ASU Mailbag: London Success, Heisman Talk & The Baylor Preview

Arizona State Sun Devils · 2026-09-22 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Two special teams touchdowns in London. A dominant defensive showing from Owen Long. And Cutter Boley finally playing mistake-free football to top Kansas 24-17. If you missed the magic at Wembley, you are in for a treat today.

Paul: It was a statement win. But now we have to look ahead. We’re sitting at 2-1, first in the Big 12 standings, and the pressure is mounting as we prepare for Baylor next week.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, your lead host, joined by analyst Paul. This is the Arizona Sun Devil Show. Today, we’re opening up the mailbag. We’ve got questions about Reed Harris’s future, the depth chart battles at running back, and whether ASU can keep this momentum going against a tough Baylor squad.

Paul: We’re going to break down the film from that London game, answer your toughest roster questions, and then get into some fun hypotheticals. Let’s dive right in.

Amanda: First question comes from Sarah in Tempe. She asks: 'Cutter Boley threw for only 95 yards against Kansas. Is he a viable Heisman candidate now, or should we be worried about his ceiling?'

Paul: Sarah, let’s be clear here. Heisman conversations are usually about volume and highlight reels. But looking at the box score, Boley went 11 of 23 for 95 yards with one touchdown and zero turnovers. That is efficient, not flashy.

Amanda: Right, and remember, we had him facing a Kansas defense that included David Santiago getting sacks and Isaiah Marshall throwing an interception. It wasn’t a wide-open passing clinic.

Paul: Exactly. And look at the context. Kyson Brown carried it 24 times for 81 yards. Reed Harris caught four passes for 48 yards and a score. The offense was balanced. Boley didn’t need to throw for 300 yards because the ground game and special teams did the heavy lifting.

Amanda: So, is he a Heisman threat? Maybe deep down the line if they start scoring more points, but right now, he’s the engine, not the fireworks. Ole Miss’ Trinidad Chambliss is getting all the headlines for the Heisman race this week.

Paul: And rightfully so. But for ASU, Boley’s job is to protect the football. Remember our prediction before the Texas A&M loss? We said eliminate turnovers. He did exactly that against Kansas. No interceptions, no fumbles. That’s the foundation for a playoff run.

Amanda: Next question is from @SunDevilFan99 on Twitter. They ask: 'Reed Harris had four catches for 48 yards. Isn’t that below his usual output? Did the Kansas defense key in on him specifically?'

Paul: @SunDevilFan99, great question. Actually, looking at the coverage, Kansas focused heavily on limiting the big play. Nahzae Cox only had two receptions for 68 yards. So the secondary was tight.

Amanda: But wait, Paul. In our last episode, we predicted Harris would see more single coverage against Baylor because everyone will respect Kyson Brown. Do you still stand by that?

Paul: I do. Against Kansas, they played physical because they knew Boley was trying to establish rhythm. Against Baylor, if they try to double-team Brown again, Harris will have room to operate. He scored a touchdown on that 25-yard pass from Boley. That’s a clutch play.

Amanda: Speaking of clutch plays, let’s talk about the special teams. Jaren Hamilton returned a kickoff 100 yards for a touchdown. Tate Nagy returned a punt 72 yards for another score. Are these flukes or a system change?

Paul: Not flukes. Look at the personnel. Hamilton is a former track star. His speed is elite. Nagy has been developing his return skills all season. This isn’t luck; it’s coaching and talent aligned perfectly.

Amanda: Martin Connington handled the kickoffs and punts, and Carson Smith nailed the field goals. This team is scoring everywhere. But here’s a concern from Mike in Phoenix: 'With so many players contributing, who is the actual leader on this team?'

Paul: Mike, that’s a vital question. On defense, Owen Long had 12 tackles. He’s the heartbeat. Offense, Boley and Brown are the focal points. But honestly, the coaches seem to be promoting a committee leadership style. It keeps the locker room loose.

Amanda: Okay, we’ll leave it there for the first segment. Stick with us after the break, we’re diving into the depth chart battles at running back and receiver.

Amanda: Welcome back. Let’s get into the nitty-gritty of the roster. First question is from Jessica in Chandler. She asks: 'Kyson Brown had 24 carries for 81 yards. Is Jason Brown Jr. or David Avit ready to take over if Kyson gets tired or injured?'

