ASU Roster Battles: QB Depth, RB Rotation & Who Makes the Cut

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-09-23 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Cut the tape. Look at the depth chart. One wrong rotation in the backfield or a hesitation on the snap and that Big 12 lead evaporates. We are talking about the razor-thin margins that define Arizona State’s season right now.

Paul: It’s not just about winning; it’s about who is standing next to you when the pressure hits. From Cutter Boley’s efficiency to the running back committee shaping up for Baylor, we’re breaking down exactly where the Sun Devils stand.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, your host for today’s deep dive into the Sun Devils. Joining me as always is Paul, our analyst who never lets a statistic go unchallenged. Let’s get straight into it.

Paul: Good morning, everyone. If you’re listening on your commute, grab your coffee. We’ve got three major roster battles to dissect after that London win over Kansas.

Amanda: Here is what we’re tackling today. First, Segment One: The Quarterback Room. Is Cutter Boley fully locked in, or is there pressure from Cameron Dyer and Jake Fette? Second, Segment Two: The Running Back Rotation. Kyson Brown had 24 carries against Kansas, but David Avit and Jason Brown Jr. are watching. Third, Segment Three: Roster Cuts. Who makes the final 53-man roster and who gets sent home? Stick with us.

Amanda: Let’s start with the most critical position group: Quarterback. Cutter Boley went 11-of-23 for 95 yards and a touchdown against Kansas. He also ran for one. It was efficient, mistake-free football. But looking at the roster, we have Cameron Dyer, Jake Fetter, and Pauly Keene behind him. Does this performance solidify Boley as the undisputed starter heading into Baylor?

Paul: Well, Amanda, 'undisputed' might be too strong a word if we’re talking about pure competition, but functionally? Yes. Boley didn’t turn the ball over. In the Big 12, especially against a defense like Kansas that can generate pressure, taking care of the football is the primary job description. He executed the game plan.

Amanda: But let’s look at the stats again. Ninety-five passing yards. That’s low volume. Did he struggle to find rhythm? Or was the offense just running through Kyson Brown heavily?

Paul: It wasn’t necessarily a struggle; it was situational football. When you’re leading in London, you run the ball. You control the clock. Boley made the reads he needed to make. He found Reed Harris for that touchdown pass. The issue isn’t Boley’s ability; it’s the offensive line’s consistency. If Tana Alo-Tupuola and Luke Baklenko hold up, Boley has time. If they don’t, even a backup looks bad.

Amanda: So, is the competition real? We have Cameron Dyer on the roster. What does he bring that Boley doesn’t? Is it mobility? Arm strength? Because if the coaching staff wants to change things up against Baylor, they need a clear reason.

Paul: Dyer brings a different skill set. Usually, dual-threat quarterbacks offer a change of pace. But here’s the nuance: if Boley is playing error-free football, why risk a turnover by bringing in a less experienced arm? Unless Baylor’s defensive scheme forces ASU to throw more than they rush, Boley stays. The depth chart is settled unless someone gets injured.

Amanda: That makes sense. No rocking the boat while you’re sitting first in the Big 12 at 2-1. But what about Jake Fetter? He’s on the roster too. Is he just there for special teams or emergency depth?

Paul: Fetter is likely emergency depth. You don’t carry three quarterbacks unless you expect injuries. The focus should be on Boley’s protection. If the OL struggles against Baylor’s front seven, then suddenly those other names become very relevant conversation points. For now, Boley is the guy.

Amanda: Agreed. Mistake-free wins games. And in London, Boley delivered. Let’s move to the backfield. Kyson Brown carried it 24 times for 81 yards. That’s heavy usage. With David Avit and Jason Brown Jr. waiting in the wings, how is this committee managed?

Paul: Eighty-one yards on 24 carries is roughly 3.4 yards per carry. That’s average, nothing spectacular. But it kept the offense alive. The question is sustainability. Can Kyson Brown handle that workload week after week? Against Baylor, we might see a split.

Amanda: I agree. You can’t burn out your feature back this early. But who takes the snaps if Kyson needs a break? David Avit or Jason Brown Jr.? There’s a name difference there—two Browns. How do coaches distinguish their roles?

Paul: Usually, it comes down to blocking versus receiving. If Jason Brown Jr. is better in pass protection, he stays in for third downs. If David Avit has more burst in the open field, he gets the early-down work. We saw Kyson take the bulk of the load because the game script favored running. Against Baylor, if they come out aggressive, we’ll see the rotation.

