Reaction: ASU's Passing Attack vs Texas Tech's Ground Game

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-18 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Pauly Keene threw for 256 yards and two touchdowns, but Kyson Brown was limited to just 39 rushing yards on five carries. We are talking about a ground game that simply could not get going against the Red Raiders' front seven.

Paul: And when the run isn't working, the pass protection collapses under pressure. A.J. Holmes Jr. had 1.5 sacks, and Julian Hugo’s single sack for Arizona State wasn’t enough to keep Will Hammond in check.

Amanda: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we break down every snap of college football. I’m Amanda, your lead host, joined by analyst Paul. Today is October 18th, 2026, and we are reacting to Saturday night’s brutal 53-25 loss to Texas Tech at Jones AT&T Stadium.

Paul: It’s a tough one to swallow, Amanda. We predicted a 27-20 victory over Texas Tech yesterday, and honestly, looking at the box score, it’s hard to find much to celebrate outside of individual passing stats. The Sun Devils fell to 3-3 and sit 11th in the Big 12 standings.

Amanda: So here is what we are tackling today. First, we dissect the offensive disconnect—why Pauly Keene looked good on paper but the offense stalled. Second, we look at the defensive breakdowns that allowed J'Koby Williams to explode for 165 yards. And third, we preview the critical home matchup against Kansas State this Saturday.

Paul: Exactly. It’s a reaction show, so we’re not sugarcoating it. The gap between prediction and reality was massive, and the reasons are buried in the tackle counts and rushing attempts. Let’s dive into Segment One.

Amanda: Let’s start with the quarterback play. On our previous episode, we praised Cutter Boley’s efficiency against Hawaii, but tonight it was Pauly Keene stepping in. He finished 25 of 34 for 256 yards and two touchdowns. Statistically, that looks like a winnable day, right?

Paul: On paper, yes. But context matters, Amanda. He was 25-of-34, which is high volume, but look at the supporting cast. Derek Eusebio caught seven passes for 89 yards. That’s solid, but it’s not explosive. Compare that to Kenny Johnson for Texas Tech, who had seven catches for 120 yards. The margin of error for ASU was non-existent.

Amanda: Right, and you can’t separate the passing from the running game. Kyson Brown had five carries for 39 yards. Five carries. How do you sustain drives with that kind of production in the backfield?

Paul: It starts with the offensive line. We saw similar issues last week against Baylor, where defensive vulnerabilities exposed the backfield. Against Texas Tech, they couldn’t establish leverage. When you’re averaging less than eight yards per carry, you become one-dimensional. And once Texas Tech knew it was all air, they could stack the box.

Amanda: But wait, didn’t we see some big plays? Ben Roberts returned an interception 24 yards for a touchdown, and Carson Smith kicked a 30-yard field goal. The offense showed up in spurts.

Paul: The special teams were a bright spot, sure. But offensively, the scoring drive that mattered most—the one that shifted momentum—wasn’t theirs. J’Koby Williams had two long touchdowns, including a 62-yarder. Once that happens, Pauly Keene has to throw more, which leads to more pressure. And did you see the sack count? A.J. Holmes Jr. got to the QB 1.5 times. Julian Hugo had one for ASU. The pass protection broke down too often.

Amanda: So the narrative here is that the passing attack was efficient but isolated. You had Keene hitting his marks, but without the run game to balance it, Texas Tech’s secondary could play loose. Did Cutter Boley have any impact later in the game, or was it entirely Keene?

Paul: The box score highlights Pauly Keene as the leader, so he took the snaps. Cutter Boley was listed on the roster, but the statistical leaders point to Keene running the show. The issue wasn’t necessarily the quarterback talent; it was the schematic fit. Without Kyson Brown or Cardae Mack creating daylight, the play-action was dead on arrival.

Amanda: That’s a harsh truth. We talked about Cardae Mack’s 154 yards against Hawaii just days ago, and now the running backs are invisible. This shows how quickly momentum shifts in the Big 12. If you can’t run the ball, you’re playing catch-up.

Paul: Precisely. And in a conference where speed is premium, being one-dimensional gets you punished. Texas Tech’s defense didn’t just stop the run; they made the offense respect it so much that the passing lanes collapsed.

Amanda: Alright, let’s move to Segment Two. We need to talk about the other side of the ball. Because while the offense had its moments, the defense gave up 53 points. That is unacceptable for a team trying to climb the standings.

Paul: Fifty-three points, Amanda. Let’s look at the tackle data. Austin Romaine had eight tackles for Texas Tech. For Arizona State, Jessiah McGrew had 14 total tackles. That’s a huge number for one linebacker. It means the defense was constantly chasing, never setting the edge.

Amanda: Fourteen tackles for McGrew implies he was everywhere because everyone else was getting burned. Did anyone else step up defensively? The sack stat only lists Julian Hugo with one. Where was the pass rush coming from?

Paul: It was sparse. A.J. Holmes Jr. had 1.5 sacks for Tech. That disparity tells you everything. The Sun Devils’ defensive line couldn’t generate consistent pressure. Without that interior push, quarterbacks like Will Hammond—who went 18-of-26 for 232 yards and a touchdown—have time to pick apart coverage.

