Amanda: If you think a one-point lead in the Big 12 is safe, you haven't been watching college football long enough. The Sun Devils are sitting on top of the conference at 2-and-1, but Baylor is coming to Tempe with a chip on their shoulder and a 3-and-1 record. This isn't just another home game; it's a potential playoff preview.
Paul: It’s a clash of styles, Amanda. We’ve got the efficient, disciplined ASU offense led by Cutter Boley going up against a Baylor team that knows they need to win these tight matchups to stay relevant. The margin for error here is razor-thin.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily deep dive into the teams that matter. Joining me as always is our analyst Paul. Paul, we talked about this matchup yesterday and the day before—our prediction was still standing at 31-24 for ASU. Do you still feel good about that number?
Paul: I do. But let’s be clear: this won’t be a blowout. It’ll be a defensive grind. If ASU controls the line of scrimmage and keeps Isaiah Marshall off the big play, the Sun Devils hold on. But if Marshall gets comfortable, things get messy fast.
Amanda: So here is what we are tackling today. First, we’re breaking down the biggest storyline: can ASU maintain their first-place status against a hungry Baylor squad? Second, we’re looking at the key players, specifically Reed Harris and the defensive front featuring Owen Long and C.J. Fite. And third, we’re giving you our keys to victory and a bold prediction for Saturday night. Let’s get into it.
Amanda: Let’s start with the matchup itself. Arizona State just pulled out a gritty 24-17 win over Kansas last week. That wasn’t pretty, but it kept them undefeated in conference play. Now they have to turn around and face Baylor, who is also 3-and-1. What’s the immediate story here?
Paul: The story is sustainability. ASU beat Kansas largely because of special teams—Tate Nagy had two huge returns, including a 72-yard punt return touchdown. That’s exciting, but it’s not a reliable offensive strategy week-to-week. Against Baylor, who has a more disciplined defense than Kansas did, ASU can’t rely on trick plays to win.
Amanda: Right. You don’t build a championship season on a 72-yard punt return. They need Cutter Boley to execute the actual offense. Remember, Boley went 11-for-23 for 95 yards against Kansas. That’s efficient, but it’s low volume. Can he handle the pressure Baylor brings?
Paul: He has to. Baylor’s defense is physical. They aren’t going to give up easy completions like Kansas did. Boley needs to make quicker decisions. In that Kansas game, he only threw for 95 yards because the run game and special teams carried the load. Here, if Kyson Brown doesn’t find consistent running lanes, Boley will be forced into third-and-long situations where Baylor thrives.
Amanda: So the burden shifts to the running game. Kyson Brown had 81 yards on 24 carries against Kansas. That’s a tough yardage average. Is the offensive line actually opening holes, or is it just grind-it-out football?
Paul: It’s grind-it-out. Look at the personnel. You’ve got guys like Luke Baklenko and Tana Alo-Tupuola on the interior. They’re capable, but they’re not dominating yet. To move the ball against Baylor, ASU needs to use play-action more effectively. If they keep pounding the rock without threatening the deep middle, Baylor’s linebackers will stack the box and make life miserable for Boley.
Amanda: That’s the risk. If the play-action isn’t working, the quarterback gets pressured. We saw David Santiago get one sack against Kansas. Imagine what Baylor’s pass rush can do if Boley is holding the ball too long. This feels like a game where turnover margin decides everything.
Paul: Exactly. Turnover margin. We predicted Boley would win the turnover battle last time, and I stand by that—but only if he protects the football. He threw no picks against Kansas, which is great, but he also didn’t create many explosive plays. Baylor is betting that ASU will try to match their scoring output through special teams and short passes, and then capitalize on a mistake.
Amanda: So the narrative is: ASU must avoid relying on luck and instead execute fundamentals. If they do that, they win. If they slip up, Baylor takes over. Let’s talk about the weapons. Reed Harris caught four passes for 48 yards and a touchdown against Kansas. Is he the primary target here?
Paul: He’s certainly the most proven weapon right now. We mentioned him in our previous episode as someone who should see increased usage due to favorable coverage matchups. Against Kansas, Nahzae Cox struggled to contain ASU’s receivers consistently. Harris is physical after the catch. If Boley can get him the ball in space, he can break tackles.
Amanda: And what about Jaren Hamilton? He had that 100-yard kickoff return against Kansas. Does he factor into the passing game as well, or is he mostly a splash threat on returns?
Paul: Hamilton is a vertical threat. If Baylor sits back in coverage trying to stop Harris, Hamilton becomes the check-down option who can turn a short gain into a big play. But again, it depends on Boley getting the initial read open. If the first two options are covered, does Boley trust Hamilton to make a play in traffic?
Amanda: That’s the question. Trust. Because if the offense stalls, the defense has to carry the weight. And that brings us to the other side of the ball. Owen Long had 12 tackles against Kansas. That’s a massive workload. Can he sustain that energy against Baylor’s attack?
Paul: Owen Long is the heartbeat of that defense. Twelve tackles is high, but it shows he’s all over the field. Baylor isn’t going to go away from the run early. They’ll test the edges. Long will be tasked with setting the edge and filling gaps. If he misses a tackle or gets blocked out of position, Baylor moves the chains.
