ASU Roster Battles: Keene vs. Boley & The Run Game Crisis

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-21 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: We were wrong. Loudly, painfully wrong. We predicted a 27-20 victory for Arizona State against Texas Tech. We thought Cardae Mack would break out for over a hundred yards. Instead, the Sun Devils got blown out 53-25 in Lubbock.

Paul: And honestly, looking at the tape, the run game was non-existent. Kyson Brown had five carries for thirty-nine yards. That isn’t a game plan; that’s a surrender of identity. But now we have to look at what’s left on this roster as we head into Week 8 against Kansas State.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily home for Arizona State Sun Devils football. Paul is here to help us make sense of the mess.

Paul: It’s good to be back, Amanda. And yes, I am still holding onto that prediction about the running game struggling unless the scheme simplified. It did not simplify.

Amanda: Today is a Roster Battle episode. With injuries potentially lingering and performance questions mounting, we are looking at who holds their job and who gets cut. We’ve got three segments: the quarterback dilemma, the offensive line chaos, and our final roster cuts.

Paul: Three segments. Let’s dig into the film.

Amanda: Let’s start with the elephant in the room. Quarterbacks. Pauly Keene went 25-for-34 for 256 yards and two touchdowns against Texas Tech. Cutter Boley threw a touchdown to Raiden Vines-Bright. Who starts next week?

Paul: This is tricky because Keene played well statistically, but the context matters. He was under pressure constantly. Julian Hugo had one sack, but A.J. Holmes Jr. had 1.5 for Texas Tech. The protection was thin.

Amanda: But Keene also had an interception returned for a touchdown by Ben Roberts. That’s a swing play. Does that hurt his standing more than Boley’s efficiency helps him?

Paul: It hurts, but it’s not fatal. The issue with Keene right now is decision-making under duress. Boley looked sharper in limited snaps. However, Coach Taylor usually sticks with the guy who has the most rhythm. Keene has the rhythm. Boley is the spark plug.

Amanda: So you’re saying Keene starts? Against Kansas State, who has a solid defense?

Paul: I think Keene starts, but if he gets sacked twice or throws another pick, Boley goes in immediately. Jake Fette and Cameron Dyer are on the bench watching. This is a live battle every snap.

Amanda: That’s a volatile situation. If Keene can’t protect the ball, the offense stalls. We talked about quick releases yesterday. Did we see that?

Paul: Not enough. Derek Eusebio had seven receptions for 89 yards, which is good, but he wasn’t getting open quickly enough when the pocket collapsed. The tight ends, Khamari Anderson and James Giggey, need to be more involved in check-downs.

Amanda: Right. So the QB battle is really a confidence battle. Keene has the talent, but the turnovers are killing momentum. Next up: the offensive line. It’s a mess.

Paul: A disaster. You have guys like Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, Jason Brown Jr. on the roster, but they couldn’t stop A.J. Holmes Jr. consistently. Wesley Helton and Wade Helton are veterans, but they looked slow.

Amanda: Is there anyone new stepping up? Jalen Klemm? Rob Lapuaho?

Paul: They need to play. If the line doesn’t improve, Pauly Keene’s arm strength won’t matter. Kansas State is going to blitz. They will test every single blocker on that unit.

Amanda: Ouch. Okay, let’s pivot to Segment 2. We’ve got the running back committee. Cardae Mack didn’t play. Kyson Brown struggled. What about Jason Brown Jr. and David Avit?

Paul: Jason Brown Jr. needs to see increased carries. I said that before the Texas Tech game, and I stand by it. If Cardae Mack isn’t 100%, Jason Brown Jr. has to be the workhorse.

Amanda: But Kyson Brown had those five carries. Was it just bad luck, or bad design?

Paul: Bad design. They were trying to stretch the field vertically. In the Big 12, you run between the tackles. You establish the inside zone. Kyson isn’t a power runner. Jason Brown Jr. is.

Amanda: What about the receivers? Omarion Miller, Uriah Neloms, Jalen Moss. Who is winning the slots?

Paul: Derek Eusebio is the clear number one option right now. He’s reliable. But for the slot, Chance Ables and Cory Butler Jr. are battling. Ables has been faster in practice, but Butler has better hands.

Amanda: And the deep threat? Reed Harris? Harry Hassmann?

Paul: Reed Harris has the speed. If Pauly Keene can get him open, he’s a big-play weapon. But again, it depends on the offensive line holding up for three seconds. Can they do that?

Amanda: Probably not. That brings us to the defense. Jessiah McGrew had fourteen tackles against Texas Tech. That’s huge. Is he the defensive captain?

Paul: He’s playing fast. Austin Romaine had eight for Texas Tech, so ASU’s linebackers were getting beat in coverage too. McGrew is tackling well, but the secondary gave up too many big plays. Ben Roberts’ pick-six was great, but it took too long to get there.

Amanda: So the defense is talented but undisciplined. One more battle: the tight end corps. AJ Ia, Kristian Ingman, Landen Miree. Who is the backup behind Khamari Anderson and James Giggey?

Paul: AJ Ia has been the most consistent receiver. If the offense needs a safety valve, he’s the guy. Ingman is bigger, but less agile. Miree is special teams focused.

Amanda: Okay, that’s enough analysis for the starters. Let’s talk about who’s in danger. Segment 3: Roster Cuts and Trends.

Paul: Here is my list. First, the third quarterback. Cameron Dyer and Jake Fette. One of them might get moved to special teams or released if they don’t show promise in practice this week.

Amanda: That’s harsh. They’re college kids. But depth is important.

Paul: In the Big 12, it is. If they aren’t needed, they take a spot from someone who could contribute. I’d say Siosaia Lapuaho or Matai Jefferson on the OL are next in line for scrutiny if the starters struggle.

Amanda: Who is trending up? Besides Pauly Keene?

Paul: Julian Hugo. He had that sack. He’s disruptive. If he can get to two sacks against Kansas State, he’s a key piece of the rotation. Also, Derek Eusebio. He’s becoming the go-to guy.

Amanda: Eusebio is having a breakout season. What about the running backs? Is Jason Brown Jr. trending up?

Paul: He hasn’t had enough touches to say for sure. But if he gets ten carries against K-State and finds some holes, he definitely moves up the depth chart.

Amanda: And who is trending down? Cardae Mack?

Paul: His absence exposed the lack of depth. If he’s not healthy, the team’s identity is gone. So yes, his availability is trending down, and that drags the whole offense down with it.

Amanda: So the message is clear: fix the line, trust the run, and keep Keene calm. It’s a tall order against Kansas State.

Paul: Kansas State is 4-2. They are confident. Arizona State is 3-3 and reeling. This is a must-win for morale, even if the playoff hopes are fading.

Amanda: Exactly. We need a win. And we need it now. Before we go, I want to ask you directly. These daily breakdowns, the roster battles, the film study—they are part of your morning routine, your commute. A small tip is what keeps them coming, free and daily. Please, chip in via the link in the episode description.

Paul: Your support means everything. It keeps the lights on and the analysts sharp.

Amanda: Thank you for listening. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Sun Devil fan. Go Devils!