Amanda: Will Hammond was efficient, but he also ran for a touchdown. A nine-yard run. That’s a failure of discipline in the secondary and the linebackers. They weren’t containing the quarterback. And then there’s J’Koby Williams. Sixty-two yards on a run. That’s a season-defining play for him.

Paul: Williams finished with 11 carries for 165 yards and two scores. That is a career-high performance. When a running back finds that kind of rhythm, it’s usually because the defense has blown a coverage assignment or missed a tackle. Jessiah McGrew had 14 tackles, which suggests he was making tackles after contact, not preventing first downs.

Amanda: Let’s talk about the turnover battle. Ben Roberts returned an interception 24 yards for a touchdown. That was a spark. Was that the only big play for the defense? What about the other side? Did Texas Tech turn it over?

Paul: The scoring summary doesn’t list any turnovers for ASU. It lists Ben Roberts’ INT return, but no fumble recoveries or interceptions thrown by Texas Tech. That’s a negative turnover margin. In a close game, that’s fine. In a 53-25 blowout, it’s fatal.

Amanda: So the defense was outmatched physically. The roster battles we’ve been watching—like the offensive line depth—are clearly impacting the defensive front seven’s ability to rest. When the offense goes three-and-out, the defense stays on the field too long.

Paul: Exactly. Fatigue sets in. By the fourth quarter, when J’Koby Williams broke that 62-yard run, the defensive ends were likely gassed. That’s why situational football is so important. You have to force punts to keep your defense fresh. Tonight, they couldn’t do that.

Amanda: Special teams had some mixed results. Stone Harrington kicked a 31-yard field goal and a 42-yard field goal for Texas Tech. Carson Smith kicked a 30-yarder for ASU. But Harrington also had a PAT blocked on J’Koby Williams’ 38-yard run. Did that impact the momentum?

Paul: It’s a small detail, but in a game like this, blocked kicks demoralize a unit. However, the bigger issue is the kickoff coverage and punt returns, which aren’t highlighted in the top stats. We know Derek Eusebio had 89 receiving yards, but if the return game wasn’t productive, field position was likely a factor too.

Amanda: It feels like every phase had a critical flaw. Offense couldn’t run, defense couldn’t stop the run or pass, and special teams had a blemish. Is there any player we can hang our hat on for next week?

Paul: Jessiah McGrew with 14 tackles is a standout effort in a losing cause. He played a full game of chess while everyone else was playing checkers. But individually, Pauly Keene’s 256 yards show he can handle the load. The question is, can he do it with better protection?

Amanda: We’ll see. As we head into Segment Three, the Sun Devils have a chance to bounce back. They are hosting Kansas State this Saturday, October 24th. It’s a home game, which should help, but the stakes are incredibly high.

Paul: Home field advantage in Tempe is real, but Kansas State is a tough out. The Sun Devils are 3-3. If they lose this, their playoff hopes take a massive hit. They need to fix the run game immediately. You cannot go into Lawrence or stick around in Tempe without establishing Kyson Brown or finding another runner.

Amanda: What does the game plan need to look like? Do we see more emphasis on the passing game with Pauly Keene, or do they try to simplify the run blocking schemes?

Paul: They need to use tight ends. Khamari Anderson and James Giggey are on the roster. Using them in the flat can help the quarterback make quick decisions, taking pressure off the offensive line. It’s about simplifying the read for Keene so he can get the ball out fast.

Amanda: So, quick releases, reliance on the passing game’s efficiency, and hope that the defensive line can finally get a stop against the run. Can Julian Hugo generate more pressure? He had one sack, but maybe he needs double-teaming help.

Paul: Double teams are key. If they can free up Hugo or get another defender into the backfield, they can disrupt Kansas State’s timing. But ultimately, it comes down to execution. The prediction was wrong last week, and the result was harsh. The team needs to reset mentally.

Amanda: We are predicting a tough test. Kansas State will test that defense again. If ASU can limit J’Koby Williams-style runs and keep Pauly Keene clean, they have a shot. But the margin for error is gone.

Amanda: To wrap up this episode, the Sun Devils dropped to 3-3 after a painful 53-25 loss to Texas Tech. Pauly Keene threw for 256 yards, but the run game stalled with Kyson Brown limited to 39 yards, and the defense struggled to contain J’Koby Williams’ 165 rushing yards.

Paul: The takeaway is clear: Arizona State must fix their offensive line protection and establish the run before facing Kansas State on October 24th. Individual brilliance from Keene and McGrew isn’t enough if the team units aren’t synchronized.

Amanda: If you love this deep dive into the Sun Devils, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite podcast platform. Your support helps us bring you daily analysis like this. And remember, every dollar helps cover the cost of our daily research, editing, and keeps this feed running for fans like you. Just click the link in the episode description to grab a coffee for the team—we’d really appreciate it!

Paul: Thanks for listening. Let’s go Sun Devils.