Amanda: Reed Harris caught seven balls for one hundred and twenty-five yards. Cutter Boley threw for three hundred and four. And somehow, Arizona State still lost by thirty-six points. The final score was fifty-five to nineteen against Baylor on Saturday night, and if you watched that game, you know this wasn’t just a loss—it was a collapse.
Paul: It is hard to look at the box score and reconcile the individual brilliance with the team result. DJ Lagway had four touchdowns. He moved all over the field. Meanwhile, our offense had only one touchdown of their own. It was a complete mismatch in every phase except Reed Harris's hands.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we break down the Big 12, one game at a time. I’m Amanda, and I’m joined by Paul. We are coming off a brutal prediction from Wednesday. We said ASU would win thirty-one to twenty-four. We said Boley would throw for one-fifty. We said he’d win the turnover battle. Instead, he threw one interception and got sacked enough to make your eyes water.
Paul: I am not proud of those predictions, Amanda. But as analysts, we have to live with them. Today, we are reacting to the reality. We are looking at why the offensive line couldn’t handle Baylor’s pressure, why the defense gave up six-three runs, and what this means for the rest of the season.
Amanda: Here is what we are covering today. First, we dissect the offensive failure—specifically Cutter Boley’s efficiency numbers versus the lack of execution. Second, we talk about the defensive breakdowns and the few bright spots like Owen Long’s tackle count. And third, we look ahead to next week’s home game against Hawai’i. Can they bounce back? Let’s get into it.
Amanda: Let’s start with the obvious. Cutter Boley finished twenty-five out of forty-three for three hundred and four yards. One touchdown, one interception. In previous weeks, we praised his efficiency. Tonight, it looked like he was playing chess while Baylor was playing checkers. What did you see out there?
Paul: The volume was there, but the context was terrible. Thirty-four rushing attempts combined for Kyson Brown and the rest of the backs yielded only thirty-four yards. That is exactly one yard per carry. When you can’t run the ball, you put an immense burden on the quarterback to be perfect. Boley wasn’t perfect. He had to bail out the protection scheme repeatedly.
Amanda: And when he did get time, he connected with Reed Harris like nobody else could. Seven receptions, one hundred and twenty-five yards. That was arguably the best receiving performance in the Big 12 this week. Why couldn’t that translate to more points?
Paul: Because Baylor’s secondary played bump-and-run leverage so tightly on Harris that Boley had to hold the ball too long. Every time Boley held it, Daniel Cobbs or another rusher came free. You saw C.J. Fite get one sack for us, which is great, but we allowed DJ Lagway to operate with zero real pressure. Lagway went twenty-five for forty for three hundred and six yards and four touchdowns. That is not a quarterback problem; that is a structural problem.
Amanda: Four touchdowns from Lagway. Tony Livingston, Louis Brown IV, Hawkins Polley. They hit different targets everywhere. Boley’s lone touchdown went to Omarion Miller on a thirty-yard pass. It was a nice play, but it felt like a drop in the bucket compared to what Baylor was doing. Did the offensive scheme fail, or did the players fail to execute?
Paul: I think it was both. The scheme tried to keep up with the passing rate, but without a running game, the play-action was dead on arrival. Kyson Brown had seven carries for thirty-four yards. David Avit and Jason Brown Jr. barely touched the ball. When you go one-dimensional in the Big 12, defenses will stack the box and then double-team your best receiver. Harris got single coverage sometimes, but mostly he had to fight through jams because the threat of the run wasn't real.
Amanda: It’s frustrating because we talked about Boley’s efficiency last week. He looked poised against Kansas. Against Baylor, he looked rattled. The interception probably killed any chance of momentum. Where did that happen?
Paul: It happened in the red zone. When you’re trailing early and desperate, you force the issue. Boley tried to fit the ball into tight windows rather than taking the check-down. It’s a coaching decision too—if the running game isn’t working, do you change the personnel grouping? Do you go empty backfield? Or do you stick with the same plays hoping they work? They stuck with it, and it cost them.
Amanda: So, we’ve got a quarterback who threw for over three hundred yards but lost by thirty-six. A receiver who dominated his matchup but couldn’t carry the team. How do you feel about the offense going forward?
Paul: You have to simplify it. You have to establish the run, even if it’s ugly. You have to protect Boley better. If the offensive line doesn’t fix its pass protection schemes, no amount of individual talent will matter. This was a schematic blowout.
