Amanda: They said it was a fluke. They said London was a one-off. But look at the standings, folks. Arizona State is sitting pretty at 2-1, and they are the undisputed kings of the Big 12.
Paul: It’s not just a fluke, Amanda. It’s efficiency. Cutter Boley didn’t put up huge yardage numbers against Kansas, but he made the critical plays when the defense was breathing down his neck. That’s how you win on the road.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily dose of college football truth. Paul is here with me, and we are diving deep into the Sun Devils’ path forward.
Paul: Good to be here. And yeah, the playoff picture is starting to sharpen. We’ve got bubble watch conversations happening all over ESPN right now, and ASU is firmly in that conversation.
Amanda: Here is what we are tackling today. First, we’re looking at the division rivals and what those headlines mean for Tempe. Second, we’re breaking down exactly how this roster stacks up against Baylor’s 3-1 record. And third, we’re talking about what outside results need to happen for these guys to keep their first-place standing.
Paul: And don’t forget, we’re checking in on our predictions from last week. Did we get that Baylor game right? Let’s find out.
Amanda: We are live. Let’s get into it.
Amanda: Okay, Paul, let’s talk about the landscape. The headlines are everywhere. ESPN is running bubble watches after Week 4, and there’s a lot of noise about who gets in and who stays out. How does Arizona State fit into this chaos?
Paul: The noise is real, Amanda. But look at the data. You have teams like Ole Miss with Trinidad Chambliss making Heisman cases, which is distracting the eye from solid conference contenders. For ASU, the key is staying within their own conference bubble.
Amanda: Right, because if you lose focus on the next guy in line, you fall behind. And the next guy is Baylor. They come to town on October 3rd at 10:30 PM EDT. They’re 3-1. That’s a tough test.
Paul: Exactly. Bill Connelly has ranked the top 10 College Football Playoff games, and a matchup between a 2-1 ASU team and a 3-1 Baylor team feels like it’s heading toward that elite tier of intrigue. It’s not just about winning; it’s about *how* you win against a peer.
Amanda: So, the division rival angle is crucial here. If ASU drops this, the Big 12 lead evaporates. If they win, they extend it. But what about the other teams? Are there any surprise upset projections coming out of Week 4 that hurt us?
Paul: The bowl projections are shifting rapidly. With some big upsets happening around the league, the margin for error in the Big 12 is razor-thin. But honestly, the biggest threat to ASU isn’t an external upset—it’s internal consistency. Can Cutter Boley replicate that London performance?
Amanda: That’s the question. He went 11 for 23 for 95 yards and a touchdown against Kansas. It wasn’t flashy, but it was effective. Now, facing Baylor, can he keep that efficiency up while dealing with a different defensive scheme?
Paul: It’s about protection. If the offensive line holds up, Boley makes decisions faster. If they break down, we see more sacks, and Isaiah Marshall showed Kansas how to pressure a quarterback effectively. David Santiago had one sack for them, but the scheme did the heavy lifting.
Amanda: So, the headline takeaway is that ASU is on the bubble, but in a good way. They are controlling their own destiny in the Big 12, provided they don’t get distracted by the national Heisman chatter or the playoff predictor algorithms.
Paul: Precisely. They are the team to beat in the division right now. But beating Baylor is the test that proves it.
Amanda: Before we dive deeper into the film, I want to take a quick second to ask for your help. This show runs on community support. Your contributions directly fund the daily research, the editing, and keeping the feed running so we can bring you this analysis every single day. If you love the Sun Devils, please chip in via the link in the episode description. Every bit helps keep the music playing.
Paul: Alright, let’s look at the roster. We talked about depth before. Against Baylor, who is stepping up? We know Kyson Brown had 81 rushing yards on 24 carries against Kansas. Is that enough to move the chains against a 3-1 Baylor defense?
