ASU Roster Battles: Mack's Load, Keene's Command, and the BYU Test

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-28 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Four touchdowns. One player. A team riding high after a statement win over Kansas State. But here’s the catch: Cardae Mack just carried the ball twenty-six times. Can he keep that pace up when we hit No. 8 BYU on the road? Or is the Sun Devils’ depth chart about to face its biggest stress test of the season?

Paul: It’s not just about how many yards Cardae has; it’s about who steps in if he needs five minutes of rest against a Cougars defense that loves to pressure. We’re looking at roster battles that could define this Big 12 run.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily dive into Arizona State football. Joining me as always is our analyst Paul. Paul, thanks for being here.

Paul: Happy Saturday, Amanda. Good to be back with the ASU faithful.

Amanda: Let’s set the stage. The Sun Devils are sitting at 4-3, currently ninth in the Big 12 standings. They just shook off a bit of rust with a solid 28-17 victory over Kansas State on Saturday night in Tempe. It wasn’t pretty early on, but it was effective. And now, the calendar flips. We’re heading to Provo to take on No. 8 BYU this Friday night. That is a massive step up in competition.

Paul: Right. And you can’t talk about this win without acknowledging the shift at quarterback. Coach Kenny Dillingham went with Pauly Keene over Cutter Boley, and it paid dividends. Keene was efficient, mistake-free, and let the playmakers do their work. But today, we’re talking roster battles. Who is earning their snap count? Who is fighting for relevance? And who might find themselves on the bubble as we head into October?

Amanda: Exactly. So here is what we’ve got lined up for you today. First, we’re going deep on the most critical position battle right now: the running back workload and the immediate implications for the BYU game. Second, we’ll look at the wide receiver corps—specifically Reed Harris’s breakout—and whether the depth behind him is ready for prime time. And third, we’re making some roster-cut predictions. Who is trending up, and who is in danger of losing their spot before November hits? Stick with us.

Amanda: Let’s jump straight into Segment One. The elephant in the room, or should I say, the elephant on the field. Cardae Mack. Twenty-six carries. One hundred and fifty-nine yards. Four touchdowns. That is an absolute masterclass in efficiency and power. Paul, when you watch that tape, what stands out to you beyond the box score?

Paul: Well, Amanda, the volume is obvious, but the technique is what jumps out. Mack isn’t just running around people; he’s finishing tackles. On those four scores, notice the contact balance. He’s lowering his shoulder on the one-yard line, which is why he scored twice from inside the six. Against Kansas State, they tried to stack the box because Avery Johnson was out and Jacob Knuth made his first career start. They knew Mack was the threat, and they loaded up seven, eight, sometimes nine men in the box.

Amanda: And he still broke through. But here is the worry. Twenty-six carries is a heavy load. Especially on the road in Provo, where the altitude and the crowd noise will be intense. If Cardae Mack gets nicked up, or even if Coach Dillingham decides to give him a breather in the second half, who is actually ready to take those snaps?

Paul: That is the roster battle we need to talk about. You look at the depth chart, and you see Jason Brown Jr., Kyson Brown, David Avit, and Marquis Gillis. Last week, Jason Brown Jr. saw very limited action. But remember, in previous episodes, we talked about how Brown brings a different skill set—a more nuanced route-running game out of the backfield compared to Mack’s bruiser style.

Amanda: So, if Pauly Keene is going to exploit single-high coverage against BYU’s pressuring defense, as we predicted earlier this week, having a receiving threat out of the backfield becomes crucial. Does Jason Brown Jr. earn more touches simply because he keeps the offense balanced?

Paul: I think he has to. If you go too one-dimensional with Mack, BYU’s defensive front, led by guys like Jordan Allen who had two sacks against K-State, is going to get comfortable. They know exactly where the ball is going. So, the battle here isn’t just about who gets the ball; it’s about who can execute in space. Brown has to prove he can make those check-downs and screen passes work. If he doesn’t, you risk getting gassed by the fourth quarter.

Amanda: It’s a delicate balancing act. You want to ride the hot hand with Mack, but you don’t want to cold-foot him against a top-tier defense. What about David Avit? Is he someone who should be seeing more snaps to keep the defense honest?

Paul: Avit is interesting. He’s smaller, faster. He’s more of a change-of-pace guy. But against BYU, speed alone might not cut it if the linebackers are filling gaps quickly. I think the real battle is between Jason Brown Jr. and Kyson Brown. Both have size. Both have experience. But only one can be the primary backup to Mack. Right now, Brown Jr. looks like the favorite because of his versatility.

Amanda: So, we’re watching Jason Brown Jr. closely this week. If he doesn’t produce, does Marquis Gillis get a look? Or is he already on the bubble?

Paul: Gillis is in trouble if he doesn’t show something special. The roster is tight. Every snap counts. If you’re not contributing on special teams or making plays in practice, you’re going to get squeezed out. Mack is playing at an All-American level right now. Everyone else is fighting for scraps.

Amanda: Powerful stuff. And it highlights just how important it is to support this network so we can keep breaking down these details for you. Because let’s be clear: the Beatline Podcast Network is free, with no ads and no paywall. Listener support is what protects that freedom. If you love getting this kind of daily, deep-dive analysis on your team, please chip in to help keep the show running. Just head to the link in the episode description. Your contribution keeps us independent and ensures we can cover every roster battle, every injury report, and every big game without interruption. Thank you for keeping the Beatline alive.

Amanda: Alright, let’s pivot to Segment Two. We’ve talked about the backfield, but what about the wide receivers? Reed Harris had a monster game against Kansas State. Six receptions for one hundred and forty-seven yards. That is a huge day for any receiver, especially in the Big 12 where the passing games are often shootout affairs.

