ASU Roster Battles: Who Saves the Offense vs Hawaii?

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-08 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: You want to talk about a wake-up call? Saturday night in Tempe wasn’t just a loss; it was a mirror held up to every single decision this coaching staff has made all season. We’re talking 55-19. A rout. And if you think the roster battles are over, think again.

Paul: It’s stark, Amanda. You look at Cutter Boley throwing for 304 yards and Reed Harris catching 125, and on paper, that looks like a competitive game. But when DJ Lagway is dismantling your secondary with four touchdowns, the problem isn’t just the quarterback—it’s the protection, the scheme, and the depth behind the starters.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and I’m joined by Paul. Today, we are diving headfirst into Arizona State’s roster battles as they prepare to host Hawai’i. We’ve got three things coming up: the critical offensive line depth chart fight, the wide receiver rotation post-Baylor, and our predictions for who survives the final cuts before conference play ramps up. Let’s get into it.

Paul: Let’s start with the most important position group right now. It’s not the skill positions. It’s the interior offensive line. After Saturday, we know Cutter Boley can move the ball, but he got hit. Hard. The pass protection issues we talked about last week didn’t go away; they were exploited by Baylor’s defensive front.

Amanda: Right, and we saw C.J. Fite get one sack, which is great for him individually, but what about the guys next to him? When you’re looking at the roster, names like Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, and Desean Bryant Jr. are in the mix. But who is actually locking down the middle?

Paul: That’s the battle. You have Brent Helton and Wade Helton on the outside, but the interior is where the pressure comes from. If ASU wants to compete against Big 12 defenses, they need a cohesive unit. Right now, it feels like there’s fragmentation. Who starts at guard? Who slides to tackle if an injury happens? That depth chart is fluid.

Amanda: And let’s be clear—this isn’t just about blocking for Boley. It’s about establishing any kind of run game. Kyson Brown had only seven carries for 34 yards against Baylor. That’s not a bad game; that’s a non-existent game. The O-line couldn’t create push.

Paul: Exactly. You can’t run the ball effectively if you’re playing from behind early. And when you’re playing from behind, you throw more, which puts more stress on the protection. It’s a vicious cycle. The roster battle here is between experience and athleticism. Who gives Boley the cleanest pocket?

Amanda: We’ve seen glimpses from Jalen Klemm and Rob Lapuaho in practice reports, but on film, it’s tough to say who the definitive starter is yet. This is going to define the next two weeks. If they can’t fix this, Hawaii won’t be much easier than Baylor.

Paul: Agreed. The talent is there, but the chemistry isn’t. Until those five guys move as one, Boley is going to be under duress. And we saw what happens when he’s under duress—he still makes plays, but the margin for error disappears completely.

Amanda: So, if you’re the coaching staff, who do you trust in Week 6? That’s the million-dollar question. Stick with us, because after this break, we’re breaking down the wide receiver room and whether Reed Harris can carry the load alone.

Amanda: Before we dive into the receiver corps, I need to ask you something directly. Every time we break down tape, track these roster battles, and bring you this daily analysis, it takes hours of research, editing, and production. Your support keeps this show free and running every single day. If you value getting the deepest football insights without paying a dime, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It helps cover the costs of keeping the feed live and ensures we can keep bringing you this level of detail. Thank you for helping us keep the lights on.

Paul: Let’s shift gears to the wide receivers. Reed Harris had a monster game—seven receptions, 125 yards. He was clearly the target of choice. But can he handle the volume every week? Against Baylor, he was targeted heavily, and he delivered. But what about the rest of the group?

Amanda: That’s the issue. You have Omarion Miller, who caught that touchdown pass from Boley, but he’s not the only guy who needs to step up. Cory Butler Jr., Derek Eusebio, Chance Ables—they’re all vying for snaps. The question is, who becomes the reliable number two option?

Paul: I think Omarion Miller has the physical tools to be that guy. He’s big, he can make contested catches. But consistency is key. In the Big 12, you can’t just rely on one or two players. You need depth. If Harris goes down, or if he gets double-teamed, who steps up? That’s the roster battle.

Amanda: And let’s not forget the young guys. Jalen Moss, Uriah Neloms, Plas Johnson. They’re on the roster, but are they ready for Big 12 action? It’s a tall order. The competition is fierce, and the margin for error is slim.

Paul: Right. And speaking of margins, look at the receiving stats for Baylor. Gavin Freeman had seven catches for 115 yards. He was consistent. ASU needs someone similar. Someone who can move the chains and keep the offense alive. Reed Harris showed he can do it, but he can’t do it alone.

Amanda: So, who are you betting on to emerge as the second option? Is it Miller? Or does someone like Eusebio surprise everyone?

Paul: I’ll take Miller. He has the size and the hands. If Boley trusts him, he’ll produce. But it’s going to take time. Trust is built in practice and in games. And after Saturday, that trust needs to be rebuilt.

Amanda: Fair point. It’s not just about talent; it’s about chemistry. And that’s something that takes time to develop. As we look ahead to Hawaii, we need to see who steps up in that receiver room.

Paul: Absolutely. And don’t forget the tight ends. Khamari Anderson, James Giggey, AJ Ia. They provide a safety valve for Boley. In a passing game like this, those short throws are crucial. Who is the primary tight end? That’s another battle to watch.

Amanda: Good call. The TE room is often overlooked, but it’s vital for balancing the offense. If ASU can establish a credible threat there, it opens up more space for Harris and the others. We’ll see how the coaches utilize them against Hawaii.

Paul: Exactly. It’s all about balance. You can’t just throw it to Harris every play. Defenses will adjust. You need multiple weapons. And right now, the weapon depth is being tested.

Amanda: Stick around, because next up, we’re predicting which players are trending up and who might be facing their final chance to prove themselves on this roster.

Amanda: Alright, let’s talk roster cuts and trends. Who is trending up after a tough loss? And who is in danger?

Paul: Cutter Boley is trending up. Despite the loss, he threw for 304 yards and a touchdown. He made good decisions when he had time. He’s resilient. And that’s what you want from your starting quarterback.

Amanda: I agree. He didn’t fold. He kept pushing. And Reed Harris? He’s definitely trending up. 125 yards is impressive. He proved he can win you games.

Paul: But let’s talk about the running backs. Kyson Brown had a quiet game. David Avit, Jason Brown Jr., Marquis Gillis—they’re all waiting in the wings. Someone needs to break out soon. The run game is stagnant.

Amanda: True. And if the run game doesn’t improve, the passing game becomes predictable. Defenses will stack the box and force Boley to beat them one-on-one. That’s a tough ask.

Paul: So, my prediction? One of the backup RBs steps up against Hawaii. Maybe Cardae Mack or David Avit gets some touches and finds a rhythm. The coaching staff needs to take a risk.

Amanda: I like that. Risk-taking is sometimes necessary. Especially when the status quo isn’t working. And what about the defense? Owen Long had 14 tackles. He’s a leader. Is he trending up?

Paul: Owen Long is always relevant. But individual stats don’t tell the whole story. The defense gave up 55 points. That’s unacceptable. So, while Owen is solid, the unit as a whole needs to improve. That’s the trend we need to see.

Amanda: Right. Individual brilliance can’t mask systemic failures. So, who’s trending down? Anyone?

Paul: The offensive line, frankly. They need to wake up. If they don’t, it’s going to be a long season. And maybe some of the younger receivers who didn’t contribute much against Baylor need to prove they belong.

Amanda: Solid take. So, to recap: Boley and Harris are up, the O-line is down, and we’re waiting for a running back breakout. What’s our prediction for the Hawaii game?

Paul: I’m sticking with my previous prediction. Arizona State wins 28-21. Boley throws for two touchdowns, and the defense finally creates a turnover or two. It’s not a blowout, but it’s a win.

Amanda: I’m with you. 28-21. It’s a must-win situation for ASU’s morale and playoff hopes. They can’t afford another loss. Hawaii is manageable if they fix their issues.

Paul: Agreed. Fix the protection, find a running game, and keep the defense focused. Then you have a shot. It’s not guaranteed, but it’s possible.

Amanda: There you have it, Sun Devil fans. Roster battles are heating up, and the stakes have never been higher. From the O-line struggles to the QB competition, every snap matters now. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Sun Devil. Let’s keep the momentum going. Go Devils!