Amanda: Stick with us. After the break, we’re talking about the defense, Owen Long’s solo efforts, and whether the special teams can actually help this team survive the rest of the season.
Amanda: We are back. Let’s talk defense. Because if the offense was bad, the defense was catastrophic. Fifty-five points allowed. DJ Lagway throwing four touchdowns. Ryelan Morris running for eighty-four yards and a touchdown. What went wrong?
Paul: Leverage. Poor leverage. On the sixty-three-yard touchdown run by Ryelan Morris, the defensive ends didn’t contain the edge. He broke outside, and there was no one there. In college football, when you give up a sixty-three-yard run, you have blown the assignment completely. It’s not a missed tackle; it’s a missed assignment.
Amanda: And the passing defense? Gavin Freeman had seven catches for one hundred and fifteen yards. Tony Livingston, Louis Brown IV, Hawkins Polley—all scoring. Did the linebackers get burned?
Paul: The linebackers were trying to cover zones but couldn’t read the quick slants. Lagway was hitting the seams instantly. Our safeties weren’t helping down enough, which left the cornerbacks in man coverage with no help. It’s a recipe for disaster when you allow a quarterback to pick apart your secondary at will.
Amanda: Okay, let’s find some positives. Owen Long had fourteen total tackles. That is huge. C.J. Fite had a sack. Isaiah Marshall, we mentioned him in the preview, how did he fare?
Paul: Isaiah Marshall struggled. He got beaten on the outside a couple of times. Long was the engine. Fourteen tackles shows he was everywhere, trying to clean up messes that shouldn’t have happened in the first place. If Long has ten more tackles, maybe the scoreboard looks slightly less embarrassing, but the damage was done before he could get to the ball.
Amanda: What about special teams? Carson Smith kicked a forty-six-yard field goal and a thirty-two-yard field goal for us. Rhett Armstrong kicked the extra point for the other score. Did the kicking game save us at all?
Paul: Smith was solid. Forty-six yards is a reliable leg. But special teams can only do so much when the offense is punting after three plays. The return game wasn’t highlighted in the stats, but generally, when you’re down by thirty-six, you aren’t getting many opportunities to shift momentum with a big return.
Amanda: So, we have a defense that needs to tighten up its assignments, a secondary that is getting exposed, and an offense that is one-dimensional. Who steps up in the roster battles? Do we need to see more from the backups?
Paul: The offensive line needs to step up. Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, Desean Bryant Jr.—they need to communicate better on blitz pickup. DJ Lagway had way too much time. If the interior line doesn’t handle the stunts, Boley is going to get hit every time. It’s a fundamental issue.
Amanda: Fundamental issues. That’s a harsh way to put it, but accurate. We predicted Boley would win the turnover battle. He didn’t. We predicted a win. He didn’t. Is there hope for the next game?
Paul: Hope is cheap. Execution is expensive. They need to execute better. Next week is Hawai’i. It’s a home game. Home fields are supposed to be an advantage. If they don’t come out with discipline, this record goes to one-and-three very quickly.
Amanda: We’ll see. Before we head to the final segment, I want to take a quick moment to talk about this show. We put out fresh, daily analysis on every Big 12 game, breaking down the tape, the stats, and the strategy. It takes a lot of work to keep this network running every single day. If you love college football and want to help us keep this content free for everyone, please consider chipping in. Just use the link in the episode description. Your support makes this possible.
Amanda: Alright, let’s look ahead. Next up: Hawai’i Rainbow Warriors. October 11th. Home game. What does ASU need to do to beat them?
Paul: Control the clock. Run the ball. Stop guessing what Boley wants to do and start establishing a ground game. Kyson Brown needs touches. David Avit needs touches. Get the running backs involved early. If you fall behind again, you’re going to face the same problems.
Amanda: Defense needs to stop giving up big plays. No more sixty-three-yard runs. No more easy touchdowns. Lay out the film from Saturday and tell the players: this is not acceptable. Can they turn it around?
Paul: They can. But they have to want it more. Discipline wins games. Efficiency wins games. Right now, ASU is playing with emotion, not structure. They need to get back to basics.
Amanda: Basic fundamentals. High standards. Let’s hope the Sun Devils hear that loud and clear. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.
Paul: Great game, guys. Remember, subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go Sun Devils.
Amanda: That’s it for today. We’ll be back tomorrow with more Big 12 reaction. Keep cheering loud. See you next time!