Film Room: ASU's Offensive Bright Spots vs Baylor Defensive Woes

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-10-06 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Reed Harris for 125 yards. Cutter Boley for 304. But the score was 55-19. How do you reconcile those two realities on film?

Paul: You don't, Amanda. Not really. You look at the tape and you see a talented offense that simply couldn't stop DJ Lagway from throwing four touchdowns while the defense collapsed under pressure.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, home of the Arizona State Sun Devils daily show. I’m Amanda, joined by Paul. We are breaking down the film from Saturday’s brutal loss to Baylor. Today, we’re doing what we should have done immediately after the whistle blew: we’re looking at the individual performances. We’ll start with the offensive bright spots that kept us in it for three quarters, then dissect the defensive failures that allowed Baylor to run away with it, and finally, a deep dive into Owen Long’s tackle count and what it means for the Hawaii game.

Paul: That’s right. We predicted a 31-24 win last week. We predicted zero interceptions from Cutter. Instead, we got a 55-19 rout. The film doesn't lie, even if the projections did. Let’s get into Segment One: What the tape showed on offense.

Amanda: Okay, Paul, let’s start with the one thing that actually worked. Reed Harris. Seven receptions, 125 yards. That is a standout performance against a Big 12 secondary. When you watch the tape, what stands out about his route running?

Paul: It’s his separation. Against Baylor’s coverage, Harris wasn’t just running routes; he was manipulating leverage. On that 30-yard touchdown catch to Omarion Miller later, Harris drew the double team, which opened up the middle. But individually, his release off the line was clean. He didn’t get jammed. That allowed him to gain depth quickly before the cornerbacks could close the gap.

Amanda: And Cutter Boley? He finished with 304 passing yards, but also one interception. Remember our prediction? Zero turnovers. This stings.

Paul: It does. And when you look at the interception, it wasn’t a bad throw. It was a decision. He was reading a Cover 2 shell, saw the safety rotate over top, and tried to fit the ball into a window that wasn’t there yet. He forced it. But overall, his mechanics were solid. His 25-of-43 completion percentage shows he was efficient enough. The issue was the context—he was playing from behind because of the defensive collapse.

Amanda: So, was the offensive line the problem? We talked about pass protection last episode as a critical weakness. Did they hold up against DJ Lagway’s pressure?

Paul: They held up... mostly. C.J. Fite got one sack, which is a positive in a game where you give up sacks. But look at the hurries. Lagway had time to step up and find Tony Livingston and Louis Brown IV. The protection scheme was okay, but it wasn’t disruptive. If ASU wants to compete against Hawaii, who is 1-4, we need to generate more pressure. Right now, we’re allowing too much time for opposing quarterbacks to make plays.

Amanda: Kyson Brown only had seven carries for 34 yards. The ground game was non-existent. Does that worry you heading into next week?

Paul: It absolutely worries me. When you’re down 30 points, teams stack the box. But even early on, the running lanes weren’t opening. David Avit and Jason Brown Jr. are on the roster, but Kyson was the primary guy. If the offensive line can’t create vertical seams, the play-action game dies. And without play-action, Cutter becomes one-dimensional. That’s how you get intercepted.

Amanda: Alright, take a breath. Before we move to the defense, I want to check in with you all. If this breakdown helped you understand why the offense looked so disjointed despite the yardage numbers, consider supporting the show. Your contribution keeps this analysis free and daily. Just click the link in the episode description to help us keep bringing you the truth, not just the headlines. Thanks for listening.

Amanda: Let’s talk defense. Because honestly, this is the story of the game. DJ Lagway threw for 306 yards and four touchdowns. How did that happen? Where did the coverage break down?

Paul: It was a combination of poor leverage and missed assignments. Look at the first touchdown to Tony Livingston. It was a quick slant. The safety was late rotating, and the cornerback gave up inside leverage. Lagway exploited that seam instantly. Then you have the 63-yard run by Ryelan Morris. That’s not a coverage bust; that’s a tackling bust. The edge defender missed his assignment, letting Morris turn the corner.

