Amanda: Four touchdowns. One half. That is the Cardae Mack story we are breaking down today on the Beatline Podcast Network.
Paul: And Pauly Keene stepping in, holding serve when Cutter Boley went down, and keeping this team right in the thick of the Big 12 race at 4-3.
Amanda: Welcome back, Sun Devil faithful! I’m Amanda, joined by Paul. We’ve got three things for you: first, a full reaction to that 28-17 win over Kansas State; second, breaking down how Keene managed the offense without missing a beat; and third, looking ahead to BYU next week. Let’s get into it.
Paul: Yeah, so many questions coming into Saturday. Avery Johnson out for K-State, Jacob Knuth starting his first career game. And then inside the ASU locker room, we had that quarterback switch. But honestly? The headline isn’t just the win. It’s the dominance from Cardae Mack.
Amanda: Let’s start with the box score because it is wild. Cardae Mack had 26 carries for 159 yards and four touchdowns. Four! In one game. Paul, we talked about the need for a simplified running game after the Texas Tech loss, and did they deliver?
Paul: They absolutely delivered. When you look at those four scores—nine yards, one yard, twelve yards, eleven yards—it wasn’t about some long, breakaway run. It was about efficiency. It was about finding the soft spots in the zone coverage and hitting them hard. Mack was moving the pile every single time he touched the ball.
Amanda: And let’s talk about the quarterback situation. Pauly Keene came in for Cutter Boley. We predicted last week that Keene would start the first half, but this was more than that. He finished the game 10-for-20 for 160 yards.
Paul: Right. And remember, our prediction earlier was that Keene would throw for around 275 yards. Well, 160 yards doesn’t hit that number, but context matters here. With Mack doing all the heavy lifting on the ground, the passing game didn’t need to be volume-heavy. It needed to be accurate. And Keene was precise.
Amanda: He did have that connection with Reed Harris though. Six catches for 147 yards. That is huge. Harris was the primary target when they had to move the chains through the air.
Paul: Exactly. Harris played with great leverage against the secondary. When you’re facing a defense that has to respect the run like they respected Mack, those intermediate routes open up. Keene put the ball where only Harris could get it. It wasn’t flashy, but it was highly effective football.
Amanda: Now, we also had a prediction that Derek Eusebio would catch a touchdown pass. Did he make an impact in this one?
Paul: He didn’t show up in the stat line as a primary receiver, which is a shame because we really wanted to see him contribute. But honestly, if you look at the scoring plays, it was mostly Mack taking care of business. The offense didn’t need to force issues to other receivers. It was a masterclass in simplifying the playbook.
Amanda: Fair point. So, Mack was the star, Keene was the steady hand, and Harris was the safety valve. What about the other side of the ball? Kansas State wasn’t exactly sitting pretty with Jacob Knuth making his first career start.
Paul: Knuth finished 26-for-41 for 194 yards and a touchdown. He actually moved the ball okay, but he struggled with timing. He threw that pick-six to Jaron Tibbs early on, which swung the momentum. Once that happened, the Sun Devils’ defense just clamped down.
Amanda: Let’s talk about that defense. Martell Hughes led the team with 14 total tackles. That is a massive workload for a linebacker. And Jalen Thompson added a sack.
Paul: Hughes was everywhere. You could see him filling gaps quickly, reading the play, and making the tackle before the runner could even think about cutting back. Against a team like K-State, who was relying on Knuth to extend plays, Hughes kept everything in front of him.
Amanda: And what about special teams? Carson Smith kicked off well, and Luis Rodriguez for K-State made that field goal. But ultimately, the special teams didn’t cost us anything. Is that enough to keep this team confident heading into the road trip?
Paul: It’s huge. Special teams consistency is often overlooked, but when you’re playing a team with a backup quarterback like K-State, you can’t give them easy points or bad field position. The kicking game held up, and the return units didn’t turn the ball over. That’s a clean sheet.
Amanda: So, we’re 4-3 now. Ninth in the Big 12. This feels like a turning point. Last week we were worried about the offensive identity. Today, we have a clear identity: run the ball with Cardae Mack and trust the quarterback to manage the game.
Paul: I think it’s more than just a turning point. It’s a validation of Coach Dillingham’s decision to go with Keene. If Keene had struggled, we might have seen panic. But he stayed calm, he distributed the ball effectively, and he let Mack do what he does best.
Amanda: Let’s shift gears. Next up is BYU. October 31st. Road game in Provo. What do we need to see from the Sun Devils to keep this winning streak alive?
Paul: BYU is going to bring pressure. They’re physical. If Cardae Mack keeps getting those 26 carries, the question is durability. Can he maintain that level of production for four quarters against a fresher defense? We need to see depth behind him. Maybe Jason Brown Jr. sees more touches if Mack needs a breather.
Amanda: That’s a great point. We mentioned Jason Brown Jr. in our pre-game previews as a potential beneficiary if Mack wasn’t healthy. Now that Mack is hot, the challenge is managing his workload. And defensively, we need Martell Hughes to continue being the anchor. 14 tackles is a lot to replicate.
Paul: Exactly. And against BYU, the passing game might need to step up slightly more. They’ll load the box against Mack. Keene will have to be ready to exploit those single-high looks. If he can hit Reed Harris or even find someone like Chance Ables in space, that opens up the run game even more.
Amanda: So, the formula is simple: Keep Mack fed, keep Keene efficient, and keep the defense on the field. If we do that, we can take this thing to Utah. Any final thoughts on where this team stands in the playoff picture?
Paul: We’re still on the bubble. 4-3 isn’t perfect, but winning these conference games is crucial. Every win moves us closer to relevance. This victory over K-State proves we can compete with anyone in the league, even when things don’t go perfectly.
Amanda: Cardae Mack with 159 yards and four scores, Pauly Keene stepping up at QB, and the Sun Devils climbing to 4-3 in the Big 12. A massive win in Tempe!
Paul: This was a complete team effort. From the trenches to the secondary, everyone played their role. Now it’s all eyes on Provo next week.
Amanda: Before we go, we want to say thank you. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Please consider supporting us via the link in the episode description.
Paul: Your support helps us keep the show free and daily for all of you. We appreciate every single listener who chimes in.
Amanda: Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. We love hearing from you. Until next time, Go Devs!