Amanda: Cardae Mack had 123 yards on the ground and two scores, but Arizona State still lost to BYU 27-20. How do you win that game when your quarterback throws for only 166 yards? We’re breaking down every snap from Provo.
Paul: It’s a tough one to swallow, Amanda. The stats don’t lie, but the film tells a different story about where ASU left points on the field. We’ve got the full breakdown coming up.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Amanda Martinez, and this is your daily deep dive into the Sun Devils. Paul, thanks for being here.
Paul: Happy to be here, Amanda. Let’s get right into it.
Amanda: Today we are looking at the tape from Saturday night’s 27-20 loss to No. 8 BYU. We’ll break down Jake Fette’s passing efficiency, Cardae Mack’s rushing dominance, and that controversial first-quarter call that changed everything. But first, a quick word for our listeners.
Paul: Yeah, Amanda, we want to remind everyone that this show stays free for you, with no ads and no paywall. That only works if you support us directly. Please check out the link in the episode description to help keep the lights on and the analysis sharp.
Amanda: Thank you for listening and helping us grow. Now, let’s look at what happened on the field against the Cougars.
Amanda: Let’s start with the offense. Jake Fette finished 22 of 42 for 166 yards and two touchdowns. On paper, that looks like a solid day, but the completion percentage was under fifty-three percent. What did you see on the tape?
Paul: Well, the volume was there, but the efficiency wasn’t. Fette was taking some shots downfield that just weren’t falling. He had three incompletions that were throwaway plays because his protection broke down, and two others where the receiver ran open but he missed the window.
Amanda: So the pocket was collapsing more than usual? I remember seeing some pressure early in the second quarter.
Paul: Exactly. BYU’s defensive line, led by Cade Uluave who got a sack, was getting consistent hand fights against the interior. Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko were doing their best, but when you’re playing a ranked team like BYU, you can’t give up free pressure.
Amanda: And that pressure seemed to affect his rhythm. He threw an interception too, right?
Paul: He did. It wasn’t a terrible throw, but it was a critical one. Fette tried to force a ball into tight coverage on a crossing route, and it ended up in the hands of a BYU defender. That turnover killed a drive that could have tied the game earlier.
Amanda: That’s frustrating. Because Cardae Mack was running the ball so well. He had 23 carries for 123 yards. That’s over five yards per carry. Isn’t that what we predicted would happen?
Paul: We absolutely predicted Mack would dominate. And he did. He found holes in the zone blocking scheme and turned them into big gains. But the issue is that when Mack gets stuffed or goes for minimal gain, the defense has to respect the run, which opens up play-action for Fette. And Fette struggled to hit those play-action passes.
Amanda: So Mack had a great day, but the offense couldn’t string together enough drives to put up enough points. Derek Eusebio had seven receptions for 48 yards. That’s not a lot of production for a wideout.
Paul: Right. Eusebio was the primary target, but he only averaged six yards per catch. The receivers couldn’t get separation against BYU’s secondary. When you aren’t getting vertical threat, the defense can stack the box even harder, which makes Mack’s job slightly harder, though he still managed 123 yards.
Amanda: And the two touchdowns came from Omarion Miller and Anthony Miller. So the red zone efficiency was okay, but the middle of the field was stagnant.
Paul: Precisely. They scored twice, but they didn’t move the chains consistently. You need to sustain drives against a team like BYU, especially when their offense is clicking. And Bear Bachmeier was clicking for them.
Amanda: Let’s flip the coin. Defense. BYU won 27-20. Sione Moa had two rushing touchdowns, including one on a fumble recovery. What went wrong for the Sun Devil defense?
Paul: The fumble recovery touchdown was a special teams play that bled into the defense, but the real issue was situational football. BYU moved the ball effectively in the middle phases of the game. Faletau Satuala had nine tackles, and he was everywhere, filling gaps and making plays.
Amanda: Satuala was a beast. Did Owen Long have a good game for ASU?
Paul: Owen Long had ten tackles, which is huge. He was the heart of that defense. But he was fighting through double teams all night. When you have a linebacker carrying that load, it means the front four isn’t generating enough disruption to take away his blockers.
Amanda: Jalen Thompson got a sack. Is that enough from the defensive line?