Paul: Harris is emerging. He’s playing with great leverage. When Pauly Keene was under center, Harris was finding soft spots in the zone coverage. Against K-State, they were playing a lot of man, and Harris used release techniques to get off the press. He’s becoming the clear number-one option in the passing game.

Amanda: But here is the question: who is behind him? You’ve got Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., Derek Eusebio, Jaren Hamilton, Harry Hassmann, Jeremiah Johnson, Plas Johnson, Jalen Moss, Uriah Neloms, and Omarion Miller. That is a crowded group. Which of these guys is actually ready to step up if Harris gets double-teamed by BYU?

Paul: It’s a deep group, but depth doesn’t mean quality yet. Jalen Moss has been around, but he hasn’t shown consistent separation skills. Harry Hassmann is a tall target, which is good for red-zone work, but he’s still developing route-running. The guy I’m watching is Omarion Miller. He has the size, he has the speed, and he’s been a consistent performer in practice. If there’s a battle for the number-two spot, it’s likely between Miller and maybe Derek Eusebio.

Amanda: Derek Eusebio? I haven’t heard much about him lately. What makes him a contender?

Paul: Eusebio is a physical presence. He wins at the catch point. Against a team like BYU, who likes to play physical cornerbacks, you need a receiver who can fight through contact. Eusebio does that. But again, he needs to prove he can get open on vertical routes. Harris is doing that. If Eusebio can’t stretch the field, he’s stuck in the slot.

Amanda: So, Harris is the alpha. Eusebio and Miller are battling for the beta role. What about the tight ends? Khamari Anderson, James Giggey, AJ Ia, Kristian Ingman, Anthony Miller, Landen Miree. That’s another crowded position group. Are any of them making an impact?

Paul: James Giggey has been the most reliable target in the middle. He’s a security blanket for Pauly Keene. When the pocket collapses, Giggey is usually there. But against BYU, you need more than just a safety valve. You need a mismatch. Giggey is a good move tight end, but he’s not a big-play threat yet. Landen Miree has the size to be a factor, but he’s still learning the system.

Amanda: It feels like the tight end group is a work in progress. That’s risky against a top-five defense. If the wideouts are double-teaming, and the tight ends aren’t creating separation, the offense stalls. Do you think Pauly Keene will try to force it to the tight ends, or stick with Harris?

Paul: He’ll stick with Harris until forced otherwise. Keene is confident in him. And rightly so. Harris earned that trust with 147 yards in one game. Forcing it to a less proven tight end would be a mistake. But if BYU starts sending extra defenders to Harris, then Giggey has to step up. It’s a chain reaction.

Amanda: Chain reaction. I like that. It shows how interconnected these roster battles are. You can’t just look at one position in isolation.

Paul: Exactly. Football is a team sport. Every gap matters. Every receiver matters. Every tackle matters.

Amanda: Let’s move to Segment Three. Roster cuts. Predictions. Who is trending up, and who is in danger? We’re three weeks into the season. Coaches are starting to tighten the ship. Who is on the bubble?

Paul: I think the offensive line is actually stable. Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, Desean Bryant Jr., Brent Helton, Wade Helton, Matai Jefferson, Terrell Kim, Jalen Klemm, Rob Lapuaho, Siosaia Lapuaho, Filiva'a Lokotui, Jarmaine Mitchell, Manamo'ui Muti, Niniva Nicholson. That’s a lot of bodies, but they’ve held together well. Pauly Keene has had a clean pocket. That means the O-line is doing its job.

Amanda: So the O-line is safe. What about the quarterbacks? Cutter Boley took the snap before Keene. Is Boley done? Or is there still a chance he gets called upon?

Paul: Boley is in a tough spot. Cameron Dyer and Jake Fette are also on the roster. But right now, Keene has the job. He’s efficient. He’s calm. He’s winning. Unless Keene struggles significantly against BYU, Boley is going to be the backup. And if Keene gets hurt, it’s probably Dyer who steps in. Boley might be trending down.

Amanda: That’s a harsh reality for Boley. He lost the job, and he hasn’t gotten it back. What about the defensive side? Martell Hughes had 14 tackles against K-State. Jalen Thompson had a sack. Who else is standing out?

Paul: Hughes is a rock. He’s everywhere. Thompson is making plays in the backfield. But defensively, the secondary is the group to watch. You’ve got a lot of young corners. Against BYU, who has a potent passing attack, those young corners are going to be tested. If they struggle, we might see some changes in the rotation.

Amanda: So, my prediction for roster trends: Cardae Mack and Reed Harris are trending up. Jason Brown Jr. is rising as the primary backup. Pauly Boley is trending down. And the young defensive backs are on thin ice. What do you think, Paul?

Paul: I agree with all of that. Except maybe the DBs. They’ve been disciplined. But against BYU, discipline might not be enough. They’ll need to be perfect. And perfection is hard to come by in college football.

Amanda: Perfect is impossible. But striving for it is what separates good teams from great ones. And that’s what we’re seeing from ASU right now. They’re striving. They’re fighting. And they’re preparing for the biggest challenge of their season.

Amanda: We’ve covered the running back workload, the receiver depth chart, and the quarterback hierarchy. Cardae Mack is the engine, Pauly Keene is the driver, and the rest of the roster is fighting for every inch. This Friday, against No. 8 BYU, every roster battle will matter. Will Jason Brown Jr. step up? Will Reed Harris continue his dominance? Will the defensive backs hold the line?

Paul: It’s going to be a tough test. But if they stay disciplined, if they execute their assignments, and if they trust each other, they have a chance. That’s the key. Trust. Execution. Discipline.

Amanda: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network! If you enjoyed this breakdown of the Sun Devils’ roster battles, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Devil. Let’s get this word out.

Paul: Go Suns. See you next time.