Amanda: And C.J. Fite? He got a sack against Kansas. Is he the primary disruptor up front?
Paul: Fite is definitely the name to watch. One sack against Kansas is a good sample size, but against Baylor, he’ll likely face double teams. If ASU can generate pressure with just three or four men, Long and the secondary can play freer. If they have to blitz constantly, they leave vulnerabilities in the intermediate zones.
Amanda: So we have the offensive efficiency debate, the special teams reliance, and the defensive pressure points. It’s a lot to manage in one weekend. Let’s zoom in on the individuals who could make or break this game. Who are the players we need to watch beyond Boley and Harris?
Paul: I want to talk about Isaiah Marshall for Baylor. He went 17-for-33 for 235 yards against Kansas. That’s solid efficiency. He threw one pick, but he also had a 72-yard touchdown pass to Tate Nagy. Marshall is calm in the pocket. He doesn’t force throws into tight windows unless he sees them.
Amanda: So how does ASU defend him? Dylan Edwards ran for 89 yards for Baylor. Does Marshall lean on Edwards early to set up play-action?
Paul: Absolutely. Marshall and Edwards form a dangerous duo. If ASU’s defensive ends, like maybe someone from that OL lineup we discussed earlier, lose leverage, Edwards cuts inside. But more importantly, Marshall uses the run to fake the handoff and hit the flat. Tate Nagy is his security blanket. If ASU ignores Nagy, Marshall will exploit it.
Amanda: This sounds familiar. Last week, ASU’s defense held up well until the special teams gave up big plays. Now we’re worried about Marshall finding rhythm. Are there any injury concerns we need to address for either side?
Paul: From the data available, there are no reported injuries for ASU heading into this game. That’s huge. It means Cutter Boley, Kyson Brown, and Owen Long are all available. For Baylor, we don’t have specific injury reports, but Marshall played through some contact against Kansas. His health is critical.
Amanda: Okay, so full strength for ASU. That helps. Let’s look at the receiving corps depth. Besides Harris and Hamilton, we have Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., and Derek Eusebio on the roster. Could one of them step up if Harris is doubled?
Paul: Derek Eusebio has the size to win contested catches. If Baylor sends extra help at Harris, Eusebio might be the guy to win those 50-50 balls in the red zone. But honestly, the biggest X-factor is the offensive line cohesion. If Luke Baklenko and Matai Jefferson can create even a half-second of extra time, Boley can hit Eusebio or Harris in stride.
Amanda: Half a second is an eternity in this league. But if the O-line collapses, Boley gets sacked. We saw C.J. Fite get pressure, but what about the other side? Who is helping Fite?
Paul: It’s usually a group effort. The defensive ends need to squeeze the edge to force the quarterback to step up into the lane. If the ends flare wide, the interior linemen like Fite have a clear path. It’s about gap discipline. If everyone stays in their assigned zone, Marshall has nowhere to go.
Amanda: Gap discipline. That’s the buzzword of the week. Okay, Paul, we’ve analyzed the strengths, the weaknesses, the players, and the injuries. Now, let’s get to the brass tacks. What are the keys to the game for Arizona State? How do they actually win this thing?
Paul: Key one: Establish the run early. Kyson Brown needs to get 15-plus carries and find at least two runs of 10+ yards. If ASU can’t run, Marshall will sit back in coverage and pick apart the secondary. Control the clock, control the game.
Amanda: Agreed. Key two: Protect the football. No turnovers. Boley’s job is to be smart, not heroic. Check down, throw it away, take the three points. Don’t try to be Isaiah Marshall and launch deep bombs into triple coverage.
Paul: And for the defense? Key three: Limit the big play. Baylor has speed. Tate Nagy and Dylan Edwards are explosive. If ASU allows a 40-yard completion or a 30-yard run, the game swings. Stay disciplined in coverage. Don’t bite on play-action fakes.
Amanda: So, run the ball, protect the rock, and no big plays allowed. It sounds simple on paper, but executing under pressure is another story. Let’s wrap this up with a bold prediction. We said 31-24 before. Still feeling that?
Paul: I am sticking with 31-24, but I’m adjusting the way it happens. I think ASU wins the turnover battle decisively. I predict Cutter Boley throws zero interceptions and forces at least one takeaway from Isaiah Marshall. That margin wins the game.
Amanda: Bold. Zero picks for Boley. That’s a high bar. But if the offensive line holds and Owen Long keeps stuffing the run, it’s possible. Before we go, I want to ask you directly. If this episode helped you understand the stakes better, or if you enjoyed the breakdown of Boley and Harris, please consider supporting the show. It’s the best way to ensure we can keep bringing you free, daily content like this. Just head to the link in the episode description to chip in. Every bit helps keep the network alive.
Amanda: We’ve broken down the ASU-Baylor matchup, highlighted the key players like Reed Harris and Owen Long, and set our prediction at 31-24. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Please subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Sun Devil fan!
Paul: Stay tuned for post-game analysis. Go Sun Devils.
Amanda: And that’s a wrap. See you next time on Beatline.