Amanda: You lost a touchdown. Not because of a penalty flag. Not because of a missed tackle. But because the league admitted they got it wrong. That is the wild, unbelievable story we are breaking down today. If you think college football officiating is simple, you haven't been watching the Big 12 lately.
Paul: It’s a chaotic week for the Sun Devils. We’re sitting at 4-4, twelve in the conference standings, and trying to figure out what went wrong against BYU while dealing with an official error that changes the entire narrative of Saturday’s game.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, your lead host, and this is the daily show where we live and breathe Arizona State football. Joining me as always is our analyst Paul. Paul, good to have you back.
Paul: Good to be here, Amanda. It’s a busy Tuesday with so much to unpack from Friday night.
Amanda: Before we dive into the mailbag, I want to do a quick check-in with our community. If this episode helps you make sense of the chaos—whether it’s understanding the replay review mess or breaking down Cardae Mack’s workload—then consider supporting the show. We keep this free every single day, but we need your help to keep the lights on. If you’ve learned something new today, please chip in via the link in the episode description. It keeps us going. Now, let’s get to your questions.
Paul: We have three segments planned. First, we tackle the biggest storyline: the Big 12’s admission regarding the replay error in Provo. Second, we look at roster battles and depth chart concerns heading into Colorado. And third, we finish with a hypothetical scenario and some quick takes. Let’s start with the elephant in the room.
Amanda: First question comes from Sarah in Tempe. She writes, 'I’m still furious about that first-quarter touchdown called on the board against BYU. The league just admitted it was an error. Does this change how you view the loss? Was the officiating the reason we didn’t win?' This is huge, Paul. Talk to us about the impact of that ruling.
Paul: It definitely changes the emotional narrative, Sarah. For sure. But tactically? It doesn’t change the final box score. The Cougars won 27-20. That extra six points would have made it 33-20, which is a different game, yes, but it doesn’t erase the fact that ASU couldn’t stop Sione Moa in the red zone later. The error is frustrating, obviously, but it wasn’t the sole determinant of the outcome.
Amanda: Right. And honestly, looking at the stats, Jake Fette threw two interceptions? No, wait, he threw one interception. Bear Bachmeier also had one. So the turnover battle was even there. But the big play defense... that fumble recovery by Sione Moa? That shifted momentum massively.
Paul: Exactly. That fumble recovery for a touchdown is a swing play. You can’t coach that kind of luck or misfortune. What we saw on film was ASU struggling with leverage in coverage. When BYU went to those quick slants, our defenders were getting turned around. That’s on the coaching staff to fix, not the replay officials.
Amanda: Here is another question, this one from @DevilDawg88 in Phoenix. He asks, 'If the league admits they messed up, why don’t they just award the points retroactively? Or does the NCAA forbid that?' It feels like we’re losing games on technicalities. Is there any recourse?
Paul: No recourse, unfortunately. Once the clock hits zero, the result stands. The Big 12 issued the statement to clear the record, essentially saying, 'Hey, we know we got it wrong.' It’s an apology, not a correction. It validates that the fans’ eyes weren’t deceiving them, but it doesn’t give ASU a win. It’s a bitter pill to swallow, especially when you’re fighting for bowl eligibility.
Amanda: It’s a tough break. And now we have to pivot immediately. We play Colorado next week. They’re 3-5. We’re 4-4. On paper, this should be a win. But after seeing how BYU exploited our secondary, I’m nervous. Marcus in Denver asks, 'Can Jake Fette fix his accuracy issues against a team like Colorado? He completed only 52 percent of his passes. Can he improve that percentage against the Buffaloes?'
Paul: Marcus, great question. I’ll tell you what—I predicted last time that Jake would improve his completion percentage against Colorado due to better pocket stability. I stand by that possibility, but it depends entirely on the offensive line. If Tana Alo-Tupuola and the rest of the line can buy Jake two extra seconds, he has time to wait for Derek Eusebio to get open. In the BYU game, the pressure came too fast, forcing him into hurried throws.
Amanda: And let’s not forget, Colorado’s defense isn’t exactly stingy. They’re giving up points. If Jake can stay upright, he should see more success. But he needs to protect the ball. One interception against BYU was costly. Against Colorado, he can’t afford any mistakes if we want to climb the standings.
Paul: Agreed. The key is balance. We need to lean heavier on Cardae Mack. I said before that we must rely on him more in the remaining Big 12 games, and I meant it. He rushed for 123 yards on 23 carries. That’s over five yards per carry. That is efficient. If we establish the run, Colorado’s linebackers will step up, opening up intermediate routes for Fette.
