Amanda: You just won twenty-four to seventeen in London against Kansas. You are sitting first in the Big 12. But if you think Cutter Boley has it locked down until November, you haven't been watching the practice squad tape.
Paul: Exactly. The headline is the win, but the story is the depth chart shaking up behind the starting quarterback and the wide receiver corps that’s about to get crowded. We are breaking down exactly where the roster battles stand right now.
Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, Arizona State fans! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily dive into the Sun Devils. Joining me as always is our lead analyst, Paul. Paul, we talked about Baylor last week, predicted a thirty-one to twenty-four win, and we’re still standing tall at two-and-one.
Paul: We are. And honestly, looking at the film from Kansas, the margin for error was razor-thin. Cutter threw for ninety-five yards on twenty-three attempts. That’s not a volume stat line, but it was efficient. One touchdown, no turnovers. But let’s be real—ninety-five yards doesn’t tell the whole story of how the offense functioned when things got tight.
Amanda: Right, because when the pocket collapsed, who stepped up? Or did they? Today, we are doing a deep dive into the roster battles. We’ve got three segments. First, the quarterback room is heating up. Second, the wide receiver war for snaps with Reed Harris leading the pack. And third, we are predicting the final roster cuts and who is trending up or down heading into the Baylor game.
Paul: And before we get into the nitty-gritty of personnel groupings and depth chart hierarchies, I want to take a quick second for our community. This show is free, with absolutely no ads and no paywall, because we believe Sun Devils football should be accessible to everyone. Your support keeps us going daily. If you can chip in to help keep the show free and ad-free, please check the link in the episode description. It means the world to us.
Amanda: Okay, let’s start with the big one. Quarterback. Cutter Boley had a solid day against Kansas, but he only completed eleven passes. Is he the unequivocal starter, or is Cameron Dyer breathing down his neck?
Paul: Cutter is the starter. No question. But Cameron Dyer is not just a backup; he is a legitimate threat in the scout team and potentially in mop-up duty. The battle isn't really about who starts Week 4 against Baylor. The battle is about who stays healthy and who can execute the read-option elements if Boley gets bogged down by pressure.
Amanda: Wait, so you're saying the competition is internal? Because Jake Fette and Pauly Keene are also on the roster. Isn't there more pressure than just Dyer?
Paul: Jake Fette and Pauly Keene are developmental arms right now. They are likely redshirting or handling specific package plays. The real conversation is Boley versus Dyer. Boley showed poise in London. He took a hit, reset, and found Reed Harris for that twenty-five-yard touchdown. That’s clutch playmaking.
Amanda: But look at the stats. Ninety-five passing yards. That feels low for a team trying to make a playoff push. Don't you worry about the offense becoming too one-dimensional?
Paul: It wasn't one-dimensional because of the running game. Kyson Brown carried it twenty-four times for eighty-one yards. And let's not forget Cutter added a one-yard touchdown run himself. So yes, he ran. But the passing efficiency was key. He didn't force throws into coverage. He managed the game.
Amanda: So, if Boley goes down, does Dyer come in and immediately change the dynamic? Or is he more of a traditional drop-back passer like Cutter?
Paul: That’s the danger for opponents. If Dyer comes in, you have to respect his legs more. Boley is a dual-threat guy, but Dyer tends to extend plays differently. If the offensive line struggles against Baylor’s front seven, having a backup who can scramble out of trouble is huge. So, the battle is less about 'who is better' and more about 'who fits the emergency plan.'
Amanda: I love that perspective. It’s not just about talent; it’s about scheme fit. Okay, moving on to the receiving corps. Reed Harris had four catches for forty-eight yards and a touchdown. Jaren Hamilton had that epic hundred-yard kickoff return, but he’s listed as a WR. Where does he fit?
Paul: Jaren Hamilton is a special teams ace first, but don't sleep on his receiving upside. He’s fast. He’s explosive. Against Kansas, he might not have seen many targets, but against Baylor, you need that speed on the outside to stretch the field horizontally. The battle here is between Harris, Hamilton, and guys like Chance Ables or Derek Eusebio.
Amanda: Chance Ables? I haven't heard much about him yet. Is he a freshman? A transfer? What’s his role?
Paul: Ables is a depth piece right now. He’s competing for slot minutes. Reed Harris is the clear number two behind whoever is number one, but the slot is a crowded battlefield. Cory Butler Jr., Omarion Miller, Uriah Neloms—they are all fighting for those crucial third-down conversions. Baylor will try to cover Harris, so you need someone else to step up.
Amanda: So, Harris is safe, but everyone else is playing for their lives? That sounds intense.
Paul: In college football, it always is. One bad drop, one missed block, and you’re riding the bench. That’s why depth matters. If Harris gets injured, who is next? That’s the question coaches are asking every single day.
Amanda: Let's stick with that theme. We mentioned the slot battle, but what about the running back room? Kyson Brown had eighty-one yards, but Jason Brown Jr. and David Avit are also there. Is there a committee approach forming?
Paul: Kyson Brown is the workhorse. Twenty-four carries is a heavy load. But Jason Brown Jr. provides a different skill set—more power, maybe better in short yardage. David Avit is the change-of-pace guy. Against Baylor, you might see a split backfield. Keep Kyson in for the early downs, bring in Jason for the goal line. It’s about preserving Kyson’s legs for the fourth quarter.
Amanda: So, it’s not a battle for the starting job anymore; it’s a battle for roles. Got it. Let’s move to Segment Two. We talked about QB and RB. Now, let’s talk about the offensive line. With players like Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, and the Lapuaho brothers, how deep is this unit really?
