TDs against BYU is impressive. But he also had that interception. That turnover came when he was trying to extend a play because the structure broke down.
Paul: It’s a structural issue, Amanda. You can’t blame the quarterback for throwing an interception if the coverage is tight and the outlet is gone. But here’s the battle: Terrell Kim vs. Matai Jefferson. Both are OL. Both need to prove they can anchor against a bull rush. If ASU wants to lean heavier on Cardae Mack—which we predicted they must—they need the run-blocking efficiency to match the volume. 23 carries is a lot. You don’t sustain that if the O-line is gassed by the fourth quarter.
Amanda: So who wins the battle right now? I’m leaning toward the veterans. Alo-Tupuola has the experience. But I’m worried about the backup plan. If Baklenko gets nicked up, does Jarmaine Mitchell step in? Or do we go with someone less experienced? The margin for error is zero. We’re playing Colorado next. They’re 3-5, yes, but they’re desperate. They want to climb out of the cellar.
Paul: Desperate teams play physical. That means heavy blitzes. That means complex coverages. If the O-line doesn’t communicate well, Fette is going to be sacked again. Jalen Thompson got one sack against BYU. Imagine what happens if the Colorado defensive line finds a gap. This is the battle: Experience vs. Youth. And right now, the youth needs to show they belong on Saturday night.
Amanda: Let’s move to Segment Two. Wide Receivers. Derek Eusebio had 7 receptions for 48 yards against BYU. That’s nearly 7 yards a catch. Not explosive. But he was the safety valve. We also saw Omarion Miller catch a 20-yard touchdown pass from Fette. And Anthony Miller caught a 1-yard score. So we have production, but do we have consistency?
Paul: Consistency is the keyword. Eusebio is reliable. He knows how to find soft spots in zone coverage. But look at the rest of the group. Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., Jaren Hamilton, Reed Harris, Harry Hassmann, Jeremiah Johnson, Plas Johnson, Jalen Moss, Uriah Neloms. That is a massive group of receivers. Where is the separation? Against BYU, Legend Glasker had 4 catches for 87 yards. He was the difference maker for them. Do we have a Glasker equivalent?
Amanda: I think Plas Johnson might be the guy to watch. He’s got size. He’s got speed. But he hasn’t seen the same volume as Eusebio. And then you have Uriah Neloms. He’s a burner. If Fette starts finding his rhythm—and we predicted he would improve his completion percentage—he needs targets who can stretch the field vertically. Neloms can do that. But can he win contested catches?
Paul: That’s the rub. Vertical routes require precise timing. If the O-line is slow, the route breaks down. If the receiver is late, the ball is overthrown. It’s a system. I think the battle here is between the slot presence and the outside threats. Khamari Anderson and James Giggey are at TE. They help in the short game. But if Colorado decides to double-team Eusebio, who steps up? Is it Omarion Miller? Or does David Avit or Kyson Brown slip out of the backfield?
Amanda: Jason Brown Jr. is also on that RB list. He’s versatile. If the passing game stalls, we need the running backs to pick up the slack. But let’s be honest, the headline is the WR room. It feels crowded. Too many bodies, not enough clear #1 options. We need someone to emerge as the primary target. Eusebio is close, but 48 yards isn’t enough to carry the offense every week.
Paul: Agreed. It’s a depth chart problem. You have too many players fighting for too little impact. In a conference this wide open, you need a weapon. Someone who forces the defense to respect them instantly. Right now, ASU is forcing defenses to earn their respect yard by yard. That’s exhausting. That’s how you lose games like you did against BYU. 27-20 is a heartbreaker when you know you played better than the scoreboard says.
Amanda: Wait, before we wrap, I have to address the elephant in the room. The Big 12 admitted the replay error. They gave BYU a TD they didn’t earn. It’s infuriating. But we can’t change the past. We can only control the present. Colorado is coming to Tempe. We are 4-4. We need a win. We need to fix the O-line, we need a breakout performance from the WRs, and we need Jake Fette to hit that completion percentage improvement we talked about yesterday.
Paul: And don’t forget the special teams. Matthias Dunn kicked three field goals for BYU. Carson Smith kicked for ASU. Special teams matter in close games. If we can keep the momentum, if we can stop the bleeding on turnovers, we have a chance. This is a roster battle. Every snap counts. Every player needs to perform.
Amanda: So, here is the ask. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or your commute, and you love having this level of detail right in your ear, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Please check the link in the episode description to support the show directly. It helps us keep this content free and daily for all of you fans.
Paul: We appreciate every single one of you. Keep listening, keep analyzing, and keep supporting Sun Devil Football. We’ll see you after the game on Saturday.
Amanda: Go Devils!