Amanda: So, the formula is simple: Run Mack, protect Jake, and hope the refs don’t screw us over again. Let’s move to Segment Two. We’re talking roster battles. Kevin in Scottsdale asks, 'With Pauly Keene still on the team, is Jake Fette’s job completely secure? And what role does Cutter Boley play in the offense?'
Paul: Kevin, Fette’s job is secure for now. He started the game, he played through adversity. Keene is a developmental quarterback right now. He hasn’t seen significant snaps that suggest he’s ready to take over the starting role mid-season. Boley is likely the third string option, there for practice squad depth. Until Fette struggles consistently or gets injured, the starter remains Fette.
Amanda: That makes sense. You don’t make a change based on one bad half. But the receiving corps is deep. We have Derek Eusebio, Omarion Miller, Anthony Miller, Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., and Jaren Hamilton. Who is winning the most targets?
Paul: Eusebio led the team with seven receptions against BYU. That’s a lot of volume. He’s becoming the safety valve. Omarion Miller caught a touchdown, so he’s a red-zone threat. But I think we’ll see more usage from Chance Ables and Cory Butler Jr. in space. Colorado has weaknesses in the boundary coverage. If ASU wants to stretch the field, those speed receivers need to get involved.
Amanda: Interesting. So Eusebio is the workhorse, but the others are the playmakers. What about the defensive line? Jalen Thompson had a sack. Faletau Satuala had nine tackles for BYU. Are we worried about our interior line holding up against Colorado’s run game?
Paul: Satuala is a beast. Nine tackles is impressive. But ASU did contain Sione Moa mostly, except for those two touchdowns. Our defensive front, led by Thompson, needs to maintain gap integrity. If Colorado tries to run outside, our ends need to set the edge. If they run inside, the tackles need to fill the holes. It’s fundamental football. No tricks, just execution.
Amanda: Fundamental execution. That’s the theme of the week. Let’s take a quick breather. Stick with us, because in Segment Three, we’re doing a lightning round and a fun hypothetical about the playoff picture. Don’t go anywhere.
Amanda: Wait, we aren't done yet! That was just the end of Segment Two. We still have Segment Three: Hypotheticals and Lightning Round. Paul, let’s get into the fun stuff. Here is a question from @SunDevilFan99 in Las Vegas: 'If ASU beats Colorado and USC, do we have a shot at a New Year's Six bowl? Or are we locked into a regular bowl?'
Paul: This is the big one. Currently, at 4-4, we are on the bubble. If we beat Colorado, we go to 5-4. Then we have to look at who else is playing. The College Football Playoff committee is watching closely. A win over Colorado would boost our resume significantly. But beating USC is a massive hurdle. If we win both, we might sneak into a major bowl matchup, maybe even the Fiesta Bowl if the seeding works out.
Amanda: Five wins gets you noticed. Six wins gets you respected. We need to win out. But let’s do a lightning round. Quick questions. First: Who is the unsung hero of the BYU game? I’d say Owen Long with ten tackles. Paul, who’s yours?
Paul: I’ll go with Carson Smith. He kicked two field goals, including a 45-yarder. In a low-scoring game, special teams matter. He kept us in it. Without those kicks, the margin is even smaller.
Amanda: Fair point. Second lightning round: What is the one thing the coaching staff MUST fix before Colorado? Is it pass protection or red zone defense?
Paul: Red zone defense. We gave up touchdowns when we should have stopped them. Sione Moa running it in from one yard out? That’s unacceptable. We need to tighten up inside the twenty. Pass protection is important, but if we can’t stop scores near the goal line, no amount of passing helps.
Amanda: Tighten up the red zone. Got it. Final question from Lisa in Mesa: 'What is your prediction for the Colorado game? Be bold.'
Paul: I’m sticking with my previous prediction. Arizona State defeats Colorado. I think Jake Fette finds his rhythm, Cardae Mack breaks a long run, and we capitalize on their defensive lapses. It’s a necessary win to keep our season alive.
Amanda: Bold prediction accepted. Thank you, Paul. And thank you, listeners, for sending in such great questions. We love hearing from you. If you enjoyed this breakdown of the replay error and the path to Colorado, please subscribe, rate, and review the show. It helps other Sun Devil fans find us. Share this episode with a friend who needs to hear the truth about the BYU loss. Until next time, keep your head up and keep cheering loud. Go Devils!