Amanda: This is huge because Kansas only got one sack via David Santiago. That seems low for a Big 12 defense. Did the ASU O-line dominate?
Paul: They were disciplined. Not perfect, but disciplined. They kept the pocket relatively clean for Cutter. But look at the names. You have veterans like Luke Baklenko and younger talents like Desean Bryant Jr. The battle is on the edges. Wade Helton and Brent Helton are also in the mix. If an injury hits the tackle spot, do you go with experience or athleticism?
Amanda: The Helton twins! Both on the roster. That’s a family reunion on the offensive line. Who do you prefer, Wade or Brent?
Paul: I don’t have enough film on them individually yet to say definitively, but generally, in these situations, you go with who has the most reps. Wade Helton seems to be getting the nod in certain packages. But the interior line is where the real stability is. Matai Jefferson and Siosaia Lapuaho are anchors. If they hold up, the tackles have a chance to shine.
Amanda: Okay, let’s shift to defense. We know Owen Long had twelve tackles against Kansas. C.J. Fite had a sack. But who is battling for playing time on the defensive line? Hyrum Vaeono was mentioned in the headlines as rumbling toward the end zone. Is he a full-time starter?
Paul: Hyrum Vaeono is a force. When he’s healthy, he commands double teams. That frees up C.J. Fite to rush from the edge. The battle here is for rotational depth. You can’t play Vaeono every snap against a physical Big 12 offense. Who is next? There are bodies around him, but he sets the tone. If he slows down, the defensive line’s effectiveness drops significantly.
Amanda: So, the defensive line is relatively set at the top, but the depth is the concern. What about linebacker? Taylor Davis had eight tackles for Kansas, but who is covering for ASU? Is Owen Long the undisputed leader?
Paul: Owen Long is the heart of that defense. Twelve tackles is a massive workload. He’s everywhere. The battle is finding a reliable number two. You need someone who can fill gaps and tackle. If Long gets tired or hurt, the secondary starts to get exposed. It’s a chain reaction. Strong linebackers mean safer corners.
Amanda: That makes sense. Defense wins championships, right? And special teams has been huge for ASU lately. Tate Nagy had a seventy-two-yard punt return TD and a thirty-eight-yard catch. Jaren Hamilton had the kickoff return TD. Are they starters or special teams specialists?
Paul: Tate Nagy is a weapon. Thirty-eight yards on a catch shows he’s a legitimate receiving threat. Seventy-two yards on a punt return shows elite speed. He’s not just a specialist; he’s a playmaker who happens to excel in return games. Jaren Hamilton is similar. He’s a WR who brings special teams energy. These guys elevate the team’s identity.
Amanda: So, if Baylor tries to punts or kickoffs, they are in trouble. That’s a psychological advantage for ASU. Do you think other teams will start avoiding kicking to Nagy and Hamilton?
Paul: They’ll try. But you can’t hide from speed forever. Eventually, you have to put the ball in play. And when you do, you risk giving up sixty or seventy yards. That changes field position dramatically. It’s a strategic nightmare for opposing coordinators.
Amanda: Alright, let’s wrap up Segment Two with the kicking game. Carson Smith kicked a thirty-nine-yard field goal and Martin Connington handled kicks for Kansas. How confident are we in Carson Smith for the Baylor game?
Paul: Smith is reliable. Thirty-nine yards is a standard range kick. But in high-pressure moments, consistency is key. If the game is close, you want someone who never misses inside fifty. Smith has shown that. He’s steady. Unlike the chaos of returns, the kicking game needs calm. Smith provides that.
Amanda: Okay, Segment Three. Roster cuts. We have about a month before the season ends, but injuries happen. Who is trending UP on the roster right now based on the Kansas game?
Paul: Reed Harris is definitely trending up. Four catches, a touchdown, and he was the primary target in critical moments. He proved he can be trusted. Also, Owen Long. Twelve tackles is a statement. He earned his stripes. And Carter Boley, obviously, for managing the game without turning the ball over.
Amanda: And who is trending DOWN? Who needs to step up their game to keep their spot?
Paul: The backup receivers who didn’t see much action. Guys like Jeremiah Johnson or Plas Johnson. They need to show they can contribute in the slot or on special teams. If you aren’t making plays, you aren’t staying on the field. Depth is thin, so every rep counts.
Amanda: What about the offensive line backups? Are any of them in danger?
Paul: Niniva Nicholson and Manamo’ui Muti. They are depth pieces. If the starters stay healthy, they might not see much action. But if an injury hits, they need to be ready to go. Their training camp performance will determine their future here.
Amanda: Final prediction time. We said ASU beats Baylor 31-24. Do we stand by that? Or does the roster depth scare you?
Paul: I stand by it. The depth is adequate. The starters are playing well. Cutter Boley is efficient. Kyson Brown is grinding out yards. And the special teams are creating extra possessions. Baylor is good, but ASU is peaking at the right time.
Amanda: I agree. Plus, home field advantage in Tempe is real. The crowd will be loud. I predict ASU pulls away in the fourth quarter. Thirty-one to twenty-four. Maybe even higher if the special teams continue to dominate.
Amanda: There you have it, Sun Devil Nation! From the QB room to the receiver wars, we’ve broken down the roster battles that will define your season. Cutters holding steady, Harris shining, and the special teams setting the tone.
Paul: Stay tuned for the Baylor preview next week. We’ll dive deeper into their defensive schemes and how ASU can exploit them. Make sure you subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen. It helps us reach more fans.
Amanda: Thank you for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Go Suns!