Amanda: That was a gut punch. Twenty-seven to twenty. We talked about Cardae Mack’s four-touchdown explosion against Kansas State just two days ago, and we predicted an upset over No. 8 BYU. Well, the Sun Devils fought hard, but the Cougars held on for the win in Provo.
Paul: It wasn’t pretty, Amanda. But it wasn’t a collapse either. Jake Fette threw for 166 yards and two touchdowns. Cardae Mack added 123 rushing yards. They stayed in this game until the very end. The Big 12 even admitted there was a replay error that incorrectly awarded BYU a first-quarter touchdown. But let’s be real—that didn’t change the outcome.
Amanda: Right. So today, we’re breaking down the box score, looking at where ASU lost leverage, and previewing the home game against Colorado next week. I’m Amanda, this is Paul, and you are listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Let’s get into it.
Paul: We’re starting with the offense. Specifically, the quarterback play under pressure.
Amanda: Okay, let’s talk Jake Fette. He went 22 of 42. That’s a low completion percentage, but he had two touchdowns. One to Omarion Miller from 20 yards out, and another to Anthony Miller from one yard out. He also threw an interception. What did you see from his mechanics in that second half?
Paul: I saw a lot of hesitation in the pocket. Bear Bachmeier for BYU was efficient—19 of 30, 236 yards—but he only threw one pick. Fette got sacked once by Cade Uluave, which is minimal, but his decision-making on intermediate routes suffered when the blitz came. He tried to force throws into tight windows instead of hitting the check-downs.
Amanda: So you’re saying the protection was okay, but the reads weren’t? Because Derek Eusebio only had seven receptions for 48 yards. That’s not a lot of production for a wide receiver who should be the primary target.
Paul: Exactly. Eusebio was covered tightly. The BYU secondary used bracket coverage on him early, then switched to zone underneath. Fette didn’t adjust quickly enough to exploit the seams. Meanwhile, Sione Moa for BYU rushed eight times for 20 yards but scored two touchdowns. That’s efficiency. ASU needed more explosive plays from the passing game to keep pace.
Amanda: But wait—Cardae Mack! He had 23 carries for 123 yards. That’s solid. And remember, we predicted earlier that he’d score at least two more touchdowns against BYU. Did he get any scores in this one?
Paul: He didn’t score in this game, Amanda. That’s the tough part. His previous performance against Kansas State was historic—four touchdowns, 159 yards. Here, he had good volume, 23 carries, but no red-zone touches. The scoring drives were mostly field goals or short passes. Mack couldn’t find the end zone tonight.
Amanda: Ouch. So the prediction missed on the touchdowns, but the yardage was still there. 123 yards is respectable on the road against a ranked defense. But ultimately, the offense stalled in the fourth quarter. The final score was 27-20. How much did special teams play into that margin?
Paul: Special teams were actually decent. Carson Smith made a 24-yard field goal for ASU. Matthias Dunn for BYU made three kicks, including a 45-yarder. But the turning point was that fumble recovery by Sione Moa. A one-yard fumble recovery for a touchdown. That shifted the momentum completely in BYU’s favor early on.
Amanda: Right, that fumble return was huge. Even though the league admitted the replay review erred on a different TD, that fumble was real. It gave BYU the early lead they needed. So moving on to defense. Owen Long led all tacklers with ten stops. Jalen Thompson had a sack. What do you make of the defensive effort?
Paul: Owen Long was everywhere. Ten tackles is impressive, especially against a mobile quarterback like Bachmeier. But the front seven struggled to contain the run outside. Sione Moa may have only had 20 rushing yards, but he scored twice. That means the defense broke down on specific runs, likely near the goal line.
Amanda: And Faletau Satuala for BYU had nine total tackles. He was a force in the middle. For ASU, did you feel like the linebacker corps could have done more to stop the inside runs?
Paul: They tried, but BYU ran a lot of power runs up the middle. Without getting too technical, the gap integrity slipped a few times. Jalen Thompson’s sack was great—it showed some pressure, but it was isolated. You need consistent pressure to disrupt Bachmeier’s rhythm. He completed 63% of his passes. That’s too high for a defense trying to keep up.
Amanda: So the defense played well individually but lost the collective battle in key moments. Now, let’s talk about the roster. We have guys like Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko on the offensive line. Did the pass protection hold up enough for Fette to stay on the field?
Paul: Yes, largely. Fette was only sacked once. That’s excellent protection. The O-line, including players like Rob Lapuaho and Filiva'a Lokotui if they were in there, did a good job keeping Bachmeier contained. But again, containment isn’t enough when you need to generate big plays. The blocking was fine; the play-calling behind it was conservative.
Amanda: Conservative. That’s the word. If you’re down by seven in the fourth, you can’t just settle for field goals. You need those deep shots. But hey, we’ve got a break coming up. Before we head out, I want to take a quick minute to ask for your support. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small contribution via the link in the episode description helps keep us free and daily. Thanks for listening!
Amanda: Welcome back. Next up is Colorado. The Buffaloes come to Tempe on November 8th. This is a home game for ASU. After losing to BYU, can they bounce back against a team that might be less experienced than the Cougars?
Paul: It’s a crucial test. ASU is now 4-4 and sitting 12th in the Big 12. Every game matters. Colorado is a tricky opponent because they often rely on speed. If ASU can fix the run defense issues we saw against BYU, and if Cardae Mack gets more red-zone looks, they have a chance.
Amanda: What about Jake Fette? Does he need to improve his accuracy to beat Colorado? Or is the running game going to carry the load again?
Paul: I think it has to be a balance. Fette needs to be more accurate on short-to-intermediate routes. Those 22 completions out of 42 attempts show inconsistency. Against Colorado, he’ll need to hit the timing routes with Derek Eusebio and Omarion Miller more consistently. If he can clean up the turnovers and boost that completion percentage, ASU wins.
Amanda: So, predictions time. We were wrong about the BYU upset. But what do you think for Colorado? Do you see ASU winning at home?
Paul: I think ASU wins this one. Home field advantage matters. The defense will tighten up, and Cardae Mack will find the end zone. I’m guessing a closer game, maybe 24-17.
Amanda: I agree. The resilience shown by Mack and Fette suggests they won’t fold after a loss. They’ll respond. So, wrap it up for us. What’s the main takeaway from this BYU game?
Paul: The takeaway is that ASU is competitive. They kept it close against a top-10 team. The errors happened, but the foundation is there. Now it’s about execution.
Amanda: Love to hear that. Sun Devils fans, keep the faith. Subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen. Share this with a friend who needs some ASU hype. Go Suns!