Mailbag: Mack's Madness, Keene's Comeback & The BYU Test

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-27 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Four touchdowns. One game. And a quarterback switch that just changed the entire trajectory of Arizona State’s season. If you missed it, Cardae Mack didn’t just win us a game against Kansas State; he carried the offense on his back while Pauly Keene executed a masterclass in simplicity.

Paul: It was a complete turnaround from last week. We talked about the need for discipline and a simplified scheme, and that’s exactly what we got. Mack ran for 159 yards and four scores, Keene was efficient with 160 passing yards, and the defense held Kansas State to just 17 points. It’s a statement win.

Amanda: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily dose of Sun Devil football. Joining me as always is our lead analyst, Paul. Paul, how does it feel to finally say we’re 4-3 and sitting ninth in the Big 12 after that performance?

Paul: It feels like relief mixed with excitement. Ninth place isn’t where we want to be in the standings, but beating Kansas State—especially with the way they were shuffling their quarterback situation—shows we have momentum. Coach Dillingham made the right call moving to Keene over Cutter Boley, and it paid off immediately.

Amanda: Today is a mailbag episode, so we are diving straight into your questions. But first, I want to take a quick second to talk about why we do this. This show is free, with no ads and no paywall. That’s because listeners like you keep the lights on. If you love getting this kind of deep-dive analysis every single day, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep the show independent and daily.

Paul: Exactly. It’s all about community support keeping the content free. So, thank you for listening, and thank you for supporting. Now, let’s get to those questions. We’ve got three segments today: roster battles, big storylines, and a fun hypothetical before we look ahead to BYU.

Amanda: Let’s jump into Segment One. We’ve got some great questions here. First up, we have Sarah from Tempe asking about the quarterback situation. She wants to know: Is Pauly Keene the starter going forward, or was this just a one-game experiment against K-State? Paul, you predicted Keene would throw for around 275 yards and two touchdowns. He only had 160 yards. Does that change anything?

Paul: I’ll be honest, my prediction was optimistic on the yardage, but the efficiency was there. Ten-for-twenty is a clean line. The key isn’t just the total yards; it’s the decision-making. Keene didn’t make mistakes. Against Kansas State, who started Jacob Knuth in his first career start, the defensive pressure was manageable. Keene exploited the coverage well. I see him as the guy moving forward, not as an experiment, but as the solution to the turnover issues we saw earlier.

Amanda: Right, and remember, we also predicted a 24-17 win, and we got 28-17. So we were close! But Sarah’s question is valid. With Cutter Boley still on the roster, fans are nervous about stability. What do you tell them?

Paul: You tell them that football is about winning games. Cutter Boley has been here, and he knows the system, but Pauly Keene provided the spark we needed. The offensive scheme was simplified, which helped both the QB and the receivers. Reed Harris caught six passes for 147 yards—that’s huge. When the QB and WR are clicking like that, you stick with it. Unless Keene starts turning the ball over, he’s starting against BYU.

Amanda: Okay, next question comes from @ASU_Alum_99. He’s asking about Cardae Mack. Four touchdowns in one game is incredible, but he had 26 carries. Is that sustainable? Should Jason Brown Jr. be seeing more action to keep Mack fresh, especially with the tough road test at BYU coming up?

Paul: That is the critical conversation. Twenty-six carries is a heavy workload. We actually discussed this in our preview—Jason Brown Jr. may see increased carries if Mack needs rest. Mack is explosive, but fatigue sets in, especially in the fourth quarter against a team like BYU that has a strong front seven. You can’t ask Mack to carry that load every single down for four quarters all season long. You need to share the rock to keep him effective late in games.

Amanda: So, expecting a committee approach? Maybe Mack gets 18 or 20, and Brown Jr. handles the rest? Or do we see Kyson Brown also get touches?

Paul: Kyson Brown is another option, but Jason Brown Jr. provides a different physicality. If we want to control the clock and keep the BYU offense off the field, you need a running back who can run between the tackles. Mack is more of a home-run hitter. You use Mack to break big plays, and you use Brown Jr. to grind out yards. It’s about balance. If we go one-dimensional again, defenses will stack the box, and Pauly Keene won’t have the space to operate.

Amanda: Love that breakdown. Let’s move to Segment Two. We’re talking roster battles and depth chart implications. Marcus in Phoenix asks: Who stepped up besides Mack, Harris, and Keene? Specifically, what did you see from the defensive line? Jalen Thompson had a sack, but Martin Hughes led the team with 14 tackles. Was the pass rush enough to contain Jacob Knuth?

Paul: Good question. Jacob Knuth finished with 194 passing yards and one touchdown, but he also threw an interception and had limited rushing success. Rodney Fields Jr. only had 36 rushing yards on 10 carries. The defensive front, anchored by Jalen Thompson’s pressure, disrupted Knuth’s timing early. Thirteen other players contributed to tackles, but Hughes was the engine. He was everywhere. The key was limiting big plays. Knuth didn’t have many deep shots, which kept the score manageable until Mack took over.

Amanda: And let’s give credit to the special teams too. Carson Smith kicked four extra points and Luis Rodriguez hit a 22-yard field goal. Consistency matters. But Marcus also asked about the offensive line. Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko were part of that unit. Did they protect Keene well enough?

Paul: They did. Keene wasn’t sacked once. That’s huge. In the previous game against Texas Tech, protection was an issue. Here, the O-line gave Keene time to step up and deliver the ball. Reed Harris ran precise routes, and the linemen created clean lanes for Mack. It’s a collaborative effort. You can’t separate the QB success from the line play. If the line collapses, Keene panics. If the line holds, he makes good decisions. Today, the line held.

Amanda: Next question from @DesertFanAZ: With the upcoming game at No. 8 BYU, who is the biggest matchup problem for ASU? BYU has a disciplined defense. Can Pauly Keene handle their pressuring defense, especially if they bring blitzes?

Paul: This is the million-dollar question. We mentioned this in our prior predictions: Keene needs to exploit single-high looks against BYU’s pressuring defense. If BYU shows a two-high safety look, Keene can attack the seams. If they blitz, he needs to get the ball out quickly. His pocket presence was good against K-State, but BYU is a different animal. They have more speed on the edge. If Keene can make pre-snap reads and identify the blitz, he’ll be fine. If he hesitates, he’ll get hurt. It’s about processing speed.

Amanda: So, mental toughness is just as important as physical talent here. What about the receiving corps? Reed Harris is clearly the number one option, but who else can step up? Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., or Derek Eusebio?

Paul: Reed Harris is the target, but you need secondary options. BYU will likely double-team Harris. That means someone like Chance Ables or Derek Eusebio needs to win one-on-one matchups. Jaren Hamilton and Plas Johnson are also on the roster and provide depth. If the secondary receivers can create separation, it opens up the running game even more. You can’t just rely on one guy against a top-eight team. You need multiple threats to stretch the field horizontally and vertically.

Amanda: Alright, let’s shift gears for Segment Three. We’re doing a fun hypothetical and a lightning round. First hypothetical: If Cardae Mack could trade any one of his four touchdowns from Saturday for a different stat line from another player, which player and what stat would he choose?

Paul: I’d say he’d trade one TD for Martell Hughes having 20 tackles. Imagine the impact Hughes could have had with even more presence in the middle. But realistically, he’d probably want Pauly Keene to have 300 passing yards. Mack’s 159 rushing yards are great, but if Keene had put up bigger numbers, it would have been a total offensive explosion. It’s about balancing the stats across the board.

Amanda: Fair point. Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. First: How much does this win improve ASU’s chances for a bowl game projection? Second: Is Kenny Dillingham’s coaching job safe given the rough start to the season? Third: Who is the surprise player to watch in the next month?

Paul: Bowl game? Absolutely. A 4-3 record with a win over a Big 12 opponent puts you in contention. Coaching job? Safe. Dillingham made the right adjustment at QB. Surprise player? I’m going with James Giggey at tight end. He’s been quiet, but if the offense continues to simplify, the TE becomes a key outlet. He’s undervalued right now.

Amanda: I agree on the bowl prospects. And I think Jason Brown Jr. could be the surprise if he gets those carries against BYU. He’s got the power. If he breaks a couple of long runs, the crowd will go wild. Alright, let’s wrap it up. We’ve covered the QB switch, Mack’s dominance, the defensive stand, and the challenge ahead at BYU.

Paul: The key is execution. Keep the offense balanced, protect the QB, and defend the run. If they do that, they have a chance to pull off the upset against BYU. It’s going to be a tough night, but ASU is playing its best football right now.

Amanda: Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen. Your support keeps us free and daily. Share this episode with a fellow Sun Devil fan. Go Devils!