Mailbag: Boley's Air Raid vs. Baylor, Harris's Breakout, and Hawaii Hopes

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-07 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Cutter Boley threw for over three hundred yards, Reed Harris turned into a legitimate big-play threat with one hundred twenty-five receiving yards, and the defense still gave up fifty-five points. If you missed it, this was not just another loss—it was a masterclass in how quickly momentum can evaporate in the Big 12.

Paul: It’s a tough pill to swallow, Amanda. We talked about the pass protection issues on Tuesday and Wednesday, but seeing DJ Lagway pick apart that secondary with four touchdowns really highlighted where the gaps are. It’s not just bad luck; it’s schematic and execution.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, home of the daily Arizona Sun Devil breakdown. I’m Amanda, and alongside me is our lead analyst Paul. Today is a mailbag episode, so we’re diving straight into your questions about the 2-2 record, the sixth-place standing in the Big 12, and what comes next against Hawai'i.

Paul: We’ve got a lot to unpack. First, we’re looking at whether Cutter Boley’s performance was enough to mask the defensive collapse. Second, we’re talking roster battles—specifically who wins the running back workload against the Rainbow Warriors. And finally, we’re answering if ASU can actually bounce back from this blowout.

Amanda: Before we get into Segment One, quick shout-out to everyone listening during their morning commute or evening drive. If these daily breakdowns help you stay sharp on the Sun Devils, a small contribution via the link in the episode description keeps this show free and running every single day. Thanks for supporting us.

Amanda: Let’s jump right in. Marcus in Phoenix sent us a question asking, 'With the team sitting at 2-2 and sixth in the Big 12, is this season already slipping out of control, or is there a realistic path to bowl eligibility?' That’s the big picture question.

Paul: It’s a fair concern, Marcus. Sixth place in the Big 12 isn’t ideal, but let’s look at the context. We lost to Baylor by thirty-six points, which is an outlier. But we’re still two games above .500. The key is how we handle the bubble watch narratives ESPN is pushing right now.

Amanda: Right, because ESPN has headlines up about College Football Playoff projections and bubble watch after Week 5. Does ASU even have a shot at that conversation?

Paul: Not right now. Not after giving up fifty-five points. But being 2-2 means you’re not eliminated. The path forward is strictly about winning the close ones and avoiding these lopsided defeats. Against Hawai'i, who is 1-4, this is a must-win game for morale, even if it doesn’t help the playoff odds.

Amanda: Okay, Sarah from Tempe wants to know specifically about Cutter Boley. She says, 'Boley threw for 304 yards and a touchdown against Baylor. Was that a good game for him, or did the loss make it irrelevant?' How do you grade his individual effort?

Paul: I think it was a solid individual performance, Sarah. Thirty-four completions out of forty-three attempts is high efficiency. He found Reed Harris for 125 yards, which is huge. But he also had one interception, and more importantly, the offensive line couldn’t keep him upright long enough to sustain drives.

Amanda: So the stats are good, but the situational football was bad. That ties into what we discussed last week about pass protection. Did Boley have time to throw those four-touchdown passes for Lagway? No, obviously not.

Paul: Exactly. DJ Lagway threw for 306 yards too, but he connected on four touchdowns. The difference was tempo and pressure. When Boley gets hit behind the line of scrimmage, the offense stalls. We saw that with Kyson Brown only getting seven carries for thirty-four yards. You can’t run the ball effectively when you’re down by double digits.

Amanda: @SunDevilFan99 asks, 'What happened to the defense? Owen Long had fourteen tackles, which is impressive, but how do you explain allowing fifty-five points?' Is this a coaching issue or a talent issue?

Paul: That’s the million-dollar question. Owen Long playing well is a bright spot—he was all over the field. But the coverage schemes broke down repeatedly. Lagway targeted Gavin Freeman for 115 yards and Tony Livingston for a touchdown. These aren’t hidden talents; they made plays because the leverage was wrong.

Amanda: It feels like every time we watch film, it’s the same story: great individual hustle, systemic breakdowns. Devon Jordan had eleven tackles for Baylor, but the secondary was getting burned deep. Do we need a coordinator change, or is this just growing pains?

Paul: I don’t think it’s a coordinator change yet. It’s about adjustment. You give up a sixty-three-yard run to Ryelan Morris, and then you’re chasing the game. The defense needs to create turnovers. We said earlier that creating more turnovers against weaker opponents like Hawaii is critical. If you don’t stop the bleeding, no amount of individual tackling saves you.

Amanda: Stick with us. We’re going to break down the depth chart and answer more of your questions about who is stepping up on the offensive side of the ball. Don’t go anywhere.