Amanda: Wait, crowd cheer for a 63-yard run by the opponent? I think you mean crowd groan here, Paul!

Paul: Exactly. A massive groan. That play killed the momentum. Once Baylor scored that touchdown, the Sun Devils’ defense looked defeated. They stopped communicating. By the fourth quarter, it was just guys trying to make plays instead of executing the scheme. Gavin Freeman caught seven passes for 115 yards. He was all over the field because ASU couldn’t contain his release.

Amanda: What about the pass rush? Daniel Cobbs got one sack for Baylor. Was there any disruption from C.J. Fite or the other linemen?

Paul: Fite got one, which is good. But it wasn’t consistent. Lagway had time to reset his feet multiple times. In the Big 12, if you don’t generate pressure, you’re going to get burned. The linebackers were also slow to react to screen passes. We saw it on the second touchdown. The offensive line pulled, and the linebackers didn’t fill the gap fast enough. It’s a technique issue.

Amanda: Owen Long had 14 total tackles. That’s a huge number. Is that a sign of a good player, or is it a sign that the defense was out of position constantly?

Paul: Both. Owen Long is a hard worker, and he made the tackles he had to make. But 14 tackles in a 55-19 loss usually means your teammates aren’t getting stops. He was cleaning up messes. Devon Jordan for Baylor had 11 tackles, and they won comfortably. So, yes, Long played well individually, but the unit failed collectively. The secondary needs to work on their communication. The blitz packages weren’t confusing Lagway enough either.

Amanda: So, what’s the fix? Do we change the personnel, or do we change the calls?

Paul: I’d say change the calls first. You have the talent. You have players like Long who can fill gaps. You need to simplify the coverage for the young backs in the secondary. Don’t ask them to do too much. Play more base man coverage and rely on your front seven to generate pressure. If you can get C.J. Fite and others to disrupt the pocket consistently, Lagway won’t have time to hit those deep balls to Freeman.

Amanda: Let’s pivot to Segment Three. One deep-dive player. I want to talk about Cutter Boley again. He threw for 304 yards, but also an interception. What does this performance tell us about his development as a quarterback in the Big 12?

Paul: It tells us he has the arm talent and the processing speed, but he lacks discipline in high-leverage moments. The interception came when he was frustrated. He tried to force a throw into tight coverage rather than checking down to Kyson Brown or Reed Harris. In college football, especially in the Big 12, you cannot be reckless. But I also give him credit for the 304 yards. He adapted to the defense. He recognized the blitzes and adjusted his protections.

Amanda: He also connected with Omarion Miller for a 30-yard touchdown. That was a key drive. Did the receiving corps help him out?

Paul: Yes. Reed Harris was the clear No. 1 option. But Omarion Miller made the big play when it mattered. The connection between Boley and Miller shows trust. If they can build that rhythm, the offense will be dangerous. The issue is consistency. You can’t have 304 yards and then lose by 36. The offense needs to protect leads better.

Amanda: Looking ahead to Hawai'i, who is 1-4. Do we expect more of the same? Or does the team bounce back?

Paul: I expect a bounce back. Not a blowout win, but a competitive game. Hawaii struggles on defense. If ASU can improve pass protection—like we’ve said for weeks—and limit turnovers, Cutter can exploit their secondary. The key is the running game. If they can establish Kyson Brown or David Avit, it opens up the play-action. Without it, they’re just throwing into traffic.

Amanda: So, predict a score for me. Given the film review we just did.

Paul: I’m going to say ASU wins 28-21. They fix the protection issues, Boley throws for two touchdowns, and the defense gets a crucial turnover. It’s not a dominant win, but it’s a necessary one to stay relevant in the Big 12 standings.

Amanda: 28-21. I’ll take that. Paul, thanks for breaking down the tape with me. For our listeners, if you enjoyed this deep dive into the film, please subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen. It helps us reach more Sun Devil fans.

Paul: Agreed. Keep your eyes on the pass protection metrics next week. That’s where the game will be won or lost.

Amanda: Hawaii is coming to Tempe on October 11th. Let’s go Suns! Beatline out.