Amanda: And what about Marquis Gillis and Cardae Mack? They’re on the roster too. Are they purely special teamers, or could we see them in garbage time or specific packages?

Paul: Gillis and Mack are likely special teams contributors. You want fresh legs on punt returns and kickoffs. If ASU is protecting a lead, they might use them to keep the defense fresh. But in terms of offensive snaps, it’s mostly between Kyson, David, and Jason. The hierarchy is clear based on last week’s usage.

Amanda: So, no surprise changes there. Kyson remains the workhorse until he breaks or the coaches decide to rest him. Let’s talk receivers. Reed Harris had four catches for 48 yards and a touchdown. Jaren Hamilton returned a kickoff 100 yards for a TD and is listed as a WR. Where does Hamilton fit in the passing game?

Paul: Hamilton is an X-factor. His speed is undeniable. But catching passes requires route-running precision. We haven’t seen much of him in the passing game yet. Harris is the reliable option. He’s safe. Hamilton is the explosive play threat. If Boley trusts him, we could see more targets.

Amanda: Remember, we predicted earlier that Harris would see single coverage against Baylor. Does that mean Hamilton will be the safety valve? Or is he still developing his chemistry with Boley?

Paul: Chemistry takes time. Harris has been in the system longer. Hamilton is likely used as a decoy or on quick slants. Don’t expect him to be the primary target yet. But his presence opens up the field for Harris. Defenses have to respect the speed.

Amanda: What about the tight ends? Khamari Anderson, James Giggey, AJ Ia, Kristian Ingman, Anthony Miller, Landen Miree. That’s six tight ends on the roster. That seems like a lot. Why so many?

Paul: In modern college football, TE depth is crucial for both blocking and receiving. Giggey and Anderson are likely the top two. The others provide specific skills—maybe one is a blocker, another is a mover in the slot. It allows the OC to mix personnel without substituting excessively.

Amanda: So, it’s about versatility. Okay, let’s wrap up the battles. Who is trending up? Who is trending down? And who might be on the chopping block for the final roster cut?

Paul: Trending up: Owen Long. Twelve tackles against Kansas is dominant. He’s establishing himself as the defensive leader. Also, Tate Nagy with that punt return TD—he’s proving his value beyond special teams.

Amanda: I love that. Nagy is a fan favorite. Now, who is trending down? And who is fighting for their life to stay on the 53-man roster?

Paul: The QBs behind Boley are in danger if there’s an injury elsewhere. If a receiver or lineman goes down, a QB spot might be sacrificed. So Cameron Dyer and Jake Fetter are on thin ice. Also, any of the sixth-string TEs who didn’t show up in the box score against Kansas.

Amanda: That’s harsh but realistic. Football is a business. Performance dictates roster spots. What about the offensive line? We have Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, Desean Bryant Jr., Brent Helton, Wade Helton, Matai Jefferson, Terrell Kim, Jalen Klemm, Rob Lapuaho, Siosaia Lapuaho, Filiva'a Lokotui, Jarmaine Mitchell, Manamo'ui Muti, Niniva Nicholson. That’s fourteen offensive linemen!

Paul: Fourteen linemen! That’s a massive group. It suggests depth concerns or a desire to keep bodies fresh. The players who started or played significant snaps against Kansas are safe. The backups are fighting for every inch. If the line struggled in pass protection, some of those names might be vulnerable.

Amanda: So, the starters are locked. The question is who sits on the bench. For Baylor, ASU will need all hands on deck. If anyone gets hurt, the depth will be tested immediately.

Paul: Exactly. And that’s why Boley’s mistake-free game was so important. You don’t want to add to the injury list. Keep the body intact. Keep the roster stable.

Amanda: Alright, let’s recap. Boley is the clear starter. Kyson Brown is the workhorse, but expect a split against Baylor. Reed Harris is the primary target, with Jaren Hamilton providing speed. Owen Long and Tate Nagy are the stars of the week.

Paul: And remember, our prediction stands: ASU beats Baylor 31-24. The offense will find its rhythm, and the defense will contain Isaiah Marshall.

Amanda: If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or your commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Please check the link in the episode description to support the show. Your contribution helps us keep delivering free, high-quality analysis every single day.

Paul: We appreciate every listener. Stay tuned for the Baylor preview next week. Go Devils!

Amanda: This is Amanda and Paul signing off from the Beatline Podcast Network. See you next time!