Paul: Jessica, good point. Looking at the full roster, you have Jason Brown Jr., David Avit, Marquis Gillis, and Cardae Mack. It’s a crowded backfield.

Amanda: But against Kansas, Kyson was the workhorse. Why not use the others more?

Paul: Because Kyson provides consistency. 24 carries is a lot. You don’t want to burn out your starter early. But for Baylor, if the game script opens up, expect Jason Brown Jr. to see more snaps. He brings a different skill set—more elusive, maybe better in space.

Amanda: And what about David Avit? He’s listed as a RB on the roster. Does he offer anything specific?

Paul: Avit is more of a receiving threat out of the backfield. If ASU goes to a spread formation to counter Baylor’s defense, Avit could be the check-down option for Boley. It’s about situational football.

Amanda: Alright, moving to receivers. Chris in Scottsdale asks: 'Reed Harris is clearly the number one target. But where does Jaren Hamilton fit in now that he’s also a kickoff returner? Does he lose snaps on offense?'

Paul: Chris, excellent observation. Hamilton is listed as a WR, but his primary value right now is special teams. However, he caught a touchdown pass. That shows he’s still part of the offensive scheme.

Amanda: So, he’s a dual-threat weapon. What about the rest of the group? We have Chance Ables, Cory Butler Jr., Derek Eusebio, Harry Hassmann, Jeremiah Johnson, Plas Johnson, Jalen Klemm, Omarion Miller, Uriah Neloms, and Jalen Moss.

Paul: That’s a huge group. For Baylor, the key is getting Harris isolated. If they double-team him, someone like Derek Eusebio or Harry Hassmann needs to step up. They’ve been practicing hard. You can feel the energy in the facility.

Amanda: Let’s talk about the offensive line. Tana Alo-Tupuola, Luke Baklenko, Desean Bryant Jr., Brent Helton, Wade Helton, Matai Jefferson, Terrell Kim, Jalen Klemm, Rob Lapuaho, Siosaia Lapuaho, Filiva'a Lokotui, Jarmaine Mitchell, Manamo'ui Muti, and Niniva Nicholson. Who is holding the line together?

Paul: The OL protected Boley well enough, allowing only one sack from David Santiago. That’s impressive against a Kansas front that was hungry. The continuity between the guards and centers is crucial. If they maintain their blocks, Boley has time to find those open receivers.

Amanda: One last question for this segment from @ASUFanatic in Los Angeles: 'Owen Long had 12 tackles against Kansas. Is he the Defensive Player of the Year candidate?'

Paul: He’s definitely in the conversation. 12 tackles is a massive number. He was everywhere. If he can replicate that against Baylor, ASU’s defense will be unstoppable. It’s a strong case for DPOY.

Amanda: We’ll come back with the final segment after this short break. Don’t go anywhere.

Amanda: We’re back for our final segment. Let’s get into some fun hypotheticals and quick takes. First up: If ASU were to face Alabama in a neutral site bowl game right now, based on this current roster, who wins?

Paul: Oh, that’s a tough one. ASU is 2-1 and flying high. But Alabama has more depth. However, if Cutter Boley plays clean and the special teams continue to score, ASU has a shot. It’s all about execution.

Amanda: I’d say ASU wins 28-24. The momentum is real. Now, lightning round. Who is the most underrated player on the roster?

Paul: Carson Smith. Kicking field goals under pressure is an art. He’s reliable.

Amanda: Who is the biggest X-factor for the Baylor game?

Paul: Tate Nagy. His punt return ability changes field position instantly. One big play can swing the whole game.

Amanda: Final prediction: Will ASU beat Baylor?

Paul: Yes. 31-24. We’ve said it before, and we mean it. The defense holds strong, and the offense finds another way to score.

Amanda: There you have it, fans. From London glory to a Big 12 lead, the Sun Devils are on fire. We answered your questions about Boley, Harris, and the depth chart. Thanks for listening.

Paul: Remember, support is what keeps this show free and daily. Your small contribution helps fund the research, editing, and keeping the feed running every single day. Please chip in via the link in the episode description.

Amanda: We appreciate you more than you know. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go Sun Devils!