Amanda: It’s a volume carry situation. 24 times is a lot. But look at the receiving corps. Reed Harris had four catches for 48 yards and a touchdown. Dylan Edwards had 89 rushing yards for Kansas, but Nahzae Cox only had two receptions for 68 yards. So, if ASU focuses on Harris, can Baylor contain him?
Paul: This is where our prediction comes in. We said back on Monday that Reed Harris would secure more receptions against Baylor due to favorable coverage. Looking at Baylor’s secondary, if they try to double-team someone else, Harris wins the matchup. He’s the safety valve for Boley.
Amanda: And what about the other receivers? Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., Jaren Hamilton. Hamilton had that 100-yard kickoff return in London. Does that speed translate to the passing game against Baylor?
Paul: Hamilton is a weapon in space. If Baylor plays tight coverage on Harris, you throw it to Hamilton on a slant or a screen. That’s leverage. That’s situational football. You don’t just throw it downfield; you exploit the void left by the deep safety.
Amanda: So, the offense looks balanced. Boley is efficient, Brown is grinding it out, and Harris is the primary target. But what about the defense? Owen Long had 12 tackles against Kansas. Taylor Davis had eight for Kansas. Who wins the middle of the field?
Paul: Long is a machine. Twelve tackles is a high number, especially if he’s filling gaps consistently. Baylor has Isaiah Marshall under center. Marshall went 17 for 33 for 235 yards, but he also threw an interception. If ASU’s front seven, led by C.J. Fite who had a sack, can keep Marshall in the pocket, he makes mistakes.
Amanda: C.J. Fite getting that sack is huge. It shows that the pass rush can generate pressure without needing to blitz constantly. That allows the linebackers like Long to flow to the ball.
Paul: Exactly. And don’t forget the offensive line. Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, Desean Bryant Jr.—these guys are the unsung heroes. If they protect Boley for five seconds, the play develops. If they hold for three, it’s a sack or a hurried throw.
Amanda: So, the roster depth is holding up. We aren’t seeing injuries slowing us down. Everyone from the starters to the backup QBs like Cameron Dyer is ready. This feels like a team that peaked at the right time in London.
Paul: It does. But remember, Baylor is 3-1. They haven’t lost yet. This isn’t a trap game; it’s a quality match. ASU needs to bring their A-game, not just their London A-game.
Amanda: Let’s talk about the bigger picture. The Allstate Playoff Predictor is out there. What does it say about Arizona State? Are they a lock, or are they hovering near the edge?
Paul: The predictors are always lagging indicators. They look at past performance. ASU’s win over Kansas was a road win against a tough opponent. That weighs heavily. But the bubble watch articles suggest that one loss can knock you out of the mix entirely.
Amanda: So, what outside results need to happen? If ASU beats Baylor, do they need other Big 12 teams to lose?
Paul: Ideally, yes. If ASU wins, they go to 3-1. If other contenders drop a game, ASU extends their lead. But realistically, ASU just needs to win their games. The Big 12 is wide open. There’s no dominant super-team yet.
Amanda: That’s exciting. It means every game matters. The Week 3 projections showed some big upsets. If ASU keeps winning, they become the team everyone wants to beat.
Paul: And that’s the pressure. Being first in the standings puts a target on your back. Baylor will come in hot. They want to dethrone the kings. ASU has to be ready for that energy.
Amanda: We predicted 31-24 for this game. We predicted Harris would have more catches. Do we stand by that?
Paul: We do. The math checks out. Boley’s efficiency plus Harris’s matchup advantage equals a Sun Devil victory. It won’t be easy, but it will be decisive.
Amanda: Alright, fans, that’s the plan. Beat Baylor, stay first, and keep the playoff dream alive. What do you think? Can ASU pull off the 31-24 win?
Paul: I’m sticking with the Sun Devils. They’ve shown grit, efficiency, and special teams brilliance. Tate Nagy and Jaren Hamilton set the tone, and the offense will follow.
Amanda: Thanks for listening to the Beatline! Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Sun Devil fan. Go Devils!