Amanda: Welcome back. We’re moving into Segment Two, where we tackle the roster and depth chart. Chris from Gilbert asks, 'Who is winning the running back competition right now? Kyson Brown had only thirty-four yards against Baylor. Is David Avit or Jason Brown Jr. ready to take over?' This is a hot topic.

Paul: Great question, Chris. Let’s look at the roster. We have Kyson Brown, David Avit, Jason Brown Jr., Marquis Gillis, and Cardae Mack. Against Baylor, Kyson was limited to seven carries. That’s not necessarily a reflection of his ability, but rather the game script. When you’re trailing by thirty-six, you don’t pound the rock.

Amanda: But does that mean we see a timeshare? Who do you want to see get the touches against Hawai'i?

Paul: I’d love to see David Avit get some work. He’s been on the roster longer and offers a different physical profile. Jason Brown Jr. is also a factor. The goal here is to establish the run to take pressure off Cutter Boley. If ASU can run the ball effectively, they keep DJ Lagway-style defenses honest. But against Hawai'i, who is 1-4, we should be able to find some rhythm.

Amanda: Lisa in Scottsdale wants to know about the wide receiver room. Reed Harris had 125 yards, but what about Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., or Omarion Miller? Are any of them emerging as consistent targets?

Paul: Reed Harris is clearly the top option right now. His 125 yards against a tough Baylor defense is significant. Omarion Miller caught a thirty-yard touchdown pass from Boley, so he’s a red-zone threat. But consistency is the issue. We need Derek Eusebio, Jalen Klemm, and Uriah Neloms to step up as reliable hands.

Amanda: And the offensive line? That seems to be the biggest headache. Luke Baklenko, Tana Alo-Tupuola, Desean Bryant Jr.—are they holding up? Paul, you mentioned pass protection earlier.

Paul: They struggled significantly against Baylor. Daniel Cobbs got a sack for Baylor, and the pressure was constant. We need better alignment and communication. Brent Helton and Wade Helton are veterans who should be stabilizing the unit. If they can’t protect Boley, the passing game collapses. This is the number one priority for practice this week.

Amanda: Marcus in Denver asks, 'Where does Cameron Dyer fit in now? He’s listed as a QB behind Boley. Is there any chance he sees action against Hawai'i?' Fans are worried about Boley’s health given the pressure.

Paul: Cameron Dyer is the backup, and Jake Fette is also on the roster. Pauly Keene is there too. Right now, Boley is the starter. Unless he gets hurt or completely loses command of the offense, Dyer won’t play. The coaching staff needs to trust Boley to manage the game. But having a competent backup is crucial for depth.

Amanda: Sarah from Mesa wonders about the tight ends. Khamari Anderson, James Giggey, AJ Ia—are they contributing enough? Reed Harris is getting the glory, but do the TEs provide value in the passing game?

Paul: James Giggey and Kristian Ingman are active players. They need to be used more in the short area. Against Baylor, the middle of the field was open at times, but the protection didn’t hold up long enough to exploit it. If the O-line improves, the TEs become viable check-down options. It’s all interconnected.

Amanda: Let’s keep going. We’ve got one more segment coming up with some fun hypotheticals and lightning round takes. Stay tuned.

Amanda: Welcome back to Segment Three. Let’s start with a hypothetical. If ASU could magically fix ONE thing before Saturday night against Hawai'i, what would it be? Paul, you’re up.

Paul: Pass protection. It’s non-negotiable. If Cutter Boley has two seconds more in the pocket, he makes better decisions. He throws fewer interceptions, and the offense stays on the field. Fix the line, and the rest of the offense clicks into gear.

Amanda: Agreed. Now, lightning round. First question: Who is the most underrated player on this roster? Give me a name.

Paul: Owen Long. Fourteen tackles against Baylor is massive. He’s everywhere. Without his leadership in the middle, that defense looks even worse.

Amanda: Second question: What is your prediction for the score against Hawai'i? We talked about this before—we predicted a 28-21 win. Do you still stand by that?

Paul: I do. Hawai'i is 1-4. They’re vulnerable. If ASU runs the ball effectively and limits turnovers, 28-21 is a very reasonable projection. Boley throwing for two touchdowns is also likely if the protection holds.

Amanda: Final question: What is the one word that describes the current state of the Sun Devils? Go.

Paul: Resilient. They’re 2-2. They haven’t quit. They need to bounce back, but the foundation is there if they fix the fundamentals.

Amanda: That’s all the time we have for today. We covered the Baylor loss, Cutter Boley’s stats, Reed Harris’s breakout, and the road ahead to Hawai'i. Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Paul: If you enjoyed this mailbag, please subscribe, rate, and review. Share it with your fellow Sun Devil fans. Let’s keep the community strong.

Amanda: And remember, if you want to support this daily content, check out the link in the episode description. Every bit helps keep us on the ground covering the team you love.

Paul: Go Sun Devils!