Paul: One sack isn’t enough when you’re playing a top-ten team. Cade Uluave had one for BYU, and while it’s just one stat, it represents the pressure that forced Bachmeier to scramble. When Bachmeier scrambles, he finds open receivers like Legend Glasker, who had 87 yards on just four catches. That’s explosive potential.
Amanda: Glasker averaging over twenty yards per catch is dangerous. Did the secondary miss any assignments?
Paul: There were some leverage issues. When Bachmeier threw deep to Kyler Kasper for a touchdown, the coverage was a bit soft. If you press that receiver at the line, you disrupt his timing. Instead, they gave him room to operate, and that led to big plays.
Amanda: Big plays kill drives. And then you have that controversy. The Big 12 admitted they made an error in awarding BYU a first-quarter touchdown. Does that change how you view the loss?
Paul: It adds context, but it doesn’t change the outcome. Even if that touchdown was taken off the board, BYU still had the lead. The momentum shifted after that call, and ASU never really regained control. It’s a bitter pill to swallow, knowing that officiating might have tightened the margin, but the performance gaps were real.
Amanda: Right. The defense gave up too many points in the second half. Matthias Dunn kicked four field goals for BYU. The scoring summary shows he nailed a 45-yarder late in the game. That sealed it.
Paul: Yes. And Carson Smith only had one field goal for ASU. The kicking game was a mismatch. When you’re trailing and you need points, missing field goals or having short kicks puts immense pressure on your offense to score touchdowns. And as we saw, Fette struggled to create those high-percentage scoring opportunities.
Amanda: So, defense was outmatched, offense was inefficient. What’s the takeaway going into Colorado?
Amanda: Let’s talk about Cardae Mack again. He’s clearly the engine of this offense. In our preview, we said he’d score at least two touchdowns. He did that. But he also had 123 rushing yards. What does his performance mean for the rest of the season?
Paul: Mack is becoming the focal point. His ability to break tackles and find cutback lanes is elite. Against BYU, he faced a very physical defense, and he still produced. Going forward, if ASU wants to compete in the Big 12, they need to lean on Mack even more.
Amanda: But relying solely on the run is risky. David Avit and Jason Brown Jr. are on the roster, but Mack carried the load. Do you think the coaching staff needs to diversify the backfield?
Paul: They should, but Mack is the best option. The issue is that when defenses know Mack is the runner, they stack the box. This is where Fette needs to step up. If he can hit the play-action passes to Derek Eusebio or the tight ends like James Giggey and Khamari Anderson, it opens up the running game even more.
Amanda: James Giggey and Khamari Anderson weren’t mentioned in the stats much. Did they have any impact?
Paul: They had limited touches. That’s part of the problem. The receiving corps outside of Eusebio—Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., Jaren Hamilton—didn’t make enough contested catches. Fette needs to spread the ball around more to keep the defense honest.
Amanda: So, the prediction from before was that Fette would improve his completion percentage against Colorado. Can he do that?
Paul: I think he can, but only if the offensive line gives him a clean pocket. If they can neutralize the pass rush, Fette will have time to work the intermediate routes. Colorado has a 3-5 record, so their defense isn’t invincible. But ASU can’t afford another low-scoring affair.
Amanda: Colorado is 3-5, so this is a must-win for ASU to climb the standings. They’re currently 12th in the Big 12 at 4-4. One loss separates them from a bowl game picture that’s getting tighter every week.
Paul: Exactly. Every game matters now. The College Football Playoff bubble is shrinking, and for ASU, it’s about securing a bowl berth and building momentum. They need to fix the offensive efficiency issues we talked about today.
Amanda: So, to recap: Mack dominated on the ground, Fette struggled with efficiency, and the defense couldn’t stop BYU’s big plays. Now, they face Colorado at home on November 8th.
Paul: If they can tighten up the secondary and improve Fette’s completion rate, they have a chance to bounce back. But they can’t afford to leave points on the field like they did in Provo.
Amanda: Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline Podcast Network. If you enjoyed this film review, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share this episode with your fellow Sun Devil fans!
Paul: We’ll be back next week with a full preview of the Colorado game. Go Devils!
Amanda: Go Devils! I’m Amanda Martinez, this is Paul, and we’ll see you next time on Beatline.