Amanda: You can keep your predictions. You can keep your 31-24 forecasts. Because if you think Arizona State is just coasting into this Baylor matchup, you haven’t been paying attention to what’s happening in Tempe. We are live on the Beatline Podcast Network, and I’m Amanda, here with Paul.
Paul: And I’m Paul. Look, we’ve talked all week about Cutter Boley’s efficiency and Kyson Brown’s ground game. But when you look at the tape against Kansas, there were moments that told us exactly how much grit this team has. Tonight, we’re breaking down the biggest storylines for Saturday’s Big 12 showdown.
Amanda: Here is the roadmap for today. First, we’re looking at the matchup angles—how ASU’s defense handles Isaiah Marshall and the Baylor passing attack. Second, we’re diving into the key players, specifically Reed Harris and the offensive line’s role in protecting Boley. And finally, we’re giving you our keys to the game and a bold prediction for the final score. Let’s get into it.
Paul: So, Amanda, we start with the opponent. Baylor comes in at 3-1, and they’re coming to Tempe. The headline here is obviously the quarterback duel, but tactically, I’m more interested in how ASU handles the run. Kansas tried to chew clock with Dylan Edwards, who had 89 yards on 18 carries last week. That’s not a lot of volume, but it’s efficient.
Amanda: Right. And Owen Long was everywhere last week with 12 total tackles. He’s the heartbeat of that defense. If Baylor wants to establish any kind of physical presence early, they have to go through Long. But what about the pass rush? C.J. Fite got one sack against Kansas, but Isaiah Marshall was pretty loose in the pocket for parts of that game.
Paul: Exactly. Marshall finished 17-of-33 for 235 yards and a touchdown, but he also threw an interception. That’s the thing about Marshall—he’s accurate, but he can be reckless. If ASU’s defensive front can keep him in the box, force him to make quick reads, you might see more pressure. The issue is the offensive line. Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko did a good job last week, but Baylor’s front seven is different from Kansas’s.
Amanda: Wait, hold on. You’re saying the O-line struggled? No, actually, Cutter Boley only took a few hits. He went 11-of-23 for 95 yards. It wasn’t a spectacular day statistically, but it was a win. They scored 24 points. So why are you worried about the protection now?
Paul: I’m not worried about the past, Amanda. I’m worried about the future. 95 passing yards is fine when you have special teams scores. Tate Nagy returned a punt 72 yards for a touchdown. Jaren Hamilton returned a kickoff 100 yards. That’s 20 points right there from non-offensive plays. Against Baylor, you can’t rely on that kind of luck twice in a row.
Amanda: That is a fair point. The special teams were electric. But if the offense stalls, does Boley have the arm talent to move the ball downfield? He connected with Reed Harris for a 25-yard touchdown, but his other completions were short. Is that a limitation of the receiver group, or just conservative play-calling?
Paul: It’s a mix. Reed Harris is a possession receiver. He’s reliable, but he’s not going to beat you deep every time. You’ve got Chance Ables and Cory Butler Jr. out there too, but Harris is the security blanket. When Boley throws deep, it’s usually because the coverage breaks down. Against Baylor, if they play tight man coverage on Harris, Boley needs to hit the intermediate seams.
Amanda: So, the storyline is clear: ASU can’t lean on special teams alone. The offense needs to put up consistent numbers. And that brings us to the second segment. We need to talk about the personnel. Who are the guys we need to watch on Saturday night?
Paul: Let’s start with the running back room. Kyson Brown had 24 carries for 81 yards against Kansas. That’s three-point-four yards per carry. It’s not explosive, but it’s sustainable. He didn’t fumble. He picked up first downs. In the Big 12, you don’t need 100-yard games every week; you need consistency.
Amanda: But wait, isn’t David Avit healthy? And Jason Brown Jr.? If the backfield is crowded, does that dilute the effectiveness? Last week, it was just Kyson doing the work. What happens if Baylor focuses on stopping the run and forces Boley to throw?
Paul: That’s the risk. If AVit and Jason Brown Jr. are available, they provide depth, but Kyson has the touch. He knows how to find the daylight. The real key here is the tight end spot. Khamari Anderson and James Giggey. If Baylor sends extra help to stop the run, those TEs become the safety valves. Boley needs to be comfortable hitting them over the middle.
Amanda: And on the other side of the ball, we have to talk about Isaiah Marshall again. He’s the Baylor QB. He’s 17-of-33, which is decent efficiency, but he threw an INT. How do you defend a guy who’s accurate but prone to mistakes?
Paul: You bait him. You let him take the check-downs. You play soft zones in the middle of the field, daring him to throw over the top. If he tries to be heroic, he’ll make a mistake. Taylor Davis had 8 tackles for Kansas, so he’s busy. If ASU’s linebackers, led by Owen Long, can fill gaps quickly, Marshall won’t have time to look downfield.
Amanda: So, speed and discipline. Don’t bite on the play-action. That makes sense. Now, injuries. The brief says no new injuries reported since the Kansas game. Does that mean everyone is cleared to go?
Paul: As far as we know, yes. No injury reports listed for either team post-Kansas. That’s huge for ASU. If their offensive line is at full strength, they have a better chance to control the tempo. A healthy line means fewer blitzes get home, and Boley has more time to read the coverage.
Amanda: Okay, so we’ve got the matchup, the key players, and the injury picture. We’re heading into the final segment. This is where we give you our keys to the game. What does ASU need to do to stay at 3-1 and keep that first-place standing?
Paul: Key number one: Turnover margin. We predicted last week that Boley would win the turnover battle. He didn’t throw any picks against Kansas, which was crucial. Against Baylor, you have to protect the football. Marshall threw an INT. If ASU can force another one, the game changes completely.
Amanda: Agreed. Turnovers are everything in the Big 12. Key number two: Time of possession. If Kyson Brown can keep the chains moving, Baylor’s offense stays on the sideline. You don’t want Isaiah Marshall having the ball for 35 minutes. Keep them off the field.
Paul: And key number three: Third-down conversions. Kansas only gave up a few big plays, but ASU needed those special teams scores to close the gap. Against Baylor, if you go three-and-out on offense, you’re in trouble. Boley needs to convert those medium-length third downs to keep the drive alive.
Amanda: Alright, Paul. We’ve laid out the keys. We’ve talked about the players. Now, give me the bold prediction. Remember, we said 31-24 last week. Are we sticking with that, or is the weather in Tempe going to change things?
Paul: I’m sticking with it. 31-24. The offense will score enough. Boley will have a slightly better day, maybe hitting 150 yards as we discussed earlier. Reed Harris will secure more receptions because Baylor will have to double-team him, opening up the deep shots for Chance Ables.
Amanda: Bold call! But I love it. Before we go, I need to ask you something important. We’ve built this network to be free, with no ads and no paywall, because we believe great sports content should be accessible to everyone. But keeping the show daily, with high-quality analysis like this, costs money. If you value these previews and breakdowns, please consider supporting us. Just click the link in the episode description to help keep the Beatline Podcast Network free and thriving.
Amanda: Thank you so much for listening. We’re predicting a 31-24 victory for the Sun Devils. Make sure you subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen to your podcasts. Share this episode with your friends!
Paul: Go Sun Devils. See you next week.