Mailbag: Mack’s Absence, Keene’s Fire, and the K-State Test

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-20 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: You thought we were going to let a 53-25 loss silence the voice of the Valley? Absolutely not. If you missed Cardae Mack’s explosion against Hawaii last week, or if you’re still shaking your head at how Texas Tech dismantled our run game on Saturday night, this is the episode for you. We are digging into the mailbag today, answering your toughest questions about the roster, the scheme, and what on earth happens when Kyson Brown gets zero touches.

Paul: Good afternoon, everyone. It’s good to be back with Amanda and the Beatline Network. Look, I’ll be honest—the result in Lubbock was brutal. But as analysts, we don’t just look at the scoreboard; we look at the film. Pauly Keene played well. The defense had moments. And frankly, there are structural issues here that we need to unpack before Kansas State shows up next Wednesday. So, pull up those questions.

Amanda: We’ve got three big segments coming up. First, we’re tackling the elephant in the room: where did the running game go, and what does this mean for the rest of the season? Then, we’re diving deep into the quarterback controversy and the depth chart battles at wide receiver. Finally, we’re doing a lightning round of hypotheticals and quick takes to get you ready for the K-State matchup. Let’s start with the pain point.

Paul: Right. And let’s set the stage: Arizona State sits at 3-3, currently 11th in the Big 12 standings. That’s not a playoff team right now. That’s a bowl game team fighting for positioning. Every single play from Saturday matters for the narrative. Let’s open the mailbag.

Amanda: Our first question comes from Marcus in Phoenix. He writes: 'I know Cardae Mack went off against Hawaii with 154 yards, but why did he vanish against Texas Tech? Was it the scheme, or did they just stop him completely? I’m worried about Week 8.' Paul, this is the million-dollar question. Talk us through it.

Paul: Marcus raises a valid concern, though I think his premise needs a slight adjustment. Cardae Mack didn't exactly vanish because of a schematic failure alone; he vanished because the offensive line collapsed under pressure. Against Hawaii, the defensive front was slow. Against Texas Tech, A.J. Holmes Jr. was getting home consistently. When you’re losing leverage on the edge, the running back doesn’t have a hole to hit. He has to make decisions in the backfield, and that slows everything down.

Amanda: So it wasn’t that they ‘stopped’ him, it’s that they disrupted the timing? Because the stat line showed Kyson Brown with only five carries for thirty-nine yards. That’s barely a change-of-pace performance.

Paul: Exactly. Five carries for thirty-nine yards is an average of seven-eight yards per carry, which sounds decent until you realize Kyson never actually got the ball in space. The box count was heavy. Texas Tech loaded up. They knew Arizona State wanted to establish the run after the Hawaii win. So they took away the mesh points. Without Mack drawing attention, the interior gaps closed instantly.

Amanda: Wait, hold on. You’re saying the offense *wanted* to establish the run? Because watching it, it felt like they were terrified to hand it over. Pauly Keene ended up with 256 passing yards and two touchdowns. Isn’t that actually a positive? Maybe throwing more is the answer?

Paul: It’s a positive outcome, sure. Keene was efficient. 25 out of 34 is a high completion percentage. But relying solely on the pass in the Big 12 is a suicide pact. You cannot sustain drives without controlling the clock. Texas Tech won because J'Koby Williams broke loose for sixty-two yards and seventeen yards later, he broke another one for thirty-eight. Those are explosive plays that come from keeping the defense honest. If you aren’t threatening the run, you’re playing checkers while they’re playing chess.

Amanda: Okay, so the takeaway is: we need to re-establish the threat of Mack and Brown to open up Keene. But here’s a follow-up from Sarah in Tempe. She asks: 'Pauly Keene played really well statistically, but the defense gave up 53 points. Is Keene the guy, or should Cutter Boley get another shot?' This ties into the QB battle we talked about last week.

Paul: Sarah, this is the critical juncture. Statistically, Keene looked sharp. Two touchdowns, no interceptions. But context matters. Texas Tech’s secondary was gashing us anyway. Will Hammond threw for 232 yards and a touchdown, and Kenny Johnson hauled in seven catches for 120 yards. Keene was playing catch-up early because Ben Roberts returned an interception for a touchdown in the first quarter. That changes the script entirely.

Amanda: Right, that pick-six by Roberts killed any momentum. But Paul, you mentioned earlier that you predicted Arizona State would struggle to establish the run against Kansas State unless they simplified the scheme. Do you still stand by that? Does Keene need help protecting him?

Paul: I absolutely stand by it. And yes, Keene needs protection. Julian Hugo had one sack against Texas Tech, which is great for the defense, but the offensive line allowed pressure on critical downs. If Kansas State brings similar pressure packages, Keene’s accuracy will suffer. We need quick releases. We need tight end usage. James Giggey and Khamari Anderson need to be involved in the screen game to neutralize the blitz.

Amanda: This has been intense. Before we dive into the roster battles, I want to take a quick breath. Hey fans—if these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Your support literally fuels the research and analysis you hear every day. Please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It means the world to us.

Paul: Thank you, Amanda. Okay, let’s move to Segment Two. We’re talking roster and depth chart. David in Scottsdale asks: 'With Cardae Mack seemingly injured or resting, who steps up? Is Jason Brown Jr. ready, or are we looking at David Avit?' The backfield looks crowded on paper, but Saturday showed us the reality.

Amanda: David, this is huge. If Mack isn’t 100%, Arizona State needs a dynamic runner. Jason Brown Jr. has shown flashes, but consistency is key. David Avit is a speed threat. Who do you think gets the bulk of the touches against Kansas State?

Paul: I’d lean toward a committee approach, but Jason Brown Jr. offers better vision in the gap. David Avit is faster, but he’s smaller. Against a physical Big 12 defense, you need someone who can absorb contact. However, if Mack is healthy enough to practice this week, he should be the feature back. You don’t bench your best player unless he’s physically unable. The coaching staff has to make that call by Tuesday.

Amanda: Okay, let’s pivot to the receiving corps. Derek Eusebio had seven receptions for eighty-nine yards against Texas Tech. That’s solid production. But Marquis Gillis and Jalen Moss are also on the roster. Are we seeing a clear number one option emerge, or is it too early to tell?

Paul: Eusebio is emerging as the reliable target. He’s consistent. He runs crisp routes. In a system that relies on short-to-intermediate passes, having a security blanket is vital. But Marquis Gillis brings vertical speed. If Pauly Keene wants to stretch the field against Kansas State, Gillis is the guy to take the top off the defense. We need both. Eusebio for the chains, Gillis for the big play.

Amanda: What about the tight ends? James Giggey and Khamari Anderson. Texas Tech used their linebackers effectively in coverage. Did Arizona State utilize the TE position enough to counter that?

Paul: Not enough. That’s the nuance. When you face a strong safety like Austin Romaine, who finished with eight tackles, you have to attack the intermediate zones. Giggey is a blocker, which is crucial for the run game we discussed. But Anderson has hands. If Keene can get the ball to them quickly, it creates mismatches against slower linebackers. We saw glimpses, but it wasn’t a sustained strategy. That has to change.

Amanda: So, the message is: utilize the tight ends more, find a way to get the running back involved, and keep Eusebio and Gillis balanced. One more question from @SunDevilFan99: 'The offensive line struggled. Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko are veterans. Why did the protection break down so badly against Texas Tech?'

Paul: That’s a tough one. Veterans shouldn’t be breaking down like that. Part of it is scheme—Texas Tech had creative stunts that confused the blocking assignments. Part of it is execution. When you miss a block by even a half-step, the quarterback gets sacked or pressured. It’s a collective failure. The coaches need to simplify the protections. Less motion, fewer complex reads, just pure athleticism and technique. If the O-line can’t handle the complexity, strip it down.

Amanda: Alright, we’re heading into our final segment. Let’s do some fun hypotheticals and a lightning round. First question: If Pauly Keene throws for 300 yards and two TDs, but the defense gives up 40 points, is that a win for you? Or is the score the only thing that matters?

Paul: Score is the only thing that matters. Football is a results-oriented business. You can throw for 500 yards and lose if you can’t stop the other team. That’s why the defense has to step up. Jessiah McGrew had fourteen tackles, which is huge, but he can’t tackle everyone. The front seven needs to generate pressure without relying solely on the secondary.

Amanda: Lightning round! Quick takes. Pauly Keene vs. Cutter Boley for Week 8 starter? Go.

Paul: Keene. Stick with the guy who played well against a Top 10 defense. Confidence is everything.

Amanda: Kansas State win or loss prediction? Go.

Paul: Loss. Kansas State is 4-2. They’re disciplined. Arizona State is 3-3 and reeling. Unless the O-line fixes its issues, it’s a long night in Tempe.

Amanda: Bold call, Paul. Alright, folks, that’s our show. We covered the running game struggles, the QB debate, the depth chart battles, and what’s ahead against Kansas State. Remember, subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this with a fellow Sun Devil fan. Let’s keep the